Science Fiction: A Definition | Jorge Luis Borges | Karel Capek | Anthony Boucher | Minorities and Civil Rights in mystery fiction | W. E. B. Du Bois | Rokheya Shekhawat Hossain | Charlotte Perkins Gilman | R.A. Lafferty | Ray Bradbury | Isaac Asimov | Cognition | Sir Thomas More | Georg Büchner | C. I. Defontenay | J.-H. Rosny aîné | Hugo Gernsback | Aleksandr Kuprin | Homer Eon Flint | Edmond Hamilton | Otto Binder | Nelson S. Bond | John W. Campbell | Arthur C. Clarke | Robert Heinlein | Rick Raphael | Cyril M. Kornbluth | Zenna Henderson | Alice Eleanor Jones | Robert Abernathy | Murray Leinster | Hal Clement | Cordwainer Smith | Charles L. Harness | Philip K. Dick | Edgar Pangborn | Fred Hoyle | Theodore L. Thomas | Walter M. Miller, Jr. | Silvina Ocampo | Stanislaw Lem | Liu Cixin | Ray Nelson | Avram Davidson | Ursula K. Le Guin | Roger Zelazny | Gene Wolfe | Edward Wellen | Vernor Vinge | Greg Bear | Paul Di Filippo | Iain M. Banks | Ted Chiang | Colson Whitehead | China Miéville | J.G. Ballard | Clifford D. Simak
Favorite Science Fiction and Fantasy Films: A List
Political and Social Commentary Tales in Comic Books. This list also tracks advanced civilizations in the future or outer space, high technology.
Plus my articles on science fiction comic books: Superman, Adam Strange, Mystery in Space, Strange Adventures, Strange Sports Stories, The Spacehawk.
The Case of the Baker Street Irregulars (1940) (Chapters 1-11, 14)
Nine Times Nine (1940)
The Case of the Solid Key (1941)
Rocket to the Morgue (1942) (first two days)
The Case of the Seven Sneezes (1942) (Chapter 1)
The New Adventures of Sherlock Holmes (written with Denis Green)
The Casebook of Gregory Hood (1946) (written with Denis Green)
The Sound of Detection: Ellery Queen's Adventures in Radio
The Compleat Werewolf
Mission of Gravity (1953)
The Collected Stories of Arthur C. Clarke
The Foundation Trilogy (1942 - 1950)
Pebble in the Sky (1950)
The Stars, Like Dust (1951)
The Caves of Steel (1953)
The Naked Sun (1956)
Lucky Starr and the Moons of Jupiter (1957)
Lucky Starr and the Rings of Saturn (1958)
The Gods Themselves (1972)
The Early Asimov
The Union Club Mysteries
The Best Mysteries of Isaac Asimov
The World Jones Made (1956)
The Man Who Japed (1956)
The Man in the High Castle (1962)
The Game-Players of Titan (1963)
Clans of the Alphane Moon (1964)
A Maze of Death (1970)
Our Friends from Frolix 8 (1970)
The Cyberiad (1965)
City of Illusions (1967)
The Left Hand of Darkness (1969)
The Dispossessed (1974)
The Wind's Twelve Quarters
A Fisherman of the Inland Sea
Four Ways to Forgiveness
The Last Defender of Camelot
The Drowned World (1961) (Chapters 1-3, 9)
The Crystal World (1964/1966) (Chapters 1-5)
Hello America (1981)
Empire of the Sun (1984)
Memories of the Space Age
Running Wild (1988)
Ring Around the Sun (1952-1953)
The Trouble with Tycho (1960)
Way Station (1963)
All Flesh Is Grass (1965)
Why Call Them Back From Heaven? (1967)
Worlds Without End
So Bright the Vision
The Worlds of Clifford Simak
All the Traps of Earth
Over the River and Through the Woods
The Civilization Game
Mystery short stories
M 33 in Andromeda
The Ring of Ritornel (1968) (Chapters 1-8)
An Ornament to His Profession
The Collected Stories of Vernor Vinge
Let's unpack this a little:
Good SF vs Bad SF. Unlike some of those definitions, mine is NOT an attempt to distinguish between good and bad science fiction, or to define goals toward which good science fiction should aspire. Instead, my definition simply seeks to distinguish science fiction from other kinds of literature, such as realism, fantasy or the supernatural.
Note: I very much agree that defining good science fiction is a worthwhile task. And that the definitions of people like Heinlein or Sturgeon that attempt to point to good science fiction make informative reading. My definition simply does not attempt to do this - instead, it tries to differentiate science fiction from other kinds of fiction.
Actual SF Tales and the Definition. Both the definitions in the Wikipedia article, and my own definition, reflect the common practice of numerous actual science fiction writers and their stories. These definitions are not, or at least not entirely, a priori prescriptions for how sf should be written. Instead, they reflect the underlying principles of countless real science fiction tales.
Obviously, there are worthwhile tales that say, mix science fiction and fantasy, and which thus do not conform to the above definition. So there are good stories that fall outside my definition, and most of the definitions in the Wikipedia.
But the big point: most good science fiction tales do conform to these definitions. Maybe at least 95% of the tales in the field. So such definitions are very much worth keeping in mind. They make explicit the ideas underlying most, although not quite all, of the successful stories in the sf field. (Ideas in the arts do not need to cover every artwork to have value. An idea, even if it has many exceptions, can illuminate big chunks of a field, and thus be useful and valid.)
The above definition works just as well for "literary" authors of science fiction, such as Karel Capek, Margaret Atwood or William S. Burroughs, as it does for genre writers like Asimov and Heinlein. Burroughs' book Nova Express very much deals with innovations like aliens invading Earth, and "word viruses". While its literary technique is highly experimental, its content is squarely within the boundaries of the above sf definition. Writers like Capek, Atwood and Burroughs clearly saw value in science fiction paradigms, and choose to write books with science fiction as the underlying principle.
Alternate Paths. Two kinds of fiction are often published as "science fiction", but do not correspond well with most definitions of science fiction, including mine:
It is not clear if such tales are "really" science fiction. Maybe they are actually separate, distinct genres.
Borges' first book of fiction was A Universal History of Infamy. This is a collection of brief, highly fictional biographies of real life criminals and adventurers. It has nothing to do with the Rogue tradition of Hornung and Leblanc. Instead, its tales unroll Borges' complex philosophical imaginings. Many of the tales are loaded with Borges' humor. The best of these 1933-1934 tales are included in the omnibus, Borges A Reader. Borges followed this collection in the 1940's with Ficciones, his greatest collection of stories.
By contrast, "Theme of the Traitor and Hero" is a triumph, a real detective story of the first water. It was made into a beautiful color film by director Bernardo Bertolucci, The Spider's Stratagem (1970), a gorgeous film that is like taking a vacation to Italy.
"Ibn Hakkan al-Bokhari, Dead in his Labyrinth" (1949) is full of vivid story-telling detail. Both in plot and style, the tale is a skillful pastiche of Chesterton. It has a fascinating central image of the labyrinth, and some not bad detective deduction at the end about the significance of a labyrinth. Unfortunately, the mystery plot as a whole is not that clever.
Six Problems for Don Isidro Parodi, Borges' collaboration with Adolpho Bioy-Casares, lies somewhere in the middle. Most of the problems are too contrived to make really good classical detective stories. Most of the stories also contain some real ingenuity, and the collection is very much worth reading.
Borges' writing shows the systematic, logical development of ideas found in Campbell writers of the "Golden Age" of science fiction. Borges is more of a Campbellian than is sometimes realized. Borges repeatedly expressed his admiration for H.G. Wells. Wells is the writer who most influenced Campbell and his authors.
Borges' "The Immortal" (1949) likely shows the influence of John W. Campbell's "Forgetfulness" (1937), a once-famous story. SPOILERS. There are broad similarities, with a huge advanced city, now deserted, and a group of primitive people nearby. Both stories contain a similar plot twist. Both stories have the hero exploring the city, entering by an obscure passageway.
Borges' An Introduction to American Literature (1967), written with Esther Zemborain de Torres, cites Van Vogt and Heinlein as outstanding science fiction authors. They were widely viewed in the 1940's as the two leading writers for John W. Campbell's magazine Astounding Science Fiction.
In addition are those Borges stories that deal with "everything": the concept of infinite collections of objects or ideas. These include "Funes, the Memorious" (1942) and "The Aleph" (1945). These two stories by contrast, take place in real neighborhoods in Buenos Aires. They feature characters who eventually encounter the infinite during their otherwise realistic daily lives. Borges' best story, "Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius" (1940) deals with not "everything", but almost everything: a whole planetful of information. It too has some authentic Buenos Aires atmosphere, and the striking contrast between the near-infinite and the everyday.
Some of Capek's tales in these collections are philosophical detective stories. "The Blue Chrysanthemum" is especially concerned with epistemology: how do we know things, learn things, acquire new knowledge. What limitations do we subconsciously impose on our search for truth? Capek's tale ingeniously explores the nature of such concepts. It reminds one somewhat of the philosophical tales of Borges.
"The Stolen Cactus" has some links to "The Blue Chrysanthemum". Both tales involve rare plants and plant collectors. The way the thief in "The Stolen Cactus" evades people's mental categories through disguise, is a bit linked to the epistemological concerns of "The Blue Chrysanthemum". This unexpectedly leads to a brief but interesting discussion of the nature of God, in "The Stolen Cactus", reminding us that Capek is the author of an sf tale about the Deity, The Absolute at Large.
Since the early scientific detective stories of Arthur B. Reeve and Cleveland Moffett, there has been an interest in the "word association test" and what it might reveal about our subconscious thoughts. "The Experiment of Professor Rouss" offers an interesting twist on this idea, one that combines satire with a genuine look at how the word association paradigm might break down.
Capek had a certain realism in his approach. His detectives tend either to be policemen, or ordinary people who take up amateur detection for the first time in their lives, as in "The Disappearance of an Actor". This last story is perhaps the closest Capek came to a conventional detective story; one is surprised that it has not been anthologized more often. The mystery in "The Disappearance of an Actor" is linked to what might loosely be termed the victim's mental makeup or world-view, giving the tale a bit of a cognitive or philosophical cast. "The Disappearance of an Actor" is a search for someone missing, linking it the searches for missing objects in Capek tales like "The Blue Chrysanthemum", "The Missing Letter", "The Stolen Cactus".
"The Receipt" is a nicely done old-fashioned detective story, in which clues found on a corpse are used to deduce the victim's identity. "The Receipt" anticipates "The Disappearance of an Actor", in that the sleuths have to reconstruct the mind-set and behavior of the victim and people the victim knew, to make progress and understand the crime. In "The Disappearance of an Actor" this is then used to develop a surprising mystery puzzle plot twist. By contrast, in "The Receipt" the reconstruction is used purely for purposes of trying to track down who the victim was. Both "The Receipt" and "The Disappearance of an Actor" also share imagery of a decayed corpse found long after a killing.
"The Poet" also deals with the police getting information to track down a crime. It explores different witnesses and their world views, and how this leads the witnesses to process information in different ways. This has philosophical and cognitive implications.
"The Orchestra Conductor's Story" develops a similar theme as "The Poet". In "The Poet", the creative poet "translates" everything he sees into modernist poetry. The conductor "hears" all the sounds around him as a form of music. And this awareness helps him understand things better than other people, even things said in other languages he doesn't speak. "The Orchestra Conductor's Story" is not constructed as a mystery story, though, unlike "The Poet".
"The Crime on the Farm" is a brief and mainly minor tale of murder without mystery or detection. Its most interesting part involves farm fields and the plants that grow on them, as well as the farmer's attitudes towards such fields. The tale's extensive plant imagery links it to Capek botany mysteries like "The Blue Chrysanthemum" and "The Stolen Cactus".
"The Fall of the House of Voticky" is a fair play mystery story, but one with an unusual structure. Capek's series sleuth policeman Dr. Mejzlik is asked to solve a mystery. But the mystery is a historical one. Events in the 1400's are known only from a few scraps of information; Dr. Mejzlik is asked to reconstruct them from these bits of knowledge. Dr. Mejzlik uses deduction, and also some guesswork he subjects to Occam's Razor. This whole structure for a mystery is highly unusual in detective fiction. The mystery involves a puzzle of who killed a certain victim and why. But it goes beyond that to the riddle of explaining all the confusing pieces of information about the case, and reconstructing now forgotten events.
Both intriguing and annoying are sketches in which Capek propounds a mystery, then fails to provide a solution. Such solutionless mysteries include: "Dr. Mejzlik's Case", "Footprints", "The Old Jailbird's Story". Capek tries to milk these situations for philosophical profundity, but mainly they seem a cheat. "Footprints" is a variation on a much better story Capek wrote earlier, "The Footprint" (1917), found in the collection Toward the Radical Center. "The Footprint" explores more possible solutions for its impossibility, before deciding that none of them would work. These ideas are interesting. Then, "The Footprint" suggests some non-trivial philosophical concepts. "The Footprint" does not concentrate on the alleged "ux-explainability" of the impossible footprint. Instead, it develops a metaphor about ideas are which are unconnected from the great bulk of other ideas, just as the mysterious footprint is not connected to a known cause.
"The Stolen Murder" is strikingly surreal, in its odd developments. An idea Capek uses was already in use in crime stories: for example in episode 5 of Les Vampires (1915-1916), a crime movie serial directed by Louis Feuillade. But Capek uses this idea to develop something original: a whole "collapse or transformation of reality". Actual reality, and how reality "officially" looks, become different, midway through the tale. Perhaps this relates a little bit to the cognitive ideas of "The Blue Chrysanthemum", where people have to think outside of standard categories.
"The Little Countess" is a burlesque of spy stories. But the details of the comic parody are also used to create a puzzle plot, mystifying the narrator and reader about what is going on. The narrator-sleuth goes through several stages in understanding the events.
Much of R.U.R. (Rossum's Universal Robots) satirizes industry and the industrial age. The robots are artificially made humans, created purely to be workers. And they are themselves designed according to industrial principles. They are what industry would design and manufacture, if it could replace human workers by a "better" product: better by the standards of modern factory production. Capek develops a large amount of science fictional detail in his picture of the robots, their origin, manufacture and behavior. And most of this detail is logically based in the values and needs of industrial manufacture.
Capek shows modern commerce leading to horrible, unexpected results. The robots are created by the methods and standards of industrial capitalism; they are made in huge numbers by inexorable demands of their economic impact - but everything leads to disaster. Reading the play today, it is hard not to think about global warning, and the economic forces that keep promoting it.
Capek returned to the theme of commerce as a powerful force running roughshod over humans values in other works. The short fantasy "The Five Loaves" (1937) in Toward the Radical Center satirizes commercial goals destroying Christian values. It is an imaginative and chilling tale.
None of the Boucher novels I have read, considered as fair play, puzzle plot detective stories, reach the heights of his mystery short fiction collected in Exeunt Murderers. These are general purpose mystery stories in the Ellery Queen tradition, not impossible crime tales, and are outstandingly plotted.
Boucher's short tales are persistent users of that EQ convention, the dying message. And variations on the dying message, in which the detective has to find hidden meanings or obscure clues, in a piece of text. These are not "dying" messages, strictly speaking, but are closely related.
Boucher is generally undervalued, both as a mystery writer and as a science fiction author. Many people in both fields think of him in his later years, when he functioned mainly as an sf editor and mystery critic. He left a reputation for both personal kindness and literary quality in these roles, with a special emphasis on the encouragement of new authors. Boucher was both the writing teacher and first publisher of Philip K. Dick, for example; Dick later dedicated his classic Ubik (1968) to Boucher's memory. But Boucher's well deserved reputation as an editor has obscured his earlier literary contributions.
Boucher had an influence on several later science fiction authors. His story "Barrier" (1942) sets forth the basic time travel scenario that will later underlay Isaac Asimov's The End of Eternity (1955). Boucher's mystery novel, The Case of the Baker Street Irregulars (1940), seems to be a key ancestor of Philip K. Dick sf stories where reality collapses. In Boucher's tale, which is not a science fiction story, characters get involved in many strange surreal adventures, that are later explained naturally as bizarre schemes of the villain. The "feel" is remarkably similar to Dick novels, such as the strange adventures of the hero in The Man Who Japed (1956).
Boucher's series detective Fergus O'Breen first appears in The Case of the Crumpled Knave (1939). This is a Golden Age novel that has everything but a really clever solution. It makes pleasant reading, till one reaches the end and discovers that there is nothing clever lurking behind all this development. Along the way there are numerous subplots focusing on the suspects. Boucher reveals that most of them are Not What They Seem To Be. This is a persistent plot gambit in his novels: Boucher will ring many changes on this theme throughout his books. Boucher includes some clever science fiction ideas in Chapter 7 of this book. This chapter also contains some of the running background information on playing cards and their collectors; more is found in Chapters 10 and 12. Boucher's novels have some Van Dine school characteristics. The settings are among the sort of intellectuals one often finds in Van Dine school writers: the playing card collectors in Knave, the mystery fans of Baker Street, the theater people in Solid Key. While Fergus O'Breen is technically a private eye, he is very intellectual, and falls into the tradition of genius amateur detective who works closely with the police. Boucher's investigations take place immediately after the crime and explore every aspect of the crime and people's lives, in the Van Dine tradition.
Anthony Boucher's works contain three impossible crime novels. One of them, The Case of the Solid Key (1941), is my favorite of Boucher's novels. But not because of the impossible crime. Rather, because it is a fascinating book about 1940's Hollywood, focusing on a bunch of young people who, like Boucher himself at the time, were trying to break into the film industry. Boucher never made it in Hollywood, by the way, but he did become a prolific writer of radio plays. The Case of the Solid Key also looks in detail at a Little Theater play production in which some of these hopefuls are involved. The actual impossible crime in Key is solid but slight.
The best parts of The Case of the Seven of Calvary (1937) deal with putting on a play, and are full of allusions to and ideas about literature. Similar rich inventiveness about matters literary is found in another early Boucher tale, the satire "Threnody" (1936). And while "The Punt and the Pass' (1945) is negligible as a mystery plot, it gives a lively look at a University campus, just like The Case of the Seven of Calvary.
"The Girl Who Married a Monster" (1954) has characters who work in television, and an attempt to create a bit of an inside look at that institution too.
The early Gregory Hood radio plays deal with "celebrity culture". Hood is a society figure who has many celebrity friends, who make guest appearances in his radio plays. I confess this enthusiasm for the famous makes me uneasy. Celebrity culture doesn't seem any more appealing in the 1940's than it does today. 1940's radio was deep into celebrities: they made frequent appearances on radio programs, in a way they rarely or ever did in books or movies. Celebrities were also linked to expensive night clubs and restaurants, a venue that appears in "Murder in Celluloid".
Boucher loved party scenes, involving artists and intellectuals. Some of his most joyous works are centered around such parties: The Case of the Baker Street Irregulars, "Mystery for Christmas", "The Elusive Violin". The presence of artist characters links such tales to the Van Dine School tradition.
The Case of the Seven Sneezes as a whole is Boucher's poorest novel. But its opening chapter is an excellent look at a Hollywood party: one of Boucher's joyous gatherings of creative people. The representatives of old, silent era Hollywood are especially interesting. It is good to see that Boucher is knowledgeable about film history as a whole, not just contemporary Hollywood.
There are some unusual writing partnerships in Boucher: The Case of the Baker Street Irregulars (Chapter 14), the frame story in "Mystery for Christmas". The one in "Mystery for Christmas" gets compared to a detective partnership.
Boucher could also write about policemen, and occasionally about underworld types, who show up in "The Ghost with a Gun" (1945).
"The Adventure of the Headless Monk" and "The Adventure of the Beeswax Candle" are two radio plays from the same period, Spring 1946, that have much in common in subject matter. Both:
Some of Boucher's work is quite racy. His first novel The Case of the Seven of Calvary is downright salty. To be blunt, I don't like this. Explicit material sinks the second half of The Case of the Baker Street Irregulars. The first half is an enjoyable, light hearted Sherlockian romp. The second half has a pair of sex crimes emerge from the suspects' past: dark and unpleasant material. "The Stripper" deals with a serial killer, and the suspects' perverse sex lives. Most of this material is not very good. Boucher was perhaps fortunate, that the puritanism of American radio seems largely to have steered him away from explicit subjects in his radio plays. The occasional exception, like the Gregory Hood radio play "Murder in Celluloid", are among his least likable radio work.
The comic elements in Boucher's novels recall those of John Dickson Carr. The events lurch between wild farce and serious crime; such an alternation of tone derives from Carr. There is also a certain self consciousness about the conventions of detective storytelling, that also recalls Carr, such as Dr. Fell's assertion in The Three Coffins (1935) that one was in the midst of a detective tale.
The characters in "The Smoke-filled Locked Room" seem to be from the far left of the Democratic Party.
Boucher would look at Communists in "Death of a Patriarch" (1943). The Case of the Baker Street Irregulars (1940) has a brief but pointed condemnation of Los Angeles' anti-Communist Red Squad, comparing it to Hitler's Gestapo (Chapter 7). There is also a discussion of Communism and the Sinclair Lewis campaign in California (end of Chapter 4), a campaign which gets a brief mention later (Chapter 14).
"The White Masters" (1946) finds sleuth Gregory Hood going after a sinister Neo-Nazi organization.
Boucher's politics are perhaps clearest and most detailed in The Case of the Solid Key (1941). His hero, sleuth Fergus O'Breen, attacks both Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union (Chapter 5). The book mentions the Ukrainian famine (end of Chapter 4): something that expresses anti-Stalinist politics.
A play which represents the characters' political ideals says that their philosophy is essentially the same as Gandhi's philosophy of passive resistance (Chapter 2). Such Gandhian ideas might, however, be just part of Boucher's political beliefs, rather than a central premise of them all. The novel also idolizes a man who had been a pacifist during World War I (Chapter 3).
Political action reaches a climax in The Case of the Solid Key (Chapter 12), when the good guys decide to run the theater as a cooperative.
But Boucher's left wing politics also have an eclectic aspect. The Case of the Solid Key also sympathizes with executed violent anarchists Sacco and Vanzetti (Chapter 3). So did many left-of-center people who did not share the pair's violent politics. A sympathetic playwright character uses Lillian Hellman's Days to Come (1936) as a model for one of his own play (Chapter 3). Hellman was a Communist. The character's play is left wing, although it is not explicitly Communist.
The first Nick Noble tale, "Screwball Division" (1942), includes Los Angeles homicide detective Lt. Herman Finch, a character from Boucher's The Case of the Baker Street Irregulars, a novel with ties to Boucher's Fergus O'Breen series. The last tale in the Nick Noble series, "The Girl Who Married a Monster" (1954), has references to Fergus O'Breen, or at least his detective agency. These indicate that the Nick Noble tales are set in the same "universe" as the O'Breen works.
A non-series short story "Mystery for Christmas" (1943) stars sleuths Mr. Quilter and Tom Smith, characters who bear a bit of a resemblance to Agatha Christie's Mr. Quin and Mr. Satterthwaite. This story too has a frame that refers to the film studio Metropolis Pictures from The Case of the Baker Street Irregulars, and its head F.X. Weinberg.
Nick Noble hangs out in a cafe on Main Street, the downtown near-slum area that served as Los Angeles' Skid Row in the 1940's.
Boucher's influence began right away, in that many of the books he recommended became winners of the Edgar awards, the annual awards for mystery fiction presented by the Mystery Writers of America. Boucher also had two of the most influential pulpits in mystery reviewing: The New York Times (for general readership) and Ellery Queen's Mystery Magazine (for hard core mystery fans). One might also point out that Howard Haycraft was a big admirer of Boucher, so that Boucher had the sponsorship of both Haycraft and Ellery Queen, the two best known American critics of the era immediately preceding his.
Boucher was often the first writer to identify famous talent. He was the first translator of Borges into English, in the 1940's, nearly 20 years before anyone else outside of Argentina was aware of his existence. He championed Ross Macdonald as the leading private eye writer of the 1950's, a dozen years before Macdonald achieved mainstream fame in 1969. One might point out that when mainstream critics took these writers up in the 1960's, that they completely failed to mention Boucher's early championing of these authors. Boucher, like all mystery critics, was treated as a non-person by the mainstream establishment.
Boucher started a tradition of separate but equal tradition of the many subgenres of crime fiction. A Boucher year-end round up of the best books of the year, will break the books down into categories such as classical puzzles, police procedurals, private eyes, suspense, spy fiction, comic mystery novels, social commentary novels, and so on, and cite the best books in each category. No one category of crime fiction will be privileged over any other by Boucher. He will suggest that good books in each subgenre are especially worthy of respect. However, Boucher will express personal affection for the classical puzzle. He will make clear that this is the most loved genre of crime fiction, by him at least, and his personal favorite. This will be presented as a personal taste, not a belief that puzzle fiction has greater objective merit than other approaches. This is a delicately nuanced approach to the proliferation of genres within mystery fiction today. It is precisely the approach that has been taken by several of today's mystery historians, such as Francis M. Nevins and Jon L. Breen.
Boucher also strongly influenced the generation of mystery reviewers that came after him. Today's large annual convention of mystery fans is called the Bouchercon. Today's critic for Ellery Queen's Mystery Magazine, Jon L. Breen, writes in a format recognizably similar to Boucher's, and Breen's yearly round-ups in the Mystery Scene annuals recall Boucher's. Bill Pronzini and Marcia Muller's 1001 Midnights (1986) is a huge collection of reviews of mystery novels, most of them from the post-1941 era. It is the most accessible source of information on the 1941-1985 period, and has become a de facto canon of recommended books for that era. Again and again while reading it, one is struck by the fact that many of the books covered in it were first recommended by Boucher in his reviews. The collection reflects a cultural tradition first started by Boucher himself. I cannot imagine that any of the these writers will be offended by my suggestion that they write in the tradition of Boucher. I think they will take it as a compliment.
Not all modern mystery critics are Boucher derived. Authors of large scale histories of mystery fiction, such as the great Encyclopedia of Mystery and Detection (1976), and the current Guide you are reading, were probably most influenced by earlier historians Haycraft, Queen, and their ancestor, S.S. Van Dine. I know that in my own case, I have wanted to write a history of mystery fiction ever since I read Van Dine's The World's Great Detective Stories (1928) as a child, a work I have read and reread with intense fascination ever since. The debt I owe all these earlier writers is huge. And a major strand of modern mystery criticism, the book length author biography cum critical study, is also largely independent of Boucher. Classics here include Norman Donaldson on R. Austin Freeman, Charles A. Norton on Melville Davisson Post, Francis M. Nevins on Ellery Queen and Cornell Woolrich, Jan Cohn on Mary Roberts Rinehart, Richard Layman on Dashiell Hammett, Frank MacShane on Raymond Chandler, John McAleer on Rex Stout, Patricia D. Maida on Anna Katherine Green, Roger Bonniot on émile Gaboriau, and Douglas G. Greene on John Dickson Carr.
Anthony Boucher repeatedly used a number of mystery plotting techniques, always with variations.
Many Boucher stories contain numerous plot ideas, often from the different categories below. The plot of the story is a mosaic, made up of a series of different plot gambits. It can be startling to read a brief Boucher mystery short story, and see that it has three or four plot ideas, any one of which might have served a lesser writer as the sole subject of a story.
Dying Messages. Boucher's stories are filled with dying messages, a favorite technique of an author who heavily influenced Boucher, Ellery Queen. Examples: the card in The Case of the Crumpled Knave, the victim's statement in "The Three Silver Pesos", the title reference in "QL 696.C9", "Death of a Patriarch", "The Adventure of May Tenth", the coins in "The Adventure of the Green-Eyed Murder", "The Stripper", "The Red Capsule", "The White Masters". There are also statements that are not strictly from dying murder victims, but which function in the same way: such as the identification of the thief in "Mystery for Christmas", the name clue in "Gregory Hood's First Case". The Case of the Baker Street Irregulars (Chapters 11, 24) contains two small verbal phrases with more than one meaning; these puzzles also work like dying message mysteries.
The dying messages in Boucher are hard to interpret: the sleuth often comes up with more than one meaning. This adds ingenuity to the tales.
There are also stories in which the presence of a dying message is not immediately obvious, but which has to be unearthed by the detective. See "Screwball Division".
Sleuth Nick Noble in "QL 696.C9" does some ingenious meta-level reasoning about a dying message. This allows him to interpret what the massage means - without at first understanding the underlying methodology of the message.
Hidden Clues in Text. Boucher also sometimes had his sleuths uncover hidden patterns in a piece of text. This text might not strictly speaking be any sort of dying message. Still, this plot approach does have some broad similarities to the dying message problem. In Boucher, see "Crime Must Have a Stop". This approach occurs in MacHarg and Balmer's "The Axton Letters" (1910).
Ciphers. The Case of the Baker Street Irregulars (Chapters 5, 8), "The Singular Affair of the Baconian Cipher" show his sleuths working out simple ciphers. In both tales, this is part of the set-up of the stories, rather than part of the finale.
The Case of the Baker Street Irregulars (Chapter 8) shows how an extra clue is worked into the cipher format. It is a bit related to the dying message puzzles found elsewhere in Boucher.
Faked evidence. Killers in Boucher often fake evidence, in ways designed to implicate another person. All sorts of evidence can be faked, including dying messages. This means that plots involving faked messages sometimes intergrade with dying message plots in Boucher. Boucher could also mix phony evidence with impossible crime plots, as in "Gregory Hood, Suspect".
Boucher was especially ingenious, in coming up with reasons for his sleuths to conclude a certain piece of evidence is faked. Examples: the card and fingerprints in The Case of the Crumpled Knave, the arrow in "Gregory Hood's First Case", the hair in "The Adventure of the Sad Clown", the document in "The Out-Of-Date Murder".
The evidence for the faking can be part of an elaborate chain of reasoning, involving many aspects of a case. This chain of reasoning can become a complex dance of ideas, as in the finale of The Case of the Crumpled Knave, or the solution to "Screwball Division". The finale of "Murder Beyond the Mountains" involves meta-level reasoning about some faked evidence, linked to a second deduction identifying the killer. The mere fact that evidence has been faked, itself becomes significant, and used for deduction.
"The Adventure of May Tenth" is an unusual Boucher dying message tale, in which the message is partly real, partly faked by the killer. It offers another Boucher variation on two of his favorite plot approaches, dying messages and faked evidence.
"The April Fool Adventure" is unusual, in that we readers know the evidence is fake right from the start.
"The Strange Case of the Girl with a Gazelle" is a seemingly impossible crime, that is actually faked due to phony evidence. The tale is an unusual hybrid of impossible crime and fake evidence plot.
Deductions from real evidence. Boucher detectives do Sherlock Holmes style deductions about people from objects: the archery finger tip and bow in "Gregory Hood's First Case". The Hood radio play "The Forgetful Murderer" has deductions from unbound pages of a book found at a crime scene, and to a lesser degree, from a mysterious metal object.
Several of Boucher's Sherlock Holmes radio plays open with the sleuth making deductions about his clients: something regularly featured in Doyle's original tales. Boucher's deductions tend to be sound but simple. For example, in "The Camberwell Poisoners" Holmes deduces that since his client carries a briefcase, and is out doing business in the middle of the night, that he is probably an insurance adjuster. This play also has deductions about a dog. Other examples: "The Singular Affair of the Uneasy Easy Chair". Such deduction is discussed in The Case of the Baker Street Irregulars (Chapter 12), with an example.
Locked Rooms. Locked room puzzles appear in Nine Times Nine, The Case of the Solid Key, Rocket to the Morgue, "Gregory Hood, Suspect", "The Smoke-filled Locked Room".
While some mystery writers deal with a wide range of impossible crime situations, Boucher instead seems most interested in pure locked rooms.
The solutions of Rocket to the Morgue and "The Smoke-filled Locked Room" have some broad elements in common, in terms of their basic approach. The solution in "The Smoke-filled Locked Room" is fairer and more imaginative, though.
"The Strange Case of the Girl with a Gazelle" is an impossible theft from a locked room.
"The Adventure of the Headless Monk" is a locked room murder - or more strictly, a "watched room" mystery, a common variant of the locked room in mystery fiction. Its solution would be a cheat in most circumstances. But within the context of Boucher's story, the solution is an interesting idea. The tale also benefits from its vivid storytelling.
"The Singular Affair of the Uneasy Easy Chair" is a locked room mystery. But its solution is such a cliche that it is not very interesting.
Hidden Objects. Boucher also created examples of an Ellery Queen and Stuart Palmer specialty, the ingeniously hidden object. Examples: the jewels in "Mystery for Christmas", "The April Fool Adventure", "The Double Diamond". Some of the hiding places will only work within the special backgrounds of the story: see "Mystery for Christmas", "The Double Diamond".
The violin in "The Elusive Violin" is also hidden, but more by a process, than by a fixed hiding place.
"The Singular Affair of the Baconian Cipher" deals with the hiding of a man.
Strange Cars. Boucher tales have strange vehicles, sometimes with hidden drivers: The Case of the Baker Street Irregulars (Chapter 11), "The Adventure of the Sad Clown".
Alibis. Alibi puzzles occasionally show up in Boucher, as in "The Adventure of the Green-Eyed Murder", "The Camberwell Poisoners". Both alibi tales involve the mathematical calculation of a single time. Once the calculation is done, the sleuth knows everything about the alibis.
A look back at a previous murder case contains a very simple alibi puzzle The Case of the Solid Key (Chapter 7). It is solved right away.
A more traditional, bust-the-perfect-alibi plot shows up in the finale of The Case of the Baker Street Irregulars. This seems right out of the Freeman Wills Crofts tradition.
Tracing a crime to an apparent murder victim. This plot gambit appears in Margery Allingham's Police at the Funeral (1931). Boucher used an Allingham-like approach in a number of works: The Case of the Crumpled Knave (Chapters 23-24), "The Three Silver Pesos". In all of these works, a character's actions murder another person, long after that character's death.
In "Screwball Division", a complex chain of circumstances disguises a victim's guilt.
The complex murder in The Case of the Solid Key was planned by the victim, and was originally designed to murder someone else. The victim winds up in the middle of it, after accidentally getting killed himself. Something similar happens in "The Red Capsule". Both tales also involve a similar planned switch of identity, between killer and victim.
Multiple Villains. Another recurring Boucher approach: a tale in which more than one villain has committed crimes. The detective (and the reader) has to disentangle this, figuring which villain did what. At its crudest, in Boucher's novels The Case of the Seven of Calvary (1937) and The Case of the Seven Sneezes (1942), this is not very inventive, or even especially fair to the reader. But several later Boucher short works use this approach with considerable ingenuity, and a greater fairness to the reader. See "Screwball Division", "Mystery for Christmas", "The Girl Who Married a Monster", "The Three Silver Pesos".
The plots in "Mystery for Christmas" and "The Girl Who Married a Monster" seem related.
Schemes that Backfire. Ellery Queen's There Was an Old Woman (1943) looks at a "harmless" scheme that turns deadly. Boucher wrote some tales in this tradition: his Sherlock Holmes radio play "The Notorious Canary Trainer" (1945), "Like Count Palmieri" (1946).
The synopses are highly detailed. They include every aspect of the plot, from the initial set-up, to all of the sleuth's reasoning in uncovering the solution. Characters and backgrounds are defined. Some scenes are just a prose summary. But key scenes are fully dramatized, including dialogue. Dialogue that contains clues to the mystery or significant plot elements is especially spelled out in detail.
Of the three synopses, two have good enough mystery elements to be worthy additions to Boucher's canon: "The Adventure of May Tenth", "The Adventure of the Green-Eyed Murder".
Boucher was a protégé of Ellery Queen, and hence a member of the Van Dine school. This school showed a continuing interest in a more equal treatment of minorities in its fiction:
HIBK writers pioneered in positive portraits of lesbian detectives:
During the 1950's some hard-boiled writers became far more positive in depicting racial minorities:
Blind Detectives. My Syllabus on Mystery Fiction has a section on Blind Detectives.
Comic Books. My list of Political and Social Commentary Tales in Comic Books has much about positive presentations of minorities.
Gay Films. My list of best fiction LGBTQ Films.
Native American Detectives. Please see (external to this site) Steve Lewis' list of Native American Detectives.
Woman Detectives. Please see (external to this site) Bob Schneider's list of Woman Detectives.
As in "The Poison Belt", the disaster in "The Comet" is due to an astronomical phenomenon through which the Earth is temporarily passing. In both tales, people shut up in isolated rooms survive. In "The Poison Belt" people also need oxygen tanks survive, a feature not found in "The Comet".
"The Scarlet Plague" had explored elements of class. "The Comet" looks at class as well. But its deepest looks are at race relations, with W. E. B. Du Bois offering a trenchant look at both racism and what might replace it.
It is reprinted in The Big Book of Science Fiction (2016) edited by Ann VanderMeer and Jeff VanderMeer.
It is reprinted in The Big Book of Science Fiction (2016) edited by Ann VanderMeer and Jeff VanderMeer. And is available free online.
"Sultana's Dream" is a genuine Utopia, in that it shows a good society emerging purely from a change in social organization. There are no biological changes to humans.
"Sultana's Dream" centers on one social change: allowing women to be educated and take on jobs in science and technology. It argues, quite plausibly, that such changes will improve society.
"Sultana's Dream" is unusual among Utopian fiction in that its society does NOT:
Herland shares some broad approaches with an earlier science fiction novel, A Crystal Age (1887) by W.H. Hudson. Both show:
Eugenics has a very bad history - and seen today, the advocacy of eugenics in Herland is a major failing. The book's stance, pro-eugenics and anti-abortion, recalls that of a famous film of the era Where Are My Children? (Lois Weber, 1916).
Asimov's first real novel, and his finest work in the form, Pebble in the Sky (1950) is not a mystery story, but it is a thriller. So is his next, and second best novel, The Stars Like Dust (1951).
Asimov went on to combine the sf novel with an explicit formal Golden Age murder mystery in The Caves Of Steel (1953). This landmark book is not the first sf mystery novel - Asimov's friend Hal Clement wrote Needle (1949), a well done novel which is a science fictional mystery like those in Asimov's earlier short stories - but it is the first full fledged hybrid of the traditional murder mystery and the sf novel, complete with murder case and detectives. Perhaps more importantly, it is a well plotted book, with numerous ingenious surprises and false solutions before the final truth is revealed. Asimov was especially proud of the fact that neither the mysterious situation in the novel, nor its many true and false solutions, would be possible in our 20th century world, that they were entirely enabled by and integrated with the science fictional future of the novel. The book is not merely a contemporary mystery story transposed to the future, but a work in which the sf and mystery elements are totally fused.
Asimov wrote a sequel to The Caves Of Steel, called The Naked Sun (1956). While still being a legitimate detective story, the mystery plotting elements are weaker here, while the sf elements are perhaps stronger than those in the earlier book. Asimov also wrote a series of six sf-mysteries for teenagers about outer space sleuth Lucky Starr. As Joseph Patrouch pointed out in his excellent critical study The Science Fiction of Isaac Asimov, some of these have related backgrounds and mystery puzzles to The Caves Of Steel, notably Lucky Starr and the Big Sun of Mercury (1956) and Lucky Starr and the Moons of Jupiter (1957).
He also published a collection of sf mysteries, Asimov's Mysteries, which show his storytelling and sf skills, but which are not distinguished as Golden Age puzzle plot mysteries.
More importantly, several of the tales in Asimov's best sf collections, Nightfall and Nine Tomorrows, contain mystery or thriller elements. The word "thriller" is perhaps a misnomer here, or at least too vague and imprecise. Asimov's tales are best described as melodramas, in which two sides of a dispute engage in an exciting struggle to achieve some practical result, and also to morally and intellectually justify their position. At their best, such as in Pebble in the Sky or "The Ugly Little Boy" (1958) in Nine Tomorrows, Asimov's melodramas are unforgettable stories.
Asimov went on to write a number of non-sf detective stories. His two mystery novels, A Whiff of Death (1958) and Murder at the ABA (1976) are terrible, but some of his later mystery short stories are ingenious. Most of Asimov's 1970's mystery tales are written in the third person, but during the early 1980's he began to experiment with building a tale around the first person narratives of different characters, a somewhat unusual technique that recalls Wilkie Collins.
Asimov made so many slighting references to his own personal literary style - or his alleged lack of it - that one is afraid that critics are going to take him at his own word. Many science fiction writers write in an elaborate, image laden, complex literary style. Examples: Bradbury, Cordwainer Smith, Samuel Delany, J.G. Ballard. There is very little imagery in Asimov's work, and his literary style clearly has nothing in common with theirs. I strongly admire all of these writers' stylistic achievements. But I also think that there are other valid approaches as well. Asimov's work is written in a style that derives not from poetry, like theirs, but which is closer to the pure form of classical music. The rhythmic complexity of Asimov's prose is breathtaking. Each sentence plays its part in an elaborate over all structure, one that builds to complex climaxes like the music of Beethoven.
I wish to thank my friend, Mark L. Ricard, for suggesting that this web site take a deeper dive into the works of Isaac Asimov. Thanks, Mark!
The science fiction ideas are richest in the first two tales, which are also the best in the series, "The Singing Bell" and "The Talking Stone":
The titles "The Singing Bell" and "The Talking Stone" both echo R. Austin Freeman's pioneering collection which invented the inverted detective story, The Singing Bone.
"The Key" has sf elements recalling Arthur C. Clarke's "The Sentinel", and others that recall Clifford D. Simak's Way Station (1963). This story also includes an sf device that recalls the Mule parts of Foundation and Empire. The first third of "The Key" differs in approach from the rest of the story:
On a level of imagery, "Runaround" (1942) from I, Robot shares approaches with "The Singing Bell". The test in "The Singing Bell" has the suspect throwing something. For different reasons, the heroes in "Runaround" test the robots' throwing ability. Structurally, these two tales have little in common. But the relationship on the level of imagery is striking. Both stories also have scenes on other worlds, on Mercury and the Moon respectively, that involve black shadows coming out from mountains that give way to regions of bright sunshine.
The mix of Solar System space travel, exotic sf artifacts and traditional mystery genres in the Wendell Urth stories anticipates Poul Anderson's "Adventure of the Martian Crown Jewels" (1958). This is an impossible crime short story, with a rich science fiction background to rival Asimov's. One suspects that Anderson was using Asimov's general approach to constructing an sf mystery, in this story.
"C-Chute" (1951) looks at humans encountering insect-based aliens in space. The most interesting part of "C-Chute" are not the aliens per se, although their social beliefs are well-handled, as in its deconstruction of war fever. Asimov shows that the aliens are behaving just as well and just as badly, as the humans in this interstellar alien Vs humans war. The rich sociological detail of the war, and the alien's behavior in it, is quite inventive and forms a substantial and original anti-war commentary.
"Kid Stuff" (1953) combines the alien-human history of "Hostess" with the insect-based alien approach of "C-Chute". "Kid Stuff" is elaborately detailed, and in theory I should like it. But actually it seems repulsively horror filled.
Asimov returns to these modes in a Black Widowers story, "Neither Brute Nor Human" (1984), a minor tale that takes some unpleasant swipes at Poe and Lovecraft, as well.
"The Talking Stone" (1955) is quite different from all of the above. It shows aliens and humans cooperating with each other, instead of being enemies, as in the other Asimov tales mentioned. The aliens resemble those of Hal Clement's Mission of Gravity (1953) in that they learn science from humans, and in that the aliens' bodies are designed to live in what for humans would be inhospitable environments.
First the real mysteries: tales in which the plot contains a mysterious situation to be solved. These fall into a number of series, each related in terms of plot.
1) "No Smoking" (1974) is the first of several Asimov tales, about people whose behavior is observed, but hard to interpret. It has a miasmic quality, and it is hard to see where the story's situation is going - before detective Henry reveals the inner logic of the events.
"The Driver" (1980) also involves interpretation of an observed person. The tale has an obscure fact gimmick, like many other Black Widowers stories - but here it is worked into a real mystery plot, complete with ingenious solution. The story takes place against a background of scientific research: a common subject in Asimov's late 1950's works, such as the sf-mysteries "The Dying Night" (1956) and "The Dust of Death" (1957).
The Union Club mystery "No Refuge Could Save" (1980) also involves a man who observes job candidates professionally for his living, just like "No Smoking". This tale could be regarded as a puzzle story, being based on an obscure bit of information. But this tiny piece of knowledge is worked into a complex mystery story, a spy tale that shows some originality of approach. The tale is loaded with bits of satire, which are often rooted in paradox, just like the mystery plot of the story itself.
Asimov did not include any of these stories in The Best Mysteries of Isaac Asimov. So Asimov apparently felt they were marginal in his work. But to me they seem like some of his best puzzle plots, and among his works which are closest to the pure mystery tradition of "baffling stories ingeniously and surprisingly explained".
All of these tales involve people under psychological observation, often in a business context. This recalls such sf-mystery tales from I, Robot as "Runaround" and "Little Lost Robot", in which humans study robots on the job, and try to understand their psychology. In both these mysteries and the robot tales, Asimov is most interested in what is going on inside people's minds. Asimov's sf-mystery Lucky Starr and the Moons of Jupiter has sf-based observation, through a Venusian "frog".
2) "Out of Sight" (1973) deals with explaining the puzzling leakage of classified information. "The Recipe" (1990) also deals with an impossible leakage of information, and has a solution partly related to "Out of Sight". Close to these Black Widowers stories is Asimov's sf-mystery Lucky Starr and the Moons of Jupiter (1957). Its main mystery plot deals with hidden leakage of information. And the solution of the mystery has some points in common with the Black Widowers tales.
These stories have solutions that are somewhat related to such tales as "No Smoking" and "The Driver".
"Out of Sight" also has specific links to "Quicker Than the Eye" in the "impossible disappearance" series discussed below, having both a solution related to the latter story, and a setting in the restaurant-like dining room of a cruise ship. Like many of the disappearance stories, its solution involves the psychology of a person watching or participating in the events.
Asimov included "Out of Sight" in The Best Mysteries of Isaac Asimov.
3) "Quicker Than the Eye" (1974) and "The Redhead" (1984) are impossible disappearance stories. Oddly enough, both take place in restaurants. This is in addition to the fact that the frame story in most of the Black Widowers tales is itself in a restaurant. "The Lucky Piece" (1990) has another small object that disappears, as in "Quicker Than the Eye". "The Lucky Piece" is unusually tricky, and has more complications than most of Asimov's impossible disappearance tales. One of his last Black Widowers tales, "Lost In a Space Warp" (1990) is another impossible disappearance, very much in the same mode. This takes place in a private home's kitchen, an environment closely related to the restaurant settings of the other tales. The last Black Widowers story (what a sad thing to say!) "The Guest's Guest" (1991) also deals with a vanishing piece of information. This time, it is lost at the Black Widowers restaurant itself.
The Union Club story "He Wasn't There" (1981) also deals with an impossible disappearance, once again from a restaurant. Its solution is less clever and plausible than the Black Widowers stories in this tradition. And the not-very-good Union Club tale "Never Out of Sight" (1983) provides a sort of absurd version of the same idea, this time set an amusement park.
Asimov included all of the above pre-1987 stories in The Best Mysteries of Isaac Asimov (1987), and made clear in his commentary that he valued such stories highly. In More Tales of the Black Widowers, his commentary on "Quicker Than the Eye" aptly links it to G. K. Chesterton's "The Invisible Man" (1910). Chesterton's tale is rooted in the psychology of an observer, something Asimov preserves.
"The Unabridged" (1976) involves a search for a hidden object. This story has formal similarities to the impossible disappearance tales above. This object has not disappeared, strictly speaking. But like the disappeared objects, it is now in a hidden, obscure place. The story opens with a general philosophical discussion of missing and misplaced objects: this contains ideas that will recur in "Lost In a Space Warp".
Even among the real mystery tales, there are formal resemblances to Asimov's puzzle stories. For example, the impossible disappearances are presented as pure puzzles. "The Redhead" asks: "How did the redhead disappear?" This mystery is not linked to a whodunit, or unraveling some other mysterious crime situation, as it would be in a typical impossible crime story by Carr, Chesterton or Hoch. Asimov's story instead presents a pure, isolated puzzle. Still, the kind of puzzle, an impossible disappearance, is 1) one that reflects a long mystery tradition of impossible crimes 2) rooted in the actual main plot of the story. These two factors make "The Redhead" fall within the paradigm of "real mystery fiction".
Asimov liked the restaurant setting for his real mystery tales. The Black Widowers "The Woman in the Bar" (1980) and the Union Club "The Appleby Story" (1981) have such settings, although neither is an impossible crime tale like those mentioned above. Both are fairly minor among Asimov's mysteries. Both do have relationships with the above series, involving a restaurant or bar as a place of concealed contact for a clandestine organization.
4) Some of Asimov's tales deal with ingenious approaches for creating secret codes. These include "Go, Little Book!" (1972), and the Larry tale "The Key Word" (1977).
Most of Asimov's code tales were not included by him in The Best Mysteries of Isaac Asimov.
"Go, Little Book!" also has ties to the "hidden leakage of information" kind of story. It too has scenes in a restaurant.
5) "The Lullaby of Broadway" (1974) is a sort of sequel to "Go, Little Book!". It is relatively unique within the real mysteries, with a plot that has some similarities with the earlier tale, and many differences.
"The Old Purse" (1987) is another hard-to-classify tale within Asimov's mysteries. It has some features in common with "The Lullaby of Broadway": an innocent married couple at the center of the tale, a writer and his wife, the New York City apartment house where they live, surprising but hard to explain events in that apartment house, and a solution involving somewhat similar kinds of intrigue in both stories. Some of these elements also formed a plot thread in The Caves of Steel, with Lije Bailey and his wife Jessie, and the huge futuristic New York City apartment buildings where they live.
Asimov did not include these stories in The Best Mysteries of Isaac Asimov. In his afterwards, Asimov reveals that the initial premise of each story is based on a real life event, while his solution is fictional and made up for the tale.
6) "Can You Prove It?" (1981) deals with an attempt to establish identity. This is an unusual, innovative subject for a mystery story. The solution invokes some of the hidden information that accompanies daily life. So does the solution of the little mystery in the Union Club tale "The Magic Umbrella" (1983), which is also about trying to establish identity, this time not of a person, but of an umbrella. This latter story is most endearing for the characterization of the two battling elderly men. They reflect the similar battling conversations among the Black Widowers. "The Haunted Cabin" (1990) is another puzzle involving a mysterious establishment of identity, like "Can You Prove It?".
Asimov included both of the pre-1987 stories in The Best Mysteries of Isaac Asimov.
Issues of identity, treated in different fashion, are also involved in such sf-mysteries as The Caves of Steel and "Little Lost Robot" from I, Robot.
7) Asimov wrote some "anti-detective stories", tales which deconstruct the conventions of the detective story, violating its norms: "The Obvious Factor" (1973), "Yes, But Why?" (1990). These have some common plot ideas in their solutions. "The Obvious Factor" especially seemed like a cheat when I first read it. No one should read these expecting fair detective tales. However, Asimov's shock effects in "The Obvious Factor" do have a scientific point, one that he memorably makes about pseudo-science.
The solution of these stories gives them some similarity to a different Asimov series mentioned above: "No Smoking", "The Driver", "No Refuge Could Save".
The robot tale "Galley Slave" (1957) also can be seen as a precursor to the anti-detective stories, in a small way. "Galley Slave" is moderately enjoyable as storytelling, being a not-bad Asimov excursion into courtroom drama, but overall the tale lacks substance. In a different way, the robot detective story "Mirror Image" (1972) also has some shared story material. "Mirror Image" has an elaborate, but somehow not very creative plot.
8) The introduction to "The Haunted Cabin" (1990) contains a real life mini-mystery that happened to Dr. Asimov. So does the entire story of "Where Is He?" (1986). Both tales are interesting, but neither of these "found" mysteries aligns closely with the main series of mystery plots that Asimov created above.
Probably the closest ancestor to Asimov's puzzle stories are "dying message" tales, and related mysteries in which sleuths have to interpret a mysterious piece of text, such as those which offer cryptic clues to buried treasure. Ellery Queen is the leading writer of dying message tales - and most of the Black Widowers stories were first published in Ellery Queen's Mystery Magazine, at the direct suggestion of Ellery Queen. What seems to be the first Asimov tale to involve puzzles, the science fiction mystery "The Key" (1966), centers on both dying messages and clues to the location of a hidden treasure. It establishes Asimov's links with both of these mystery traditions.
Another work, one with more distant relationship to Asimov's writing: Lewis Carroll's A Tangled Tale (1880-1881 in magazines, 1885 in book form). This little-known but ingenious work embeds math puzzles into a fictional story. Asimov only rarely included purely mathematical puzzles or games into his tales. Asimov's Union Club mystery "Getting the Combination" (1982) is an example.
On specific puzzle-oriented Black Widowers tales:
"Friday the Thirteenth" (1975) and "The Year of the Action" (1980) are puzzles that involve both calendars and history; both are about determining ambiguous years; both look at the historical implications of those years. "The Year of the Action" involves Gilbert and Sullivan. It is hardly a mystery - but it does contain a well developed little historical essay about its puzzle, and is fun to read. Asimov had previously written two nicely-done pastiches of Gilbert lyrics: "The Foundation of S.F. Success" (1954) and "The Author's Ordeal" (1957), both in the collection Earth Is Room Enough. Gilbert is quoted by Asimov as early as "Runaround" (1942).
"The Year of the Action" prophesizes the rise and re-birth of the animated film. It took awhile, but animation has been a huge business since around 1990. ("Robbie" (1940) showed science fiction films as mainstream entertainment in the future. This too came to pass.)
"The Ultimate Crime" (1976) is a similar pure puzzle, about Sherlock Holmes and astronomy.
"To the Barest" (1979) is fun, because it gives some humorous inside looks at the Black Widowers as an institution. Its "puzzle in a will" aspects recall "The Curious Omission" (1974).
While Asimov was famous for being a religious skeptic, "The One and Only East" (1975) contains a sympathetic character who is religious. It offers a full outline of his religious practice and attitudes. Once again, this is a complex portrait of a whole way of life, that relates in form, to the portraits of new ways of life in Asimov's science fiction stories. As in many of Asimov's puzzle stories, the puzzle is barely connected to the rest of the story. The geography puzzle about "the East" has nothing to do with the religious aspects of the tale, or even the family situation of the hero. It is like a whole second story nested within the tale as a whole. "Sunset on the Water" (1986) has a geographical puzzle related to that in "The One and Only East". It also has autobiographical aspects about Asimov's love of history.
Several of the Black Widowers tales show personal sides of Dr. Asimov. "The Cross of Lorraine" (1976) offers metaphors for Asimov's fictional talent and its place in his personal life, just as the earlier sf "Dreaming is a Private Thing" (1955) did. (The little girl in "Robbie" is also a creator and teller of stories, both in her spaceship game-playing and her versions of fairy tales she tells Robbie.) The tale's puzzle is unusual, in that it is a purely geometric, non-verbal riddle.
"The Family Man" (1976) deals with cognitive psychology: styles and methods of thinking. The story's puzzle is weak, unfortunately, but the discussions of thinking throughout are interesting. The discussion of "family men" versus solitary men and Henry's position on this adds to the characterization of Henry in the stories.
"Middle Name" (1980) is also a pure puzzle, without real mystery in the conventional sense. It is mixed with an unusual discussion of relations between the sexes. This discussion seems related in approach to science fiction. Just as science fiction, especially Asimov's, often sets forth a sociological account of an imaginary or future world, so does this story create a detailed look at relations between the sexes in today's society.
"The Quiet Place" (1988) offers interesting metaphors for the tales of friendship between men that are so important to Asimov. It is a puzzle story, but it also offers some real detective work in its dual attempts to track down a person and a place. The story contains imagery that suggests mystical visions of peace, here linked to a place visited by the hero. This is perhaps related to the mystical visions of mental breakdown during space travel, that occur in some of Asimov's fictions. The tale has subject matter links with the story-within-a-story "The Wandering Londoner" in The Caves of Steel (Chapter 10), although that is a horror tale, while "The Quiet Place" is upbeat.
A historical note: The first Black Widowers tale, "The Acquisitive Chuckle" (1972), does not really have a detective - the solution just unfolds. It is only with the second tale that Henry firmly assumes the role of detective, which he will hold ever after. This second story is also the first tale in which Asimov realized he was writing a series: Asimov originally conceived "The Acquisitive Chuckle" as a one-shot. Also, there are only five Black Widowers in these first two stories. It is only with the third, the otherwise not-too-interesting "Truth to Tell" (1972), that math teacher Roger Halsted makes his appearance. One also notes that as far back as "Super-Neutron" (1941) Asimov was writing a tale about a men's dining club that has a guest telling it a story. So the Black Widowers have deep roots within Asimov's fiction.
"He Wasn't There" (1981) is one of the most elaborately constructed of the pure mystery Union Club stories. Asimov wrote this based on a plot contributed by Martin Gardner, well known for his "Mathematical Games" columns in Scientific American. Its New York City apartment house setting recalls such Black Widowers stories as "The Lullaby of Broadway" and "The Old Purse", but the mystery plot has a different structure than those tales.
"The Men Who Wouldn't Talk" (1980) has an uninspired puzzle gimmick. But the body of the story deals with a mass investigation at a prison, and contains some inventive ideas. It is related to earlier mass investigations such as "Little Lost Robot" and Lucky Starr and the Moons of Jupiter.
"Irresistible to Women" (1981), despite being in a collection of non-sf mysteries, is actually a science fiction mystery, although it is not labeled as such. Like Asimov's robot sf-mystery novels of the 1950's, it is a whodunit, with a series of suspects, from among whom the detective has to find the guilty party. This whodunit structure is rare in Asimov's post-1972 short stories. Here we have three women suspects who visit the murdered man shortly before his death: a plot set-up found in countless Ellery Queen short stories. The mystery involves cognitive science, and hence is related to the many Asimov mysteries that turn on psychology and the inner mental workings of the characters.
David Starr, Space Ranger opens with a mysterious death in a restaurant. In this it anticipates the many non-sf mysteries that Asimov would write that were set in restaurants.
Unfortunately, as a mystery David Starr, Space Ranger is weak:
There are other links between "The Hazing" and later Asimov:
Lucky Starr and the Big Sun of Mercury continues Asimov's interest in portrayals of scientific research. Here the research of Project Light builds upon the earlier discovery of the interstellar jump and subetheric space, which had been seen in "Little Lost Robot" and "Escape!" in I, Robot. As in the earlier stories, this research is viewed as a part of future history: events logically following on previous events. The way Project Light is a large scale human undertaking set in outer space recalls "Little Lost Robot". The jealousy of Cook for his superior recalls "Liar!" in I, Robot.
Lucky Starr and the Big Sun of Mercury reflects the wrong astronomical idea of its era, that Mercury only keeps one face to the sun. It does not: Mercury, we now know, revolves like every other planet. However, luckily the story does not emphasize this aspect much. Instead, the focus of Lucky Starr and the Big Sun of Mercury is how large the Sun seems when viewed from Mercury, and how much light it gets from the sun. These aspects have not dated at all. Asimov uses them to create his poetic opening chapter.
The Venusian frog aspects develop ideas Asimov first explored with The Mule in The Foundation Trilogy. Lucky also faces a hazing, as in the story "The Hazing", although here it does not lead to space travel or kidnapping.
Lucky Starr and the Moons of Jupiter is also a tale of a large scale scientific program on a base in space, like "Little Lost Robot" and "Escape!" in I, Robot. We see not only people engaged in research, but a richly developed look at the results of the research, anti-gravity. Asimov had previously explored a world in which anti-gravity was in common use, in "The Singing Bell". Here he shows its initial development.
While Lucky Starr and the Rings of Saturn is not mainly a mystery, it is one of the best Lucky Starr novels, gripping throughout. The last three Lucky Starr novels, Lucky Starr and the Big Sun of Mercury, Lucky Starr and the Moons of Jupiter, Lucky Starr and the Rings of Saturn, seem to form a trilogy. Like The Caves of Steel, they emphasize the conflict between Earth and a group of thinly populated outer planets that use robots. In all of these books, robots play a major role. These books and "The Ugly Little Boy" (1958) were the last major sf works Asimov created before the long silence, 1959 - 1971, during which he published almost no new science fiction, except for his novelization of Fantastic Voyage and a few often very short stories. So their very existence seems precious.
Lucky Starr and the Rings of Saturn opens with an absorbing account of space travel, to and near Saturn (Chapters 1 - 8). It involves a chase through space, as well as a vivid account of Saturn and its rings, and shows what Asimov could do when he choose to write "space opera". Everything has been imagined with both logic and detail. Like the space travel in "Super-Neutron" (1941), the space ship goes south of the ecliptic, and views a planet from its South Pole. There were good space travel scenes in the second half of Lucky Starr and the Moons of Jupiter, too. But those mainly restricted themselves to vivid descriptions about what might be seen from Jupiter's moons. In Lucky Starr and the Rings of Saturn, Asimov instead develops a look at space travel as a whole.
The second half of Lucky Starr and the Rings of Saturn deals with a political struggle. Its intrigue reminds one of the political parts of The Foundation Trilogy and Pebble in the Sky. The book has the first real look at the lives and beliefs of the Sirians, and other Outer World planets. It gives a full look at the politics of these societies. The depiction of how the Sirians regard Earth people as racially inferior is a chilling and powerful pro-Civil Rights commentary, like Pebble in the Sky. The book also shows Asimov's belief that political solutions to problems are far better than war.
Between the complex vision of space travel, and the equally full look at a series of planets and their life styles in its second half, Lucky Starr and the Rings of Saturn is deeply science fictional. It is a full tilt look at a possible future, an Asimov specialty.
Dua is close to what is now known as transgendered: she looks like one of the three sexes on this planet, but she really is an unusual combination of two of these three sexes.
It might be worth emphasizing, that The Gods Themselves deals very purely with "consensual relations among adults". Also, while the characters all have flaws and limitations, their relationships and sexuality are presented largely sympathetically.
Genre science fiction wrote much about gender and gay life during the 1966-1976 era. Writers like Ursula K. Le Guin, Joanna Russ, Samuel R. Delany, Thomas M. Disch and J.G. Ballard offered many science fictional explorations of such alternative sexuality and gender. The Gods Themselves was part of this movement: an important part.
The explicitness, detail, depth of feeling and respect with which the gay and transgender characters and relationships are depicted, makes The Gods Themselves almost unprecedented. Not just in science fiction, but in human literature as a whole.
Redundancy. Asimov uses "redundancy" to make clear that these characters are LGBTQ:
Mystery Plot. The middle section of The Gods Themselves has mystery elements. These elements involve the beings called the Hard Ones. Both heroes Odeen and Dua wonder about the many mysterious unknown aspects of the Hard Ones' lives. The reader wonders too: readers know just as little as Odeen and Dua. At the end of the story, Odeen and Dua figure out the answers about the Hard Ones, and share them with the reader: just like detectives giving the solution at the end of a typical non-science fiction mystery. The middle section of The Gods Themselves is thus a combination of science fiction and mystery: just like The Caves of Steel and other Asimov science fiction-mysteries. However, the middle section of The Gods Themselves differs from The Caves of Steel, in that the mystery does NOT involve a murder.
The mystery in The Gods Themselves has some broad structural resemblances to the mystery surrounding the Second Foundation in The Foundation Trilogy:
Confusingly, "hard sf" is frequently defined in a number of ways, that actually refer to distinct concepts:
Asimov was championing hard science fiction in his essays during this period.
Cosmic Engineering. The discussion of moving the Moon (in the last third) is in the tradition of sf tales of Cosmic Engineering. Asimov likely grew up reading such tales in 1926-1945 pulp magazines, written by authors like Edmond Hamilton and Otto Binder. (See also my article on Otto Binder's 1950's Cosmic Engineering comic book tales in Mystery in Space.)
The Gods Themselves has something of a "kitchen sink" construction: as the saying goes, Asimov seems to be "throwing everything but the kitchen sink" into the story. The book is a huge compendium of science fiction subjects and techniques, some old and maybe old-fashioned like Cosmic Engineering, others up-to-the-minute.
The discussion of sheep in Book One is also a look at social change. It starts with a single premise: the rise of sheep herding in England. It goes on to explore a whole series of ramifications, showing how raising sheep has transformed many aspects of English society. This is a common paradigm of Campbell school science fiction. Such fiction often starts with a single change, then shows how it logically transforms many aspects of society.
There are differences: Utopia looks at a real-life change (sheep) that has already happened; Campbell science fiction at an imaginary social change that might happen in the future. Still the intellectual approach and literary techniques are remarkably similar.
Before reading Utopia, I knew that some authors, notably Poe in "Mellonta Tauta" (1849) and H.G. Wells in The Time Machine (1895), had looked at social change before Campbell (whose influence started in the 1930's). But I now see that such change is discussed centuries earlier, in Utopia.
Utopia also shows examples of a systematic change in values. Book Two shows all the Utopians finding gold ornaments to look clown-like and childish. Such changes of values are a standard technique in Campbell school science fiction.
Another impressively modern passage in Book Two points out that music makes a strong impression on people - but that we don't understand how it does this. Today, "how music works" is a subject of much research, attracting philosophers, neurobiologists and others. (England had major classical composers in John Browne and William Cornysh, who lived just before More, and Thomas Tallis, who was born soon after More's generation.)
Less substantial is the brief look at formal logic in Utopia. It mainly offers satirical jabs at a popular medieval book on logic. It does not really look at logic itself, or its role in human thought. This would be left to Poe in "Mellonta Tauta".
Some of Skelton's (admittedly less successful) earlier works are in the long tradition of "dream poems": works presented as dreams of the poet. See the "Garland of Laurel" and "The Bowge of Court". Like many dream poems, these have fantasy elements. As Ursula K. Le Guin pointed out, there a large numbers of fantasy works that are not sold in book stores as "fantasy". Much of our cultural heritage in fact has fantasy aspects.
I have no idea what sort of Rogue Fiction, if any, was popular in 1516 when Utopia was published.
Please see my article on later Rogue Fiction, especially on its influence on detective stories.
Both the crooked proposals in Book One, and the Utopians' war plans in Book Two, are schemes proposed by governments. This differs from most 19th and 20th Century Rogue Fiction, in which the schemers are lone crooks. One implication: 19th and 20th Century Rogues are usually breaking the law, stealing or swindling. But these government schemes in Utopia are not strictly speaking crimes, even though they are immoral and objectionable.
Such plain clothes anticipate today's school uniforms, which attempt to put both rich and poor students on an equal footing. They also anticipate the plain dress of religious groups, such as the Puritans and the early Quakers.
During the Elizabethan era soon to come some decades after More, English Art would excel at portraiture: notably Nicholas Hilliard and Isaac Oliver. Many portraits would show their subject in fancy clothes: a direct contradiction to the ideas advocated by Utopia.
In addition, the scenes where hero Woyzeck is made the subject of the doctor's medical experiments, bring Science very much into the world of Woyzeck.
Murder Fiction. Woyzeck concludes with a murder. Despite its early date, crime fiction was already a going concern by 1836. Pelham (1828) by Edward Bulwer-Lytton contains a murder mystery. The hero finds a murdered man, bloody and half-in a small pool. Pelham thus anticipates such features of Woyzeck as a knife killing, blood on the murderer, moonlight, and a pool - although these features are combined in different ways in the two works.
Quality. In its original German, Woyzeck has a dignity, a forcefulness, a vividness and a rhythmic quality not always found in its translations.
Woyzeck is far from a favorite of mine, nightmarish and depressing. Still it is highly original.
The book's highlight is its depiction of the New York City of the future (Chapter 5). This chapter is a parade of technical marvels. Depictions of advanced, large, fabulous cites were a standard in 1910's sf:
The depiction of New York City streets (Chapter 4) shows that electric vehicles have replaced gas-powered cars. Electric vehicles also appear in the non-science-fiction detective story "The Man Higher Up" (1909) by William MacHarg and Edwin Balmer. In Ralph 124C41+, pedestrians are speeded along by the electric-motor roller skates they wear, called "coasters". Both the coasters and the electric vehicles are re-charged wirelessly from power sources on the streets: thus avoiding the need for charging stations.
Influence on Asimov. Gernsback's New York City anticipates the futuristic city Trantor in Isaac Asimov's Foundation (1951) and the future New York City in Asimov's "Robbie" (1940) and The Caves of Steel (1953). Both Asimov and Gernsback have elevators leading to the roofs of buildings, where one can stare out and see immense vistas. The Roosevelt Building in "Robbie" is a half-mile high skyscraper, twice as tall as the real-life Empire State Building.
The "routing goods" technology in Gernsback perhaps finds an echo in the different "routing people" technology in the opening of Foundation.
Influence on Air Wave. The article about the 1940's high-tech comic book hero Air Wave discusses Gernsback's influence on the character's technology.
It depicts industry as something that consumes workers, the way the evil pagan god Moloch was worshipped by human sacrifice in the Bible. This metaphor anticipates the science fiction film Metropolis (Fritz Lang, 1927). Metropolis in turn influenced the Moloch imagery in Allen Ginsberg's poem Howl (1955).
The description of the elaborate machinery in "Liquid Sunshine" has a "visionary" quality. So do the depictions of advanced lenses and technical equipment earlier in the tale. They describe an elaborate visual experience, one that is beautiful, and which seems to evoke an almost hallucinatory intensity of visual patterns. Visionary experience was prominent in the 1910's works of William Hope Hodgson. The subject matter of Hodgson and Kuprin is different, with Kuprin being more interested in machinery. Still, the visionary feel of Kuprin definitely recalls Hodgson.
The young hero's many jobs and wandering from place to place, recall the early life of Kuprin himself. This gives "Liquid Sunshine" an autobiographical aspect. The liveliness of these descriptions perhaps reflects their roots in reality. However, the specific details of "Liquid Sunshine" are likely different from the author's own adventures.
"Liquid Sunshine" deserves praise for its sympathetic depiction of Jews. The black servants in the story are not caricatured either. Unfortunately, the tale mars these accomplishments, by having the scientist make dismissive racial remarks at the story's end.
Flint's Utopian novella "The Queen of Life" (1919), about a trip to Venus, seems quite sophisticated. It opens with a vivid space flight to that planet, followed by a well thought out look at Venus' advanced civilization. The tale is a genuine science fiction story: full of imaginative, logical detail following from Flint's basic premises. The story's many feminist angles should also intrigue modern readers.
Flint's sequels "The Devolutionist" (1921) and "The Emancipatrix" (1921) seem inferior to "The Queen of Life". The idea of humans as slaves to animals has a long tradition in sf. It shows up in "The Emancipatrix", with humans as slaves to bees.
Flint's stories about cosmic engineering, humans altering solar systems through technology, were cited as an influence by Edmond Hamilton.
Hamilton would script many mystery and science fiction tales for comic books in the 1950's and 1960's. His mysteries often centered on "mysteries of identity".
Problem and solution. "Who Goes There?" has a "problem and solution" structure. The hero, and implicitly the reader, are faced with a science fiction problem: identifying the alien. Eventually, the hero comes up with a solution, a method to identify the alien. The method used as the solution is logically based on the ideas in the story.
Such a "problem and solution" has some resemblance to the mystery tale: a riddle or puzzle, and a logical yet surprising solution based on prior events in the story.
Note that the method is the solution to the problem. The identity of the alien determined by the method is not something that the reader can deduce logically. Only the method of determining the alien is developed logically from prior story elements. This differs from most mysteries, where the identity of the culprit is the solution, logically derived from clues. By contrast, in "Who Goes There?", it is the method of finding the alien that is the problem's solution.
"Problem and solution" tales occur in other science fiction authors. They include some of Isaac Asimov's robot stories, and Gardner Fox's Adam Strange comic book science fiction series. The final section of Theodore L. Thomas' "The Weather Man" (1962) has a problem-and-solution structure.
Lovecraft tradition. "Who Goes There?" perhaps reflects the work of H.P. Lovecraft and his followers, a tradition not always viewed as close to Campbell:
Technology. "Who Goes There?" opens and closes with pictures of the aliens' advanced technology. This gives a "super-science" dimension to the tale, recalling such Campbell stories as "Night" (1935).
The opening includes a spectacular light show: a favorite subject in science fiction.
Popularity and canons. "Who Goes There?" is far and away John W. Campbell's most famous story today. This is in part because of the numerous film versions, as The Thing. It is also perhaps because it is one of the most horror-centered of Campbell's works, thus finding an audience among the vast group of horror fans.
However, the fame of "Who Goes There?" also reflects its repeated inclusion in science fiction canons. Even before the first film version The Thing from Another World (Howard Hawks and Christian Nyby, 1951), there are signs that "Who Goes There?" was becoming a canonical science fiction story. "Who Goes There?" was included in the pioneering science fiction anthology Adventures in Time and Space (1946) edited by Raymond J. Healy and J. Francis McComas, a work that helped establish science fiction canons. Since that time, "Who Goes There?" has repeatedly shown up in key science fiction canon-building enterprises, such as The Science Fiction Hall of Fame, Volume Two (1973), where it was voted top place among science fiction novellas, and the All-Centuries Locus Polls (2012), where "Who Goes There?" took 4th place among novellas.
One might compare the description of a prehistoric Dartmoor barrow in the mystery novel known as The Corpse With the Blue Cravat or The Coroner Doubts (1938) by R. A. J. Walling. (Walling's descriptions are near the start of Chapter 3):
The TV series Arthur C. Clarke's Mysterious World (1980) includes an episode about megalithic structures, The Riddle of the Stones.
Having a hero move out of his home region to explore a forested area, also occurs in Clarke tales like "The Lion of Comarre" and "Second Dawn".
Ursula K. Le Guin's The Dispossessed (1974) has its dissatisfied hero travel from his home in a desert Utopia to a lush, fertile green area hosting a very different society. Like Clarke's heroes, he is the only member of his otherwise inward-looking society to make such a journey.
Pets. Theon has two pets, and the human-pet relationship is idealized. Similarly, "The Lion of Comarre" gets its title from the lion who adopts the hero as his human owner. Both tales' relationships are modeled on that of humans and dogs.
Like other parts of Clarke tales, an idealized viewed of dogs is deeply British. British writers and painters often depicted dogs as better morally than humans, with dogs' loyalty and steadfastness seen as morally superior to humans' behavior.
Future Cities. John W. Campbell wrote famous tales of advanced future cities, often abandoned. Such Campbell short stories as "Night" (1935) and "Forgetfulness" (1937) perhaps influenced Clarke's cities in Against the Fall of Night.
The Night Land (1912) by William Hope Hodgson depicts much of what is left of mankind gathered together in a single, isolated city on a far future Earth. The hero learns of the existence of a second settlement, and sets out to find it. This could have influenced Clarke. However, the tone of the two novels is different, with Against the Fall of Night lacking the horror and eeriness of The Night Land.
Automated Transport. SPOILERS. The automatic underground transport system recalls Clarke's "Rescue Party" (1946).
The automatic spaceship in which the hero catches a ride anticipates Childhood's End.
Such systems are very British. They recall the Underground subway system in London, and Britain's national railway system. Both of these are key features of British life.
The Computer. The main computer is known as the Associator. Central to it is what we now call a "database" or "knowledge base": a large collection of information, facts and knowledge. It also has reasoning capabilities. One suspects that the novel's concepts were influenced by earlier real life proposals for creating vast knowledge bases:
Vanamonde. Vanamonde is "born" as an infant, and slowly grows up. This anticipates the Star Child at the end of the film 2001. However, Vanamonde is "explained" in considerable science fictional detail, whereas the Star Child is a puzzling image that suddenly appears without explanation.
It is unclear to me that group minds or telepathy are superior to or an advance on the single individual minds of today's humans. This means that I have trouble seeing the ends of Against the Fall of Night and Childhood's End as progress, or improvements on today's humanity.
Religions and Movements. Against the Fall of Night (Chapter 8) has a religious movement, which worships the Old Ones. It eventually drops out of mainstream society, building an alternative society of its own.
Similarly, in "The Lion of Comarre" (Chapter 2) the Decadents movement offers an alternative to mainstream society, eventually building its own city. However, the Decadents are not a religious group, even though they have moral values differing from mainstream society.
Both groups are long-lived, and deeply committed. Neither group is purely political. Such religious or value-based groups allow Clarke to look at social dissent, but without invoking radical politics that is politically based. "Earthlight" (the short story version) makes negative satirical comments about "reformers", expressing what seems to be both distaste and disinterest on Clarke's part in dissenting political movements.
The Decadents are likely inspired by the real-life late 19th Century Decadents, and their British representatives, the Aesthetic movement, led by Walter Pater and Oscar Wilde. Like many other traditions invoked by Clarke, the Aesthetic movement is deeply British. Also notable: Pater and Wilde were gay men, as was Clarke.
A Science Fiction Mystery Story. The hero of Against the Fall of Night is trying to solve two mysteries: What is beyond the city of Diaspar? What is the truth about humanity's past? The book shows him steadily answering both questions.
This gives Against the Fall of Night the structure of a mystery story: a tale in which a hero investigates and solves a mysterious situation.
However, Against the Fall of Night has little of the mechanism of traditional, non-science fiction mystery. Neither clues nor deduction play much role in finding the solution. Nor is a hidden villain revealed, unlike "Whodunit" mystery tales.
A Gay Subtext?. Five of the six main characters in Clarke's Against the Fall of Night are men. Most of the personal relationships are between men. Some of these relationships are emotionally important to the men: see Jeserac's feelings for Alvin (end of Chapter 11) and Rorden's relationship with Alvin (start of Chapter 12). The relationship that develops at the end between Vanamonde and Theon is also between two male characters, even if one of them is non-human.
The hero has no relationships with women. His sexual orientation is unspecified: he is never marked as straight or gay. This is unusual for books and films, which most frequently explicitly describe their heroes as heterosexual.
The idea that all the male characters are gay, and that their friendships have gay sexual dimensions, is consistent with the novel. However, the novel does not actually say this explicitly. It is also possible to read the book as a story which simply does not explore any of the characters' sexuality.
Poet A. E. Housman is the source of the book's title. Housman was gay, and was a favorite of gay writers of the era, also giving the title to Patrick White's mainstream novel The Tree of Man (1955), and being quoted by mystery writer Aaron Marc Stein in Sitting Up Dead (1958).
Some of the character types and kinds of relationships return in "The Wall of Darkness" (1949), a tale with all-male characters. In both works:
Earthlight alternates between two groups of protagonists: a spy Bertram Sadler, and a pair of young astronomers Conrad Wheeler and Sid Jamieson. Sadler is straight, and has a wife back home on Earth. But Wheeler and Jamieson have their primary relationship with each other, and function as a team throughout the book. They are explicitly discussed as a "couple" (last part of Chapter 9). No sexual orientation is assigned to them. But they can easily be seen as a gay pair. They recall the adventurous pairs of young men protagonists in John W. Campbell and Isaac Asimov.
The end of the story explains the solution in enormous detail. Partly this is an example of Clarke's stress on clarity and communication: he is an exceptionally clear writer throughout his books. But it also reflects the way the genre of mystery fiction stresses clear solutions to its mysteries, with everything spelled out in detail during the solution at the end of the story.
Quasi-Medieval. "The Wall of Darkness" (1949) has a quasi-medieval feel:
Influence on Le Guin?. "The Wall of Darkness" might have influenced Ursula K. Le Guin:
It has aspects of a "future history", showing the beings undergo a series of developments over time.
"Second Dawn" has links to Against the Fall of Night. In both:
A big negative: the relentless sexism. The hero's wife is uninterested in ideas, perhaps incapable of serious thinking, and obsessed with jewels and personal display.
However much of the second half of "Jupiter Five" is a let-down: the tale stops focussing on the aliens, and looks at silly intrigue with a rival explorer. "Jupiter Five" would be better if it were longer and had more about the aliens.
BIG SPOILERS. The description of the huge alien construction reminds one of Simak's prior tale "Limiting Factor" (1949).
"Jupiter Five" contains witty reflexive looks at contemporary publishers, such as Life magazine and Sidgwick & Jackson. Clarke's "I Remember Babylon" will mention Clarke's involvement with the Book of the Month Club.
The art gallery recalls the paintings and carvings on display in the building in "The Lion of Comarre" (Chapter 4). Both are huge buildings filled with a vast number of art treasures, the product of an entire culture.
Social Science Fiction. Earthlight is one of Clarke's books that comes closest to the Campbell ideal of "Social Science Fiction". It depicts a future society on the Moon in fascinating detail. Within that society, it also gives a detailed picture of the workings of a futuristic astronomical observatory.
Geometry. Curved geometry plays a role in many objects and environments:
A Science Fiction Mystery Story. Earthlight has a mystery plot fairly common in spy tales: who is the mole that is leaking information, and how are the leaks occurring technically? Such mystery puzzles already had a long history by 1955. Please see my list of Information Leaks in Mystery Fiction.
Aspects of the mystery recall the (non-science-fiction) mystery novel They Watched by Night (1941) by John Rhode:
One should emphasize that Earthlight is full of originality, and that its signaling is based on creative ideas found only in Clarke.
Short Story to Novel. Earthlight was expanded and modified from a short story of the same name (1951). Much of the actual writing is new - and much better. The ideas are more imaginative and more poetic.
The "mysterious traitor" subplot is completely new in the novel, not present in the short story. Also new is the sleuth hero whose job it is to find the traitor.
The other four main characters made their debut in the short story. They are more developed in personality in the novel.
The short story has a brief witty passage not in the novel, describing how the appearance of various characters suggests they are any profession other than astronomers. It suggests the astronomers are "presenting themselves" with various images. This is fun. But it implies a certain irony and style manipulation among the characters, that is absent in the novel. By contrast, in the novel everyone is in deadly earnest at all times.
"The Roads Must Roll" (1940) is Heinlein's most impressive short story. It is richly inventive in its look at future technology leading to new social organization.
"Delilah and the Space Rigger" (1949) recalls "The Roads Must Roll", in showing a whole new technological infrastructure, and the society that develops out of it.
"Misfit" (1939) is the first of Heinlein's "big engineering projects in the future" tales, anticipating "The Roads Must Roll" and "Delilah and the Space Rigger". In both "Misfit" and "Delilah and the Space Rigger", we see the huge enterprise being built. "Misfit" also has elements of Cosmic Engineering: altering astronomical objects through human engineering, usually to benefit Mankind. Cosmic Engineering is associated with Edmond Hamilton and Otto Binder.
"Coventry" (1940), by contrast has little technology in it. It is mainly sociological. It casts a satiric look at Libertarian fantasies, contrasting them with grim realities.
Three of the stories give a vivid picture of life on a future moon colony: "The Black Pits of Luna" (1948), "It's Great to Be Back!" (1947), "The Menace from Earth" (1957).
I long since had read such later stories as Simak's "Target Generation" and Le Guin's "Paradises Lost". Both are earnest, serious-toned looks at moral choices faced by people on such starships. By contrast, "Universe" startles by its playful, comic, satirical tone. "Universe" also seems more experimental in its literary techniques, with its inclusion of verse.
Ideology. "Universe" refuses to endorse any historical group as Good Guys:
No one's beliefs in "Universe" are a matter of private conviction - instead, a viewpoint immediately links one to a political-and-social group. The religious are out to preserve the (lousy) traditional society; the young atheists are out to take ever the Ship, and plotting a genocide of the mutants. Both groups are seen as scientifically false and socially rotten.
The religious-government authorities such as the Captain, have their ideas implicitly compared to the way the Catholic Church treated Galileo:
Heinlein was a Methodist. He was raised in a strongly Methodist family, and he still self-identified himself as a Methodist in his non-fiction travel book Tramp Royale (1953-1954).
Ignorance. "Universe" is another Heinlein work where knowledge is NOT passed along through written form. One of the "root causes" of problems aboard the Ship is that there is no print or electronic transmission of ideas. There are old books, but apparently no new books or documents. And few people can read, or count. As in Starman Jones, knowledge is mainly passed along through apprenticeship: a highly inefficient route, in my judgement.
However, Have Space Suit - Will Travel looks at a contemporary US high school, where the curriculum and attitudes are so dumbed-down that its graduates are not college-ready. The teenage hero has to stand consciously outside of his society, and pursue a vigorous course of self-study, just to be qualified to enter a university engineering program. Here is a whole society, filled with books and literate members, that in spite of these advantages has dumbed itself down nearly to the level of the Ship in "Universe".
The last two-thirds of Starman Jones are thinner. The endless political intrigues among the astrogaters are unpleasant. Worse, they lack plausibility, especially in the complete lack of built-in safety features or double checking over their calculations. This criticism has the benefit of hindsight, to be fair: safety features in software are standard in the 2000's, whereas Heinlein was trying to extrapolate in 1953!
Similarly, the photographing of the records is interesting (start of Chapter 14), but one wonders why such archiving doesn't happen automatically. In the future technology of Murray Leinster's "The Ethical Equations" (1945) for example, it likely would have.
Real knowledge of How To Do Things in Starman Jones is restricted to a few men with practical experience. They can teach young men in person. But there are no textbooks, training films, training software or encyclopedias in this future, to share knowledge on a massive scale. Modern society since the 1700's has depended on such books to spread the principles behind its industrial base. Admittedly, in the future world of Starman Jones, all professions and knowledge are highly restricted by Guilds. Still, one wonders if one is also seeing a none-too-workable prejudice in Heinlein against book learnin' and in favor of Practical Men.
So what is different about the future in "Code Three", from the 1963 United States? Mainly the high tech police vehicles, and the very high speed highways. Most of "Code Three" is devoted to pictures of all the advanced technology mounted on the giant police truck the heroes drive. Raphael shows imagination and logic, in his endlessly detailed depictions of this technology. This is the center of the story.
The high speed freeways are also logically imagined. They are visibly influenced by the advanced highways in Robert Heinlein's "The Roads Must Roll" (1940), one of the most famous and admired of sf stories. Heinlein broke up his roads into a series of lanes, each moving at a different speed, from slow to fast. The freeways in "Code Three" are also broken up into zones, in which cars move at different ranges of speed. Heinlein featured a corps of professional highway workers, and buildings and equipment for them; the highways in "Code Three" are similarly patrolled and maintained by a specialized Patrol.
Before either Heinlein or Raphael, Hugo Gernsback had two lanes on pedestrian sidewalks in Ralph 124C41+ (1911) (Chapter 4). The lanes were for pedestrians moving in different directions, not speeds. And Gernsback's pedestrians are on motorized roller skates he called "coasters".
The future in "Code Three" is full of constant communication, resembling a bit today's society and its in-touch members. However, communication in "Code Three" is above all the human voice saying things, transmitted by radio. Radio was THE high tech medium of the 1940's, and it wowed many authors of science fiction and scientific detective stories. It is still central in "Code Three" in 1963. "Code Three" does include a fascinating scene where information is read off metal tags by a machine, interpreted, and transmitted by radio. So Raphael was envisioning other kinds of data communication. But there is no conception of an Internet routinely transmitting every sort of text and data; rather, specialized machines are built occasionally to transmit important kinds of data such as those on the metallic tags.
The heroine is a well-developed person, in the depiction of her professional activities. This is an implicitly feminist portrait, with her working in a position of equality with the men.
"Code Three" recalls 1950's films, about California highways and vehicles:
William P. McGivern wrote "Killer on the Turnpike" (1961), a non-science fiction novella about State Police hunting for a murderer on what seems to be the New Jersey Turnpike. The highway and the police patrolling it are organized on similar lines as in "Code Three". This might not indicate that "Killer on the Turnpike" was an influence on "Code Three". It might simply mean that both stories are grounded in the reality of the US highway system in the 1960's. Both authors show mobile police vehicles talking by radio to dispatchers in fixed locations; highway entrance and exit points as key areas of possible interception; milestones used to identify locations on the highway; information connections to national crime fighting networks. Both works also feature bad weather to make the highway scenes more suspenseful.
Code Two and Death in Small Doses are examples of the era's semi-documentary school of films about elite government agencies fighting crime in a high tech world. Such films were shot in a near-documentary manner, showing how their organizations functioned in detail. One can see related ideas in prose mystery fiction like "Killer on the Turnpike" and prose science fiction like "Code Three". These works are also strongly technological.
These works are not explicitly political, but on reflection they do have a political dimension. "Code Three", "Killer on the Turnpike", Code Two and Death in Small Doses all glorify government agents and their organizations. They came from an era when patriotic Americans valued their government. After 1978, radical conservatives and libertarians would constantly belittle and demonize government. They have done everything possible to fire government employees and defame their work. These stories and films reflect the attitudes of an earlier and more practical time, when the real life achievements of government agencies were recognized and applauded.
Like some of Kornbluth's science fiction tales, "A Ghoul and His Money" shows contemporary science. In this case, the science is the technology surrounding ceramics. As usual in Kornbluth, the science is depicted in rich detail. It gives the reader an inside look, at part of the contemporary world.
Science is used both by the narrator-detective, and by a woman in the story. This gives "A Ghoul and His Money" an aspect of Scientific Detection.
For such a brief tale, there is a surprising amount of mystery in "A Ghoul and His Money". All the mysteries are resolved by the tale's end.
"A Ghoul and His Money" deals with women's issues, long before they became prominent in the 1970's. Woman's employment, equal attitudes to women, and spousal abuse are all examined trenchantly. Kornbluth manages to cover the core of these issues concisely, without watering down their content or significance. He also injects notes of satire and dark humor, not surprisingly in an author whose science fiction is famous for its satire.
"A Ghoul and His Money" is also typical of Kornbluth, in that it shows us economically struggling people.
Social Science Fiction. "Ararat" is Social Science Fiction. In other words, it creates a new society, run on different principles from our own.
Unlike much is Social Science Fiction, "Ararat" is not set in the future or another planet. Instead its new society takes place in contemporary times a remote desert area of the US Southwest, isolated from most of contemporary society and culture.
Unlike some Social Science Fiction, the society "Ararat" does not all follow from a single social or ethnological change. SPOILERS. It has such a change (refugee aliens crash land on Earth, must build new life there). But it also incorporates a multiplicity of ideas unrelated to this. These have to do with:
I think Henderson wants readers to solve this puzzle, long before the narrator does. At the end, the narrator kicks herself for not figuring the puzzle out sooner.
The mystery puzzle helps bring plot and structure to the tale.
A similar mystery puzzle, this time about a little boy, is in "The Indelible Kind" (1968). Both puzzles involve explaining the behavior of a new character who has just moved to an area. Both puzzles have similar solutions. Both puzzles seem intended to be simple for the reader to solve.
Feminism?. There is discussion about whether or not Henderson's works have feminist aspects, or whether they embody stereotypical roles for women.
The women schoolteachers in "Ararat" and "The Indelible Kind" are hard-working professionals, who do well in a demanding job. This is consistent with feminist views. Admittedly, teaching school was stereotyped as woman's work in the 1950's - so "Ararat" does not offer a challenge to job-norms of its era. But the way "Ararat" depicts a woman working hard and succeeding at her job is nothing to be ashamed of either, from a feminist standpoint.
The Old Ones who lead the alien society include both men and women. This can also be seen as feminist.
Influence. "Ararat" anticipates ideas in John Wyndham's Re-Birth (1955).
Social Science Fiction. "Created He Them" is Social Science Fiction. In other words, it imagines a new society, based on innovative scientific and social events that have transformed our contemporary world.
Influence. A plot idea in "Created He Them" anticipates Philip K. Dick's The Game-Players of Titan (1963), one of his best novels.
"When the Mountain Shook" (1956) has its moments, and is quite readable. It's a creditable tale, but doesn't reach the level of "Junior". It suffers from too much emphasis on psychic powers. On the plus side, it has plenty of plot and science fiction situations.
"Single Combat" (1955) is an odd, paranoiac fantasy. It never becomes at all believable, even by the indulgent standards one applies to the Fantastic. I think it is a bad story.
"First Contact" (1945), traditionally Leinster's most famous tale, is interesting when discussing the alien's communication through infrared, part of Leinster's interest in communication media. The Crab Nebula parts are lively. But it is also too militaristic for comfort. Leinster sometimes depicts both the social and natural worlds as full of enemies who want to destroy each other. Sometimes, as in "De Profundis" (1945), this can be a basis for an imaginative story. But often times, it just seems depressing.
Leinster also likes portraits of societies breaking down into complete disorder. This is funny and remarkable in "A Logic Named Joe". It is less appealing in the sinister opening sections of "Sidewise in Time" (1934).
"Evidence" takes place on a run-down cattle ranch in modern day 1919 Texas, near the Mexican Border. Perhaps any story set on a Texas cattle ranch should be classified as a Western. But Western elements are not stressed. Instead, the tale seems more like a "detective story set in a rural region". The hero seems more like a folksy man of the countryside, rather than any sort of cowboy.
Mission of Gravity shows the influence of an early story by "Lee Gregory" (Milton A. Rothman), "Heavy Planet" (1939). Both deal with planets with huge gravity, and both have protagonists who are alien life forms, adapted to the enormous gravitational pull. In both, the aliens are intelligent and technological, but not as advanced as the humans who have just arrived on the planet for the first time. In both, obtaining new science and technology from the humans is a major goal of the local aliens. Clement's alien society is more idealistic than the one in "Heavy Planet", with the aliens more interested in commerce, and less in war and fighting.
Mission of Gravity is at its best in its opening chapters (1-6), when it offers a pure science fictional look at an initial exploration of an alien planet. After this point, the tale becomes more of an adventure story, with less sf invention. The opening is the part most closely linked with Clement's essay "Whirligig World".
Landscape and Influences. The section about the cliff (Chapter 9) recalls an episode in the film The Big Trail (Raoul Walsh, 1930), a Western movie about a wagon train. The cliff section is something of a return to the mood of the opening (Chapters 1-6).
As a science fiction novel depicting adventure among oceans, islands and dramatic landscapes, Mission of Gravity has a bit of the feel of H.G. Wells' The Island of Dr. Moreau (1896).
The bay (Chapter 11) recalls landscapes in Poe's "The Domain of Arnheim" and "Landor's Cottage".
Perhaps Mission of Gravity in turn influenced the later Riverworld books of Philip Jose Farmer. Mission of Gravity (Chapter 10) shows advanced beings boating down a river, and attacked by a warlike tribe who live on the nearby shore: something that returns in the Riverworld. However, Riverworld reportedly originated in an unpublished novel Owe for the Flesh written in 1952, a year before Mission of Gravity was serialized in 1953.
Arthropods. The main alien group in Mission of Gravity is clearly inspired by the Arthropods: the widespread real-life group of animals that includes arachnids, insects and crustaceans. A terrific documentary on Arthropods is The Incredible March of the Spiny Lobsters (1976), an episode of the TV series The Undersea World of Jacques Cousteau.
Features of the aliens that recall Arthropods:
The human hero's last name Lackland recalls Lackland Air Force Base, named in 1948 for Brigadier General Frank Lackland. Hal Clement had a long career with the US Air Force. Lackland Air Force Base plays a major role in Air Force training, reminding us that Clement was a teacher both in the Air Force and his civilian job. And that humans spend much time training aliens in Mission of Gravity.
Science: Need for Unconventional Innovation. Science, as an intellectual discipline, is a topic that runs through Mission of Gravity.
The astronomy of the Mesklinites, and their bowl-model of their planet, is at a similar scientific level to the real-life ancient Greek astronomy of Ptolemy. Both are at a similar stage of scientific development:
"Whirligig World", Clement's article on the creation of Mission of Gravity, depicts him as challenging conventional science fiction truisms in the basic premises of his novel. Such a challenge to conventional ideas also underlies the depiction of science in Mission of Gravity. Both the Mesklinite view of their planet, and human meteorologists' ideas on the sea, need to be replaced with improved models that challenge conventional ideas.
Sociology and Race. Mission of Gravity can be read as an allegory, about the present and near future relationships between Westerners and the Third World. The human hero and allies are humans with advanced technology; the alien is a highly intelligent and hard-working member of alien group with a much lower level of technological and scientific development. The book ultimately shows scientific knowledge flowing to the alien society, which will use it to advance. The humans in the novel can stand for the West, with its advanced science; the aliens might stand for Third World countries in Asia and Africa, who will be learning science from the West, and developing into high tech societies in the near future. And just as the aliens are equally as intelligent and capable as the humans in Mission of Gravity, so, the book implies, Asians and Africans are just as intelligent and capable as whites.
As best one can tell, this parallel is not explicitly made in the novel. But it forms such an exact parallel to the real-life situation of the West and the Third World in 1953, that it seems likely that Mission of Gravity has such implicit meaning.
Mission of Gravity is strongly admiring of its alien heroes, and strongly supportive of their quest to advance technologically. Looked at as an allegory, Mission of Gravity is similarly strongly in favor of the Third World, and its struggle to advance in science and technology.
Hal Clement's real last name, Stubbs, is one with roots in British history: there is a major English painter George Stubbs. One suspects that Hal Clement was a New England WASP. He was friends with the Jewish Isaac Asimov, with whom he brainstormed Mission of Gravity. One sees parallels with the human hero Charles Lackland of Mission of Gravity. Lackland is also an English-sounding name. And he works with biochemist Dr. Rosten. Rosten is a Jewish name. Human society in Mission of Gravity is thus typified by WASPs and Jews working together: a anti-racist portrait of the United States and Western society in 1953.
Diplomat. We learn human hero Charles Lackland is a diplomat (Chapter 5). This suggests a hidden background and agenda to the character.
Government: A Positive View. The science project on which all the human characters work is important to governments (middle of Chapter 5). Although the book doesn't say explicitly, it is likely government-funded or somehow government-sponsored. Both the project and the humans are portrayed in a mainly positive light. Implicitly, so are the governments that fund or sponsor the project. They all seem to be mainly benevolent.
Mission of Gravity implicitly depicts these future governments and the people who work for them as mainly good, practical and effective. Mission of Gravity is NOT a libertarian work. It shows none of the anti-government attitude that drives today's conservative libertarians.
The governments concerned with the project are "the governments of ten planets". This phrase suggests that these are world-governments: governments who run entire planets. Mission of Gravity thus shows humans developing world-government in the future. World-government was a cause advocated by H.G. Wells.
On the other hand, the alien governments seen are mainly portrayed negatively: the forest people (Chapter 10), the island people (Chapter 12). The forest people are a "primitive" society with a dictatorial king, and the book's disdain seems mainly a distaste for dictatorial rule. However, the islanders are more advanced. The negative view of the island people might thus be more relevant as a critique of contemporary society.
Economics. The aliens have a trading system, that looks capitalistic. Clever traders who take risks and make money were much admired by Astounding Science Fiction. See also Simak's "The Big Front Yard" (1958).
The "port fees" assessed by the island people are seen negatively, essentially as extortion (Chapter 12). This might, or might not, be a negative look at government taxation in general.
But we actually learn almost nothing about the humans' economic system. Cost is important to them: we hear about how valuable the lost rocket is, and how much it cost to produce. But otherwise economics is invisible among the humans.
This means that Mission of Gravity does not make any predictions about the future of humanity's economic systems.
The positively portrayed alien traders might be interpreted as an endorsement of capitalism as a system. But the evasiveness in Mission of Gravity about the future of humans' economics suggests interpretation should proceed with caution.
The opening of "Whirligig World" describes structural aspects of the "problem" science fiction tale. Although Clement does not make this explicit, or even mention mystery fiction, his ideas seem like well-known concepts about the mystery story genre, modified by him to analyze science fiction:
Cordwainer Smith's science fiction resembles Isaac Asimov's Foundation Trilogy, in that it takes place in a far future universe that is completely different from both today's society, and the work of other science fiction writers. Both writers are also more interested in showing a future humanity, than they are in exploring alien worlds or beings. Both writers' works have aspects of the thriller, and both writers' thrillers involve melodrama, in which two sides of a moral dispute compete for their teams' success.
Both writers were also scholars in their private life, Smith being a Sinologist with State Department connections. I once interviewed a State Department colleague of Smith's, and he told me that Smith was the wittiest storyteller he had ever met, a man with an amazing flow of monologue.
"The Ballad of Lost C'Mell" is set at a later time period than "The Dead Lady of Clown Town" in Smith's future history and hence was placed later in The Best of Cordwainer Smith. However, I believe "C'Mell" should be read first, to give the two tales maximum impact.
In "Drunkboat" (1963), Smith incorporates large sections of Arthur Rimbaud's poem "Le Bateau ivre" (1871). "Drunk boat" is just a literal translation of Rimbaud's title. Here Rimbaud's non-rational visions are made to represent the experience of space travel. There are precedents for such hallucinatory and verbally symbolist depictions of space flight, in Isaac Asimov's "Escape!" (1945) and "I'm in Marsport Without Hilda" (1957). Smith includes other such avant-garde passages in his work, notably the opening of Norstrilia.
Smith's title is a variation on a quote from William Cowper's hymn "Light Shining Out of Darkness", the one that begins "God moves in mysterious ways, His wonders to perform". As an Anglican, Smith presumably sang this hymn many times in church. Cowper's hymn states that "Blind unbelief is sure to err, and scan His work in vain. But God is His own interpreter, and He will make it plain." Perhaps from here, Smith developed the sf concept of a "scanner". It is perhaps another example of a sort of pun or word play leading to creative ideas for Smith.
The Scanners as a group resemble many disparate kinds of organizations. These show Smith's interest in and creativity with social organizations that have quasi-governmental roles:
The exploited habermen are at first depicted as condemned criminals. They are called the scum of the earth, and are at first seen as just "bad" people. But gradually one becomes aware that the habermans are also drawn from "heretics": people whose views society finds intolerable. This is part of Smith's look at social dissenters and innovators. Such social dissidents are often given terrible difficulties by society in Smith - but often wind up having a deep influence on society, too. It is part of the dual vision Smith has on the importance of social non-conformists and innovators.
The Scanners sometimes communicate by light signals and other visual means. Such light signals recall a bit the "light show" in Hugo Gernsback's description of futuristic New York, in Ralph 124C41+ (1911).
The well written ending of Ria evokes the inner nature of each character in the form of music. This music all blends together and forms a hidden music of humanity, which Smith calls the Instrumentality of Mankind. It is clear that this is another name for the Tao, the hidden inner principle of reality, in Taoist philosophy. Smith evoked Taoism sympathetically in one of his last stories, "Under Old Earth" (1966), and clearly Taoist ideas were important in his work. Smith used the same name for the governing body of his far future sf tales. It is unclear whether he was already planning these sf stories, and based the name and concept in Ria on this sf government, or whether the reverse was true. I suspect the sf ideas came first. In the sf stories, the phrase "Instrumentality of Mankind" contains no musical meanings, or references to musical instruments. It refers instead to its members being the "Instruments" of humanity, carrying out their wishes, and achieving their goals. The use of the same name to refer to the Tao in Ria, and the giving this name a musical significance, seems to be kind of inspired pun. A pun created not as humor, but as an enhancer of meaning and allusion.
The hero is unusual in that he is an Aleut. He spent World War II undercover posing as a Japanese civilian, and now is fishing for Soviet secrets in Siberia.
Only some details about a crashed pilot in the early chapters seem especially Smithian. (This thriller is my excuse for including Cordwainer Smith in this Mystery Guide. Mainly, I just wanted to discuss this major author.)
Thinking. "The Rose" shows the possibilities of thought. It deals with many different modes of cognition: music, science, mathematics, paintings, dance, color, automatic writing, graphs of equations, paradoxes, games like chess. It deals with possible translations from one mode to another, such as mathematics to music, and structures found in both science and art.
A non-fiction work that shows many media of thought is A Computer Perspective (1973), by Charles and Ray Eames. This classic book shows the rise of computer technology. It takes a deep dive into human thought, showing how mathematics and computing permeate human history and society. It shows how human life is based on thinking. Reading A Computer Perspective and "The Rose" together will open up new insights into how human life is based in thought, including mathematics.
Campbell era sf took an interest in cognition. Heinlein's "Gulf" and Asimov's "Jokester" are examples. "The Rose" is one of the deepest dives into cognition in Golden Age sf. Please see this article's section on Cognition.
Thomas Carlyle's On Heroes (1840) contains six lectures. The third, "The Hero as Poet" investigates the idea that Nature and humans are music, when looked at deeply. Quotes: "All deep things are Song. It seems somehow the very central essence of us, Song" and "The Greeks fabled of Sphere-Harmonies: it was the feeling they had of the inner structure of Nature; that the soul of all her voices and utterances was perfect music." and "See deep enough, and you see musically; the heart of Nature being everywhere music, if you can only reach it." This is perhaps a related idea to the depiction in "The Rose" of mathematics and music being translatable into each other. Orson Welles cited Carlyle in his documentary film Filming Othello (1978). Welles claimed that the film medium is musical, when looked at deeply. This is another equivalence between two modes of thought, film and music.
Please see my picks of Classical Music.
Anticipating Kornbluth. "The Rose" anticipates Cyril M. Kornbluth's short story "Gomez" (1954). Both deal with scientists trying to create unified theories. "The Rose" describes attempts to unify nearly all of science. By contrast, Gomez is trying to unify physics, a more restricted but still vast domain. Gomez is trying to create a unified field theory in physics: still a goal of much real life physics.
If "The Rose" compares science and mathematics to classical music, "Gomez" uses a metaphor of a chess grand master to suggest the mental workings of its scientific genius.
"Gomez", like "The Rose", shows a state security apparatus surrounding the genius scientist.
Anticipating Le Guin. "The Rose" anticipates subjects in Ursula K. Le Guin's The Dispossessed (1974). SPOILERS. Both works:
References. "The Rose" cites "Alexander's painting, Lady on a Couch, where the converging stripes of the lady's robe carry the eye forcibly from the lower left margin to her face at the upper right." (Chapter 15) Best guess: this refers to John White Alexander's painting "Repose" (1895). Both "Repose" and another famous Alexander painting "Isabella and the Pot of Basil" (1897) indeed show a striking sense of design, with interesting lines making up the composition. John White Alexander's son was mathematician James Waddell Alexander II, a founder of Knot Theory. The Alexander family themselves embodied "Science and Art".
The finale shows Weber's waltz "Invitation to the Dance" starting in the background. This is perhaps a reference to the ballet The Spectre of the Rose (1911), which used the Weber as its music. This work was produced by the famed Ballets Russes.
Mystery. The Paradox Men introduces mysteries right away. SPOILERS:
Future History. The life story of Muir (Chapter 2 of The Paradox Men) has elements of a Future History. His life milestones are linked to key moments in the development of this future society.
Social Science Fiction. There is much discussion of the sinister economics of slavery (Chapters 2, 5, 6). This is in the Campbell tradition of Social Science Fiction: a detailed look at a systematically different society. Slavery is relentlessly seen as horrifying in The Paradox Men.
The Paradox Men places much emphasis on the origins of slavery, the economic and political forces that sustain it, and solutions that might bring it to an end. This look at "origins, causes and cures" is somewhat different from much other Social Science Fiction.
Slavery in The Paradox Men is not linked to race. Instead it is compared to slavery in the Ancient World.
Links to "The Rose". The Paradox Men has subjects in common with "The Rose". Usually these subjects are transformed between the two works, however:
Cognition. The use of microfilm to present "the sum total of human knowledge" (Chapter 3) recalls the proposals in H.G. Wells' non-fiction book World Brain (1936-1938).
The Microfilm Mind can only present partial knowledge to those who give him queries. This is a good device for moving the plot forward. It also recalls the cryptic answers of the Oracle of Delphi, in Ancient Greece.
Mathematics. Concepts in The Paradox Men are often presented in terms of mathematics. SPOILERS:
Toynbee. The Paradox Men cites British historian Arnold J. Toynbee, and discusses his ideas in some detail (Chapter 6). I'm not a historian, have not read Toynbee, only summaries of his work, and am thus not qualified to discuss his work.
The Wikipedia article on Toynbee implies Toynbee's most influential book was the 1947 one-volume abridgment of Toynbee's A Study of History. This "sold over 300,000 copies in the U.S.", an astonishing number for an academic scholarly work. It quotes Michael Lang: "Toynbee was perhaps the world's most read, translated, and discussed living scholar." The article also states "The press printed innumerable discussions of Toynbee's work". Toynbee was thus at the peak of his influence when The Paradox Men (1949, 1953) was published. The Toynbee ideas included in The Paradox Men are indeed from A Study of History.
Despite being a non-historian I'm going to risk a comment. Toynbee's systematic, comparative method might be seen (accurately or not) as an attempt to write history using scientific methods. Toynbee's work thus might appeal to science fiction writers, always looking out for advances in science.
Toynbee's ideas can be seen as a way of thinking about history. They are thus part of Harness' interest in methods of thinking and cognition.
Economics and Rivalry. Stingingly negative comments are made about "free enterprise" (end of Chapter 6). This must have been a controversial opinion in the anti-Communist 1949-1953 era. Capitalism is still an official system in America Imperial (or Imperium) in 2177, the year in which The Paradox Men is set.
The hero is masquerading as a professor from the rival Eastern Federation. He is allegedly from Kharkov in Ukraine. In one of his French speeches he uses the word "tovarich" (Chapter 7). Tovarich means "Comrade", the traditional Communist greeting. This suggests that the Eastern Federation is heir to 20th Century Communism.
The 2177 rivalry between America Imperial and the Eastern Federation thus recalls the real-life 1949 contest between the United States and the Soviet Union.
HUAC?. Among the sinister officials of the evil government, is the Minister of Subversive Activities (Chapter 2). This perhaps recalls the real-life House Un-American Activities Committee (HUAC), then at the peak of its activity. The Minister is seen negatively - and if this is a reference to HUAC, it means that HUAC is also seen negatively.
Thurmond. The head of the sinister government police is Thurmond. In 1949, this would have recalled the real-life Governor Strom Thurmond, who ran for President in 1948 on a racist anti-Civil Rights platform. The Thurmond in The Paradox Men is a vicious villain. Likely this is also a negative comment on the real-life Strom Thurmond.
The Ball. The big 2177 diplomatic and government ball (Chapters 6, 7) bears an odd resemblance to a 1940's Washington party. Big shots there include a Senator, a banker and Ambassador: figures one could meet at a real-life 1949 Washington fete. The whole thing recalls the Washington society galas in the 1940's mystery novels of Leslie Ford, such as The Murder of a Fifth Columnist (1941), Murder in the O.P.M. (1942) or The Woman in Black (1947). As in Ford, such parties allow women to attend socially, and mingle with male government officials and businessmen. (The evil society in The Paradox Men is sexist and male-dominated.)
The ball also recalls fancy balls in tales of international intrigue. For example, the German Embassy Ball in Ashton-Kirk: Secret Agent (1912) (start of Chapter 22) by John T. McIntyre. McIntyre emphasizes the brilliant color of the spectacular dress uniforms of various nations worn by men at the ball. Similarly, The Paradox Men talks about "the bright-plumaged males" at the ball (start of Chapter 7). It also cites "the brightly uniformed reception master" (Chapter 6). By contrast the sinister police at the ball are in gray. This gives them a serious, ominous edge.
It is possible that Harness was directly influenced by Ford or McIntyre. But it is also possible that all three writers are simply part of a long tradition of depicting such government fetes.
Stockton. "The Lady and the Tarsier", the title of Chapter 2, echoes the famous story "The Lady, or the Tiger?" (1882) by Frank R. Stockton.
The barbaric cruelty of court life in "The Lady, or the Tiger?" anticipates the lifestyles of the sinister government officials in The Paradox Men. Unfortunates being forced into life-or-death wagers by powerful officials occur in both "The Lady, or the Tiger?" and The Paradox Men (first part of Chapter 3).
Its overall approach recalls a notable non-sf short story, Douglass Welch's "Mrs. Union Station" (1937). Both tales offer good-natured, but pointed satire on a group of hobbyists who carry their passion to extreme lengths: model railroad enthusiasts in Welch, chess club members in Harness. Both tales are knowing "inside" looks, filled with satiric detail. Both stories are looks at what we would now call a "subculture", a sub-world filled with people with different values and activities than the world at large. The specific events in Harness' "The Chessplayers" are quite different from anything in Welch, though.
Links to The Paradox Men. The animal in "The Chessplayers" recalls the tarsier in The Paradox Men. SPOILERS. Both animals have some capabilities of human thought. This gives them a science fiction dimension.
The way the chess club treats members the same despite their outside rank or wealth, echoes in a comic way the democratic finale of The Paradox Men. And it shows equality happening in the contemporary USA, rather than in a future society as in The Paradox Men. Both tales are inspiring.
Both "The New Reality" and "The Tetrahedron" examine famous scientists of the past. They postulate that these scientists had ideas that are now lost to modern science. This premise is implausible, looked at from stern standards of realism. But it does make for interesting sf.
The finale of The Paradox Men (Chapter 21) looks at a series of famous scientists from the past. But NOT with a suggestion that they had ideas now lost. This passage in The Paradox Men does have a bit of the same feel as "The New Reality".
"Lethary Fair" echoes Harness traditions, in its own comic way:
"Lethary Fair" sometimes seems to be parodying cyberpunk, especially William Gibson and the film Blade Runner (1982). "Lethary Fair" includes information transported by emplanted mind chip, like Gibson's "Johnny Mnemonic" (1981). And a beautiful female android, like Blade Runner.
Cyberpunk featured a world that is decayed socially while technologically advanced. But cyberpunk's societies, however socially decayed, tend to feature the most advanced, glamorous cities: Gibson's work is in the Sprawl, a futuristic version of the Boston-New York-Washington corridor, while Blade Runner is inspired by Kyoto and other high tech Japanese cities. By contrast, the baggy-pants comedy of "Lethary Fair" is set in a socially decayed version of a small town in the South, full of good old boys and local characters. It is a deliciously low-rent version of cyberpunk.
"The Minority Report" recalls ideas and approaches used by Clifford D. Simak. One of the most powerful ideas in Simak's City, is a future human society in which no man has killed another for decades. In City, this is achieved through advances in human civilization: people achieving a more peaceful future. In Dick's "The Minority Report", such a future without murder has come about through technological innovation instead. While this is less idealistic, perhaps, it is still an important concept. Dick is to be congratulated for having done some original thinking about how such a society might come about and be maintained.
Simak's novella "Worlds Without End" (1956) combines the spy thriller with science fiction. Intrigue shows rival future organizations struggling for power. "The Minority Report" takes a similar approach. Dick shows a political dimension, by structuring this as a sinister military coup against a civilian government. Dick is expressing his pacifist convictions. Dick's story was published nearly a year before Simak's.
The hero of "The Minority Report" encounters or develops several different interpretations of events, over the course of the story. These different ways to see the tale's events can seem almost like "alternative realities". They emerge, seem very real, then suddenly collapse: all rather like the ways Reality itself sometimes collapses in other Dick stories.
The alternative explanations also seem like an approach derived from mystery fiction. Sleuths in mystery fiction often draw up tentative explanations of what they think might be going on. Sometimes these explanations of the tale's mysteries turn out to be true. Other times, these plausible explanations turn out to be utterly wrong, and collapse when confronted by new evidence.
I didn't like Steven Spielberg's film version of "The Minority Report". It drains all the political commentary out of Dick's story, betraying Dick's meaning. Filming "The Minority Report" as an action-and-special-effects film also seems wrong-headed. "The Minority Report" is a spy story. It could have been filmed with standard, traditional film techniques that emphasize story telling and suspense. And with little violence, action or special effects. Classic thrillers like Topaz (Alfred Hitchcock, 1969), Le Samourai (Jean-Pierre Melville, 1967) and A Dandy in Aspic (Anthony Mann, 1968) are the sort of movies that could serve as models for an ideal film version of "The Minority Report".
The opening (Chapters 1-5, start of Chapter 6) describes a future world. It follows the strict "social science fiction" paradigm: showing how society has been transformed by a series of technological innovations and scientific discoveries. "Social science fiction" is especially associated with editor John W. Campbell and his magazine Astounding Science Fiction. Dick was trained as a writer by Anthony Boucher, who published in Campbell's magazines.
The opening draws on early stories of Dick, but greatly extending their concepts in new directions:
For all his messy personal qualities, the hero Joe Chip's job has him using technical means to investigate and measure the world around him. His job is to discover and learn the real nature of the world, rather than just guessing or judging by appearances. This links him to the job of "detective" in mystery fiction, although Joe Chip has no official detective status.
After the opening, the story moves in drastically different directions (Chapter 6).
Putting Runciter in cold-pac, recalls the way Lord Running Clam's spores are gathered up in Clans of the Alphane Moon.
The funeral hymn Dies Irae, part of the Verdi Requiem (Chapter 7), describes the Last Judgement. So does the poem quoted in "Faith of Our Fathers", Dryden's "A Song for Saint Cecilia's Day".
The helicopter beanie (Chapter 7) is probably a homage to such beanies' inventor, science fiction writer Ray Nelson. Dick and Nelson collaborated on the novel The Ganymede Takeover.
Ellery Queen. A Mirror for Observers shows the influence of mystery writer Ellery Queen.
Ellery Queen set many works in the fictitious New England city of Wrightsville. Latimer, the Massachusetts city where A Mirror for Observers is set, resembles Wrightsville. Both are industrial cities of around ten thousand people. Both have the rich living on a hill. Both authors emphasize parks.
In the first Wrightsville book Calamity Town (1942) Ellery comes to town under a pseudonym, telling people (truthfully) he is a writer looking for a place to write his new book. The hero of A Mirror for Observers goes to Latimer, posing as an author looking for a room to write his new book. This is a false claim, unlike Ellery in Calamity Town.
Queen's The King Is Dead (1952) offers a cautionary look at the possible rise of Fascism in contemporary America. So does A Mirror for Observers.
The Wrightsville books include dancing and drama teacher Emmeline DuPré. A Mirror for Observers has Mrs. Agnes Mapp who taught art and music.
Ellery Queen wrote four novels about actor-turned-detective Drury Lane (1932-1933). Drury Lane has the ability to impersonate almost anyone, taking over their identity. So do the Martian characters in A Mirror for Observers. Drury Lane and other characters with impersonation ability are surveyed in section 9 of my article on Doubles.
Ellery Queen included a child prodigy in The Tragedy of Y (1932).
A hard-working Italian-American woman keeps a rooming house in Queen's "Money Talks" (1950). Ellery goes undercover as one of her roomers. She anticipates Rosa in A Mirror for Observers. The hero goes undercover at the rooming house in A Mirror for Observers too.
The Day the Earth Stood Still. The film The Day the Earth Stood Still (Robert Wise, 1951) anticipates A Mirror for Observers. Both have human-looking aliens who move into a rooming house and befriend a boy who lives there.
Teen Gangs. Sinister Billy Kell leads a teen gang in A Mirror for Observers.
A Mirror for Observers was published in early 1954. See also the teen gang in Step Child (Budd Boetticher, May 27, 1954), an episode of the TV series Public Defender.
Schools. A Mirror for Observers (Part one: end of Chapter 2) anticipates Robert Heinlein's Have Space Suit - Will Travel (1958) in criticizing education at public high schools as worthless.
SF Traditions. Theodore L. Thomas began his career with a collaboration with Charles L. Harness. "The Weather Man" embodies some Harness traditions:
As noted, the "cognitive" aspects of "The Weather Man" recall Harness, and the "new science" approach echoes Asimov. However, Thomas' specific ideas are original. And any writer who develops a "new science" faces extraordinary challenges. Thomas' approach may echo sf traditions from Asimov and elsewhere. But it is an important achievement in its own right.
A Story Sequence. In many ways "The Weather Man" is a series of three short stories. The three sections share a common background of a future Earth of weather control. But each one has new characters and a different setting and locale. Story sequences are common in science fiction and mystery fiction. "The Weather Man" is unusual in that its three stories were all published together, as a single work.
However, the science fiction plots and background of the three sections are closely linked.
Three Kinds of SF. The three sections embody three standard kinds of science fiction tales:
Ancestors?. The core premise of A Canticle for Leibowitz recalls H.G. Wells' film Things to Come (1936), another post-apocalyptic tale. Both are future histories, in which:
Other works in the post-apocalyptic tradition include Lewis Padgett's Mutant (1945, 1953) and John Wyndham's Re-Birth (1955).
A Lack of Science Fiction Ideas. I have mixed feelings about A Canticle for Leibowitz. Among its virtues: it is highly readable and has good storytelling. Among its faults: it has few original science fiction ideas. It sticks closely to the above standard paradigm of the post-apocalyptic tale. It introduces few other science fiction concepts.
Miller certainly knew how to develop a Campbell-style science fiction story, with original science fiction ideas, and which shows how these new ideas lead to a different, innovative society. Examples: his short works "Crucifixus Etiam", and especially "The Lineman". However, he mainly chose NOT to use such a Campbell approach in A Canticle for Leibowitz.
You could easily get the impression reading A Canticle for Leibowitz that it is the work of a naive, mainstream writer, who knew little about traditional science fiction techniques or structures. Not so: Miller's short fiction shows his skill with Campbellian science fiction techniques. And Miller regularly published in Campbell's magazine Astounding.
A Canticle for Leibowitz does in fact read like an almost mainstream novel: One that takes a science fiction premise, the post-apocalyptic tale, and then writes a mainly mainstream novel about it, with few sf ideas.
Underground. Some of the most vivid settings in the novel are underground chambers:
Other works by Miller include high-tech underground sites. Examples:
Space Colonization. The final third emphasizes how difficult it is for humans to live in colonies on other planets. The difficulties of space colonization are a central subject in Miller shorter works like "Crucifixus Etiam" (1953), "The Hoofer" (1955), "The Lineman" (1957).
Such Miller short works emphasize the horrible psychological difficulties, faced by workers in such inhospitable, stress-filled environments.
Miller had been a member of a bombing crew during World War II: a notoriously stressful work environment. One wonders if this helped inspire such short stories. A mainstream work that offers insights about bomber crews: Irwin Shaw's short story "Gunners' Passage" (1944). It shows originally virile young men on such crews undergoing complete physical and psychological collapse, due to pressures of their job.
Mutants and Color. Mutants in this post-atomic world are sometimes described in terms of body color:
Right to Life. The Catholic Church insists on mutants' right to life (start of Chapter 1). This makes a contrast to John Wyndham's Re-Birth (1955), in which religious fundamentalists try to exterminate mutants.
Thon Taddeo's struggle to flourish as an illegitimate child (first half of Chapter 13) also perhaps has a subtext of Catholic teachings on "right to life".
Collectives: Alternatives to Capitalism. The monks live collectively. Their monastery is a form of economic organization, that is non-capitalist. A Canticle for Leibowitz is thus a look at non-capitalist, collective social organization. The book is sometimes critical of the monastery, especially in Part I. Throughout Parts II and III, it is largely sympathetic to the monks. By contrast, the book is mainly critical of the world outside of the Church, offering scathing looks at war lords and outside governments.
The monks are not entirely separate from capitalism. They sell monastery products, such as the books they copy, thus having them take part in commerce. The commercial demand influences what sort of books they copy (Chapter 7). While the novel makes no explicit comment, it is hard not to feel that it disapproves of this commercial influence, implicitly suggesting that it leads to the copying of less worthwhile books.
Miller short works discuss economics:
Catholicism: Piety+Culture. Today, many Americans equate religion with theology. They see religion as theology and theology as religion. But historically many people over the centuries have stressed non-theological issues as central to their religion:
Among the music mentioned in "The Lineman" are Palestrina and plainchant: two key examples of Catholic sacred music.
Mathematics. A discussion of math equations, from a document written by a 20th century physicist, is interesting (Chapter 19). But it is hard to interpret, and to relate to concrete real-life math ideas. Here are some guesses - that may not be accurate.
A contracted derivative actually stand for a whole set of derivatives. Guess: this refers to tensors. Tensors were employed by Albert Einstein for the equations he developed in General Relativity. Einstein fell in love with tensors, admiring their power to compactly note complex mathematic concepts. Thon Taddeo expresses a similar enthusiasm, finding the idea downright "beautiful". Another guess: the unspecified 20th Century physics in this chapter, is actually an account of Einstein's General Relativity.
Next Taddeo talks about equations that stand not for "quantities", but which express a system of equations about a system of quantities. Guess: These equations deal with vectors or perhaps matrices. A further guess: Taddeo had never seen vector equations or matrix equations before. He had only seen equations dealing with isolated quantities: what mathematicians call "scalars". By contrast, vectors and matrices deal with whole systems of numbers simultaneously.
Origin of Humans. A discussion of the origin of humanity is tongue-in-cheek, with elements of satire. SPOILERS. First Taddeo rejects evolution, which the monks propose (Chapter 20). Here are religious people advocating evolution, and a secular scientist rejecting it: a role reversal of the real-life 19th Century development of the theory of evolution.
Next Taddeo proposes an idea which is clearly wrong. The monks suggest he is basing his concepts not on historical fact, but on a play whose fictitious events he has mistaken for fact (Chapter 22). This play is unnamed: but likely it is R.U.R. (Rossum's Universal Robots) (1920), a science fiction play by Karel Capek.
Allegorical Interpretation. The priest in A Canticle for Leibowitz suggests that the Creation account in Genesis should be interpreted allegorically, rather than literally (Chapter 22). This shows him accepting science rather than fundamentalism.
This view of evolution is widespread, almost universal among contemporary real-life Catholics. They see evolution as offering literal, scientific truth, and are whole-hearted supporters of evolution. And see Genesis as offering an allegory, while not literally true, that has spiritual and cultural value. Given the sympathetic treatment of the priest here, one strongly suspects that A Canticle for Leibowitz is advocating precisely this view.
The anthology Is God a Creationist?: The Religious Case against Creation-Science (1983) edited by Roland Mushat Frye, documents the views of many religious scholars who support evolution. The book includes Catholic, Protestant and Jewish scholars. One is Pope John Paul II.
The priest's advocacy of "allegorical interpretation" has deep roots in Catholic thought. Saint Thomas Aquinas recommended both literal and allegorical interpretations of Scripture.
Two Eras of Catholicism. Part I and Part II of A Canticle for Leibowitz take place around 600 years apart years apart. Knowledge and science greatly advance between the two Parts. Catholicism changes too:
The Coming of War. The final third of A Canticle for Leibowitz shows the coming of possible total war. It can be compared to Miller's brief but vivid short story "Way of a Rebel" (1954) (available free on-line at http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/32416).
Both tales "deconstruct" noble-sounding government statements, that make the war sound admirable. The tales make clear that this is manipulative propaganda.
"Way of a Rebel" gives its hero the option of taking part or refusing to take part in the war. This is a greater choice than most of the characters in A Canticle for Leibowitz have. "Way of a Rebel" spells out in intelligent detail, the various moral and practical issues involved. It thus gets to explore important ideas not found in A Canticle for Leibowitz.
British Police Mystery. The Investigation is set in Britain. It features an investigation by Scotland Yard: the approach pioneered in the 1920's by Freeman Wills Crofts. The Investigation also resembles Crofts in that we learn the ideas of the detectives throughout the story, rather than only at the end. However, The Investigation is not otherwise close to Crofts traditions or approaches. For example, The Investigation emphasizes cars and trucks, while Crofts loved trains, boats and motorcycles. And the police in The Investigation seem odd, eccentric or emotionally disturbed, while the Crofts School emphasizes how normal and everyday its policemen are.
SPOILERS. Aside from the hero's landlords, most of the characters in The Investigation are police, who serve as suspects. A British mystery novel with a cast of police suspects is Murder in Blue (1937) by Clifford Witting. (The title refers to the blue police uniforms worn by the book's suspects.) However Murder in Blue does not much resemble The Investigation.
British mysteries that like The Investigation study footprints in snow are less common than one might think. Dancing Death (1931) by Christopher Bush is an example.
Links to Solaris. The Investigation anticipates Solaris. In both:
The film The Lodger also anticipates The Investigation in emphasizing the lodging house where the hero rents rooms. And in showing British fogs.
Resurrection: Ancestors?. Long before Lem, resurrection was a regular theme in comic book writer Jerry Siegel, creator of Superman. Please see my list of Siegel's Resurrection tales.
Characters who are seemingly dead, but who come back to life, are a recurrent theme in the films of director Joseph H. Lewis. And in Murder Is My Beat (Edgar G. Ulmer, 1955). Please see these articles of mine for details. Murder Is My Beat especially anticipates The Investigation in the scene where a woman recognizes a living man, as a man who is supposed to be dead. In both Murder Is My Beat ands The Investigation this scene involves trains. Both also have scenes in the snow.
In prose mystery fiction the subject appears in Craig Rice, and in Margery Allingham's "The Case of the Late Pig" (1937).
There are many mysteries, often comic, about corpses that are kidnapped or moved about. Craig Rice wrote The Corpse Steps Out (1940), Frank Gruber The Mighty Blockhead (1941-1942), Robert Reeves Cellini Smith: Detective (1943). Alfred Hitchcock brought this tradition to the screen with The Trouble with Harry (1955). The Disappearing Corpse (1957) by James Warren is a comic mystery novel in this tradition. It resembles The Investigation in taking place in a remote area of rural Britain, and in emphasizing driving in heavy fog. Please see my list of Fog in Mysteries.
Multiple Solutions. The Investigation presents many tentative solutions throughout the novel. At the end, we get a naturalistic solution, "naturalistic" in the sense that it does not depend on science fictional ideas. Is this the "true" solution? Maybe, maybe not. I think The Investigation holds open the possibility that some of the earlier science fiction solutions might actually be correct, instead.
Adaptations. The Investigation was filmed at least twice for Polish television. The 1974 version directed by Marek Piestrak has been praised. It is part of a 2017 retrospective of Lem film adaptations screened at the prestigious Anthology Film Archives in New York City.
The ocean on Solaris makes highly complex geometric patterns, as an expression of its intelligence. Real life folk dancing in Eastern Europe often employs geometric patterns. See all the revolving circular forms in the Lithuanian folk dance Subatele.
Complexity. "Complexity" as a metric, a way to measure the depth of a thought or idea, was perhaps more popular in the 1960's than today. Classical music and jazz are distinguished from popular music by being far more complex. This was often cited as a virtue, and as a reason we should listen to classical music and jazz. Poetry was also seen as often highly complex.
The intelligent ocean in Solaris makes patterns that are too complex for humans to understand. Measured by the metric of complexity, these ocean thoughts are more advanced than human thought - because they are more complex.
Simplicity: Algorithms?. Seemingly the opposite of Complexity is Simplicity. Occam's Razor is the principle that if two rival scientific theories explain some aspect of reality, that the simpler theory is more likely to be true.
Martin Gardner pointed out that there is no explicit algorithm, that would precisely measure exactly how simple a theory is. I've seen research on some very restricted kinds of theories, that rigorously measure their simplicity. But I think that Gardner's point is still true: so far, there is no general algorithm that can measure how simple any theory is. And thus we cannot be rigorously sure that one theory actually IS simpler than another.
And similarly, there is no general algorithm that can precisely measure how complex an idea is.
Much Classical music and jazz are so much vastly more complex than many pop songs, that we can be sure they are more complex. But for closer cases, we still have no more than a "gut feel" for how complex a given idea is.
Please see my picks of Classical Music.
Adaptations and Influence. One wonders if The Cyberiad helped inspire The LEGO Movie (2014), with its heroes being "master constructors" in a world nearly entirely made of robot parts.
"The Seventh Sally, or How Trurl's Own Perfection Led to No Good" helped inspire Will Wright's video game SimCity (created 1985, distributed 1989). This story also parallels a long tradition of simulation computer software, stretching from the 1950's to the present.
The Cyberiad was made into an opera (1970) with music by Krzysztof Meyer. The opera seems mainly based on one section, "Tale of the Three Storytelling Machines of King Genius".
Ancestors?. Clifford D. Simak had long written about both robots, and the ability of machinery to enhance/influence artistic creativity. Simak's "Limiting Factor" (1949) anticipates some ideas in the middle section of Lem's "Altruizine".
Aleksandr Kuprin's "Liquid Sunshine" (1913) deals with a very large, multi-story machine. It perhaps influenced the huge machines in Lem. The young Lem worked as both a welder and auto mechanic: scenes of his heroes tinkering with machinery reflect a man who has worked with machinery in real life.
Poland's national literature remembers its medieval era. A book like Krzyzacy ("The Black Cross" or "The Teutonic Knights") (1897-1900) by Henryk Sienkiewicz is filled with sinister knights, kings and fighting. This novel was widely taught in Polish schools. A hugely popular hit film was made of it by director Aleksander Ford in 1960: a film seen by nearly every person in Poland. So the evil kings and regimes in The Cyberiad are grounded in realistic looks at the region's past. They are not simply fairy tales.
The way the robot can manufacture objects, and pull them out of a container in his belly in "A Good Shellacking", recalls the robot in the classic sf film Forbidden Planet (Fred M. Wilcox, 1956).
The cubical planet in "Altruizine" recalls the Bizarro World in Superman comic books, first seen in the comic book tale "The World of Bizarros" (Action Comics #263, April 1960).
Ancestors?: Burlesques. The "burlesque of fairy tales" tone of The Cyberiad perhaps recalls comics writer-artist Ed Wheelan. Wheelan made burlesques of both movie genres, in his series Minute Movies, and of fairy tales in Foney Fairy Tales. Wheelan's satire "Eyes of the Skull" (Flash Comics #18, June 1941) parodies conflict between the nations Agraria and Agressa. It perhaps anticipates the two countries in conflict in "The Trap of Gargantius".
The Space Child's Mother Goose (1958) by Frederick Winsor presented science-fiction variants on traditional nursery rhymes. It's a delightful book, and surprisingly deep in its mathematical and scientific ideas: also anticipating The Cyberiad.
Trurl's Machine. "Trurl's Machine" deals with a machine that has the wrong idea (two plus two equals seven) and which tries to force that idea on everyone else. It can be read as an allegory, about people who want to inflict bad science on the world, often for political motives:
The Trap of Gargantius. "The Trap of Gargantius" creates a detailed future society, with an innovative condition by the end of the tale. It thus follows the Campbell tradition of "social science fiction", which looks at such innovative future or alien societies. By contrast, such Campbellian alternate societies are not present in several other stories in The Cyberiad.
The Dragons of Probability. "The Dragons of Probability" invents a complete imaginary science of probability and nonexistence. As Lem points out in his commentary, the fictitious science is inspired by the real-life physics domains of quantum mechanics and particle physics. This invented science is skillful. It deserves applause both for its creativity and inventive detail, and the accurate, insightful way it mirrors the thinking of real-life physics and mathematics.
Lem had previously invented the fictitious science of "solaristics" in his novel Solaris (1961).
The Divine is transformed into the original-to-this-tale idea of the "Universal Matrix of Transfinite Transformations". Seeing the divine in an all-inclusive collection of all transformations is indeed a mathematically creative view of infinite possibility and structure.
Dragons can "hypercontiguate", a kind of multiplication. This allows dragons to take part in "algebra", such as group theory. Mathematicians love group theory and are eager to find such algebraic structures, in everything from matrices to Lie Algebras to knots. Dragons also have inverses: also a group theory concept. The multiple kinds of inverses perhaps invoke the mathematical theory of quaternions.
Probabilities of dragons have become something other than integers (whole numbers). Such non-integral values recall spin in particle physics. More distantly, they invoke non-integral dimensions in Hausdorff theory.
Trurl's Prescription. "Trurl's Prescription" opens with a good science fiction idea. SPOILERS. It shows a large group of robots, living not on a planet, but plugged into a huge machine they have built, near a star. This is perhaps a variation on the "The Trap of Gargantius": both deal with groups of robots, in both the robots are plugged into something. The rest of the tale is less interesting, offering more word-play than substance in its sf ideas. Its core plot twist is a variation on "The Offer of King Krool".
Altruizine. I disagree with the fundamental thesis of "Altruizine", that idealistic social reforms or innovations are doomed to failure. However, the colorful details of this story are inventive, making it enjoyable reading.
The final section is a story-within-the-story. SPOILERS. Its subject of information shared between minds, is broadly related to the mind-switching in "The Mischief of King Balerion". And both are related to ability of the ocean in Solaris to read minds and create things based on what it reads there.
Gay Themes. SPOILERS. The plugs in "The Trap of Gargantius" can be read as homoerotic imagery. So can the whole subject matter of uniformity imposed by militaristic discipline. Ideas of uniforms and subjection to authority return in "The Offer of King Krool".
The brief suggestion in "The Mischief of King Balerion" that the King might want to experience the body of a woman, can also be given LGBTQ readings.
"How Trurl built a Femfatalatron" sticks exclusively to heterosexual experience in its sex machine - and in that sense, can be read as a heterosexual story. But it also describes one male controlling and stimulating the sexual feelings of another man, using this machine. This can be seen as a gay sexual situation.
Video Game. The video game sections total around 54 pages (but would be shorter if printing were not so expansive in the book). They form a separate novella or long short story embedded in the novel.
The video game episodes resembles a series of linked short stories, based on common themes. The game format allows for unusual story telling approaches. They are "experimental" in their literary techniques.
They contain a science fiction puzzle (set forth in Chapters 7 and 11, solved in Chapter 15). Puzzles are a standard element in some science eviction. Such puzzles have some affinity with mystery fiction. The way Wang solves the puzzle, makes him analogous to the detective in traditional mystery fiction.
The video game sections recall Lem's The Cyberiad. Both works have a series of "artificial" events, that have symbolic relevance to the real world. This is an experimental approach, different from standard fiction techniques. The section on the computer (Chapter 17) recalls a bit "The Trap of Gargantius" in The Cyberiad.
These sections also resemblance Lem's novel Solaris somewhat. The planet in Liu's novel is called Trisolaris, evoking Lem. (I am not sure how close this parallel of names is in the Chinese original.) And the "three-body problem" from physics is presented as a conundrum that is nearly impossible for science to analyze or understand, recalling the ocean in Solaris.
The video games sections also recall "Reiko's Universe Box" (1981) by Kajio Shinji:
The opening episode of the video game (Chapter 7), somewhat recalls Arthur C. Clarke's "The Lion of Comarre", with travelers converging on a mysterious pyramid.
The multiple civilizations recall Harness' The Paradox Men. The Paradox Men is based on historian Arnold Toynbee's ideas of successive civilizations, and features a new such Toynbee-style civilization in the future. The Three-Body Problem differs from The Paradox Men in that it contains multiple civilizations instead of one, and in that it does not explicitly invoke Toynbee. It also differs from Toynbee in that civilizations fall in The Three-Body Problem because of astronomical factors, while in Toynbee historical forces cause the decline of civilizations.
The emphasis on suns in both the video game and non-video-games parts of The Three-Body Problem, also recalls the solar setting of parts of The Paradox Men.
Hard Science Fiction. Some non-video-game episodes are steeped in science and scientists. They fall squarely into the tradition of "hard science fiction" (often abbreviated as "hard sf"). Likely, the author consciously intended these sections as hard sf:
There are also hard sf aspects to some of the video games episodes.
The Countdown. The numbers sent to the hero form a countdown from some alien messenger (Chapter 6). This recalls J.G. Ballard's "The Voices of Time".
Pentecost. The Three-Body Problem invokes the Christian doctrine of Pentecost. with the hymn to the Holy Sprit (end of Chapter 9). This links the Christian Pentecost-concept of messages from the divine Holy Spirit, to the messages from aliens in The Three-Body Problem. Pentecost is often symbolized by tongues of fire descending on the disciples; some of the messages in The Three-Body Problem take the form of changes to the universe's background radiation (Chapter 9).
Pentecost is repeatedly invoked in the film Brokeback Mountain (Ang Lee, 2005).
The subject of technology vs art in "The Poetry Cloud" recalls science vs art in "The Rose" by Charles L. Harness.
Nelson never became a best selling author. But his work was prestigious, and anthologized by such leading sf figures as Isaac Asimov, Forrest J. Ackerman, Avram Davidson, Harlan Ellison and Judith Merril. "Eight O'Clock in the Morning" (1963) was recognized as a classic long before it was filmed, as They Live (1988). The movie adds characters and incidents, but most of its science fiction concepts come straight out of Ray Nelson's story.
SPOILER. "The Great Cosmic Donut of Life" (1965) shows a future society where group marriage is common. The hero is locked in a rivalry with another man, over the heroine's affections. The tale ends with the hero getting down on his knees and proposing marriage - to the other man. It is quite startling. It is not quite "gay marriage": the two men and the heroine are now part of a group marriage of three people.
Ray Nelson has a personal web site. This includes a bibliography.
Davidson's crime fiction often attempts to evoke a society, a locale or a milieu. Some of his works are historicals: "The Importance of Trifles" (1969) recreates 1830's New York City. Others evoke a modern-day locale, such as "The Cobblestones of Saratoga Street" (1964), and its portrait of a thinly-disguised version of New York's Gramercy Park neighborhood. In addition, Davidson constructs clear, well-defined plots. These plots partly focus on crime and mystery, but they also include much of the non-crime aspects of his characters' lives and work.
Between his interest in social details, and his plotting, Davidson can be described as a "content-driven" writer. This is not too surprising: both the science fiction and mystery fields are dominated by content-driven writing. Davidson's crime fiction tends to deliver this content in a clear, fairly straightforward manner.
Davidson wrote a linked series of detective stories with fantasy solutions and puzzles, collected in The Adventures of Doctor Eszterhazy. The depiction of their imaginary 1900-ish Eastern European city of Bella, owes something to his portrait of 1830's New York City in "The Importance of Trifles". Both cities have a colorful waterfront full of sailors, as seen in Bella in "The Ceaseless Stone" (1975). The Eszterhazy tales are detective-solving-a-mystery in form, as is "The Importance of Trifles".
Science fiction constitutes nearly half of Le Guin's published fiction. That number does NOT include fantasy like Earthsea. Nor does it include Orsinia, which I claim should be categorized as realist mainstream fiction, even if it is set in an imaginary Central European country. When I say science fiction is half of Le Guin's fiction, I'm talking about strict outer-space-and-the-future science fiction, as the term has been understood since 1926.
What is best in Le Guin's writings?
But many admirers of Le Guin are mainly specialists in mainstream realist fiction: which in itself is fine. Unfortunately, many despise science fiction: which is not fine. You can see them tying themselves into pretzels to say something nice about Le Guin, without endorsing that Dreadful Evil Science Fiction Genre. This approach is so self-inconsistent that it is doomed to logical failure. People need to abandon it, and revise their aesthetics so that they recognize the merits of science fiction.
A book of essays about it, mainly by Political Science professors, is The New Utopian Politics of Ursula K. Le Guin's The Dispossessed (2005) edited by by Laurence Davis and Peter Stillman. It is available for free on-line here. The Dispossessed is linked to a large number of key social questions: environmental, economic, anti-consumerist.
Le Guin's speech to the National Book Foundation is related to ideas in The Dispossessed.
Social Science Fiction. John W. Campbell and his magazine Astounding emphasized what Campbell writer Isaac Asimov called "Social Science Fiction". This is science fiction that looks at some innovation, whether scientific, technological or social, and depicts how a whole society and way of life would logically follow from this innovation. The more detail about how this society would function, the better: as long as the detail is logically based on the innovation.
Two aspects of The Dispossessed build up elaborately detailed portraits, in the manner of Social Science Fiction:
The enormous richness, creativity and inventiveness of the portraits of Anarres and Cetian physics in The Dispossessed are major reasons why this book is so admired.
Much of Le Guin's science fiction, including The Dispossessed, is centrally in the tradition of Social Science Fiction. Although Le Guin is not a "Campbell writer", never working with Campbell or publishing in his magazine, her conception of science fiction follows the same paradigms as Campbell. Like Philip K. Dick, she is a writer of Social Science Fiction, a tradition firmly linked to Campbell, without being a writer with a personal connection to Campbell.
Scientific Research. The Dispossessed offers a detailed portrait of scientific research. This subject is traditionally viewed in science fiction as a topic of deep interest. It appears in countless science fiction novels and short stories. One reason that The Dispossessed is widely regarded as a good novel, is that skillfully imagines a scientific research program.
In its science The Dispossessed bears some resemblance to "The Rose" (1953) by Charles L. Harness. Both center on unified theories of physics or science. Both draw parallels between physics or mathematics, and music.
The Dispossessed also recalls Cyril M. Kornbluth's short story "Gomez" (1954). SPOILERS:
A Western. The Dispossessed has features that recall Westerns, especially the Television Westerns of the era. The resemblance is especially strong in the opening chapter. An angry mob threatens to lynch the hero; the forces of authority have to stand up to them, and try to quiet the crowd. This situation appears in endless TV Westerns of the 1950's and 1960's. It was hugely popular.
A key character in the opening is the foreman of the local crew. Foreman characters were widespread in TV Westerns: The hero of The Virginian was foreman of the Shiloh ranch.
A doctor is prominent in the opening: doctors were ubiquitous in Westerns, usually sympathetic and idealistic, as is the doctor in The Dispossessed. Doctors in Westerns are often shown as independent thinkers, people who stand outside the sometimes flawed social order of their communities. Similarly the doctor in The Dispossessed tries to relate to Shevek "man to man", rather than as someone he wants to manipulate for society.
We meet Pae, a slick, upper crust and charming looking man of the upper classes, who is secretly corrupt. This was a type regularly found in Westerns. William Bishop often played such well-tailored menaces in movie Westerns, as did Ed Nelson on TV. In Western films and TV, audiences usually learned right away that these villains were no good, despite their charming, respectable appearance. Similarly The Dispossessed tips readers off early on that the hero finds Pae untrustworthy.
The rest of The Dispossessed is less Western-like, but it still has aspects recalling Westerns, especially the chapters on Anarres:
Classic Russian literature (Gogol, Dostoyevsky, Anton Chekhov, etc.) famously often deals with financially ordinary people. The same is true of the Western: a point not often appreciated. The archetypal Western hero is a wandering cowboy who owns nothing but a few simple items in his saddle bags. So Le Guin works that deal with poor working people such as The Dispossessed and "Brothers and Sisters" reflect the traditions of Russian Literature. But at the same time, they also can be seen as embodying traditions of the Western.
Mobiles. The heroine Takver makes mobiles. Some of these include wires and beads. These recall:
Architecture. The old city of Rodarred is notable for its many towers (start of Chapter 11). This is an "ancient city with an imaginative architecture". It recalls another such metropolis, the opening city in The Left Hand of Darkness. That town was built to withstand spring flooding. Compare: The Case of Jennie Brice (1912) by Mary Roberts Rinehart, a mystery tale which also shows people coping routinely with floods in Pittsburgh.
Atmosphere and Light. The Dispossessed is full of descriptions of the sky, light and atmosphere.
One associates such descriptions with Robert Louis Stevenson. And with writers influenced by Stevenson:
Cooperatives. The Dispossessed shows a society run entirely by cooperatives, which have replaced for-profit business, government and other legal institutions. This society is a would-be Utopia, a complete transformation of existing society.
In real life here on Earth, cooperatives have been highly successful, for hundreds of years. Such cooperatives are usually part of a mixed economy. co-existing along with for-profit business, government institutions, non-profits, charities, etc. (Although the United States and Western Europe are often described as "capitalist societies", this is an over-simplification. They are in fact mixed economies.)
Consequently, one does not have to depend on the idea of a Utopia-exclusively-run-by-cooperatives, to feel enthused about cooperatives and their potential. Or to be interested in the vivid depictions of cooperatives in The Dispossessed. Whether or not the Utopia shown in The Dispossessed would work in real life, or whether it would be a good thing, thus become side issues. Cooperatives work well in the here-and-now, and without a Utopian transformation of society. This gives The Dispossessed a deep interest, independent of any Utopian ideas in the novel.
Please see my list of Cooperatives and Worker-owned Businesses in Mystery and Science Fiction. The list has links to my articles on the writers mentioned. A vivid look at real-life contemporary cooperatives is the documentary film Shift Change (Melissa Young, Mark Dworkin, 2012).
Challenge. The Dispossessed is a book that challenges us to rethink our own lives. How should we live? What work should we do? With what institutions and organizations should we be affiliated? What public policies should we support? This challenging quality is also found in the films of Roberto Rossellini.
In both Le Guin and Rossellini, this challenge is seen as combining both personal character and social institutions and choices. It is far from fully private. It involves changing and shaping society, too.
Motivation to Work. One of the weakest ideas in The Dispossessed is its repeated insistence that people will work simply for the satisfaction they get out of their jobs, rather than money. In real life, many people will work hard without pay at science, the arts, raising children, and for causes in which they believe. But most jobs people only do if they are paid money. Most work at hard demanding jobs people do for pay. Admittedly, large numbers of people also have an interest in their work, and take pride at doing a good job. Still, their work is only performed if they can get wages.
In real life, many, maybe most people who work at cooperatives draw a salary. So the success of cooperatives does NOT depend on the willingness of people to work purely because they find their work interesting, as in The Dispossessed.
So while I do not believe this aspect of The Dispossessed is accurate, this does NOT invalidate the novel. It makes it uncertain that the Utopian social organization in The Dispossessed would actually work. But it has no affect on the novel's portraits of cooperatives, or the fact that cooperatives have a major role to play in real-life society and economies.
Preserving Cultures. We briefly learn about the survival of a song originated by the miners, the only group of people on Anarres not part of the anarchists who settled the planet later (middle of Chapter 2). This is a relic of an earlier culture, one that has survived.
Le Guin would look at the attempts to preserve earlier knowledge in one of the best of her early science fiction tales "The Masters" (1963). Preserving threatened cultures and their knowledge and fiction would become a major subject in long works of her later career: The Telling (2001), the novella "The Finder" (2001) in Tales from Earthsea, Voices (2004).
The Road to Serfdom?. A-Io is a country much like the contemporary United States. Among other things, it is a prosperous capitalist society; it has freedom of the press. But it is often viewed negatively in The Dispossessed.
A-Io has features associated with horrible societies. It has bad medical care for the poor, systematically having the poor die off needlessly in filthy "hospitals". Troops of the A-Io government massacre protesting citizens and dissidents. It has extensive political prisoners.
All of this has happened on A-Io without any external cause, such as a totalitarian coup or conquest. The Dispossessed thus seems to express a viewpoint widely held by libertarians: Western-style governments are going to degenerate into monstrous regimes. The Le Guin work that chronologically follows The Dispossessed, and widely seen as linked to it, "The New Atlantis" (1975) makes this explicit. It looks at a future United States whose government is full of bureaucrats actively promoting evil. One gets a similar portrait of Western democracy degenerating all by itself into evil bureaucracy in the film Brazil.
I have a big problem with this. It does not seem to be true. It is now over 40 years since The Dispossessed and "The New Atlantis" were published, and nothing in their predictions about the US government have come true. The point of view expressed in Le Guin's books and Brazil seems to be a lot of bunk. This idea, central to libertarians, is just plain false.
Global Warming. The Dispossessed describes a future Earth ruined by environmental catastrophe. It is very hot (Chapter 11).
The linked story "The New Atlantis" (1975) is more explicit. It shows a future Earth hit by the "greenhouse effect". Sea levels have risen, and much of Manhattan is under water. This 1975 story is describing Global Warming at an astonishingly early date.
Unlike their portraits of government bureaucracy which I don't like, these tales' look at Climate Crisis have proved remarkably prophetic.
Let me reiterate what I've always said elsewhere too: Climate change is real. It is caused by humans. It is extremely dangerous. We need to take drastic action immediately, to prevent huge catastrophes in the future. And we need to start accepting what "mainstream science" and 97% of climate scientists are telling us about Global Warming as the truth.
Philosophy. Cetian physics incorporates philosophy and metaphysics. The hero thinks this is a good thing, an example of the "tearing down walls" between subjects that he advocates. By contrast, I'm skeptical of the heavy emphasis on philosophy and psychology in the real-world study of literature and film over the last fifty years. Literary and cinematic criticism might be better off without incorporating philosophy and psychology.
The Wall. In general, however, I'm impressed with Le Guin's concept of "the wall". It refers to people refusing to examine ideas or think about subjects, because it would contradict their preconceptions, or what society tells them they should think. This is in fact common in real life.
"Brothers and Sisters" has neither the anarcho-syndicalism nor the Cetian physics so prominent in The Dispossessed. But otherwise its setting strongly anticipates the planet Anarres:
There is a gay character in both works.
"Brothers and Sisters" is one of Le Guin's best mainstream works.
A Western. The locale of "Brothers and Sisters" has a Western feel, like The Dispossessed. The dry setting, the quarrying, the railroads, the mountains contribute to this Western effect. The story takes place in 1910: close to the time period of many Westerns. Foremen are typical characters in Westerns: Kostant is a foreman at the quarry in "Brothers and Sisters".
"Brothers and Sisters" has some Western-like features not found in The Dispossessed:
"A Week in the Country", "Imaginary Countries" and "Hand, Cup, Shell" are all set at country homes; they are all group portraits of a family that owns the home. I confess I don't like this subject in Le Guin's work very much. As fiction these country house works seem drastically inferior to "Brothers and Sisters" and The Dispossessed. "A Week in the Country" picks up whenever it gets away from the country house subject and starts criticizing Communism. The anti-Communist parts are both politically meaningful, and embedded in memorable imagery.
The lyric quoted is by Thomas Campion. It is the finale of verses that begin "Silly Boy!", from Campion's The Third Book of Ayres (1617?). Campion is a gifted poet, a contemporary of Shakespeare. I've read his complete poems, and you would enjoy them too. They are available in The Works of Thomas Campion (1967) edited by Walter R. Davis.
As a subsidiary theme, the criticism of the West for materialism also persists. We do not learn the actual politics of the revolutionaries, but we do learn that they want to develop a society that is both utterly non-Communist and which avoids the materialism of Western capitalism. This avoidance of both Communism and capitalism is also present in the anarcho-syndicalism of Anarres.
"Unlocking the Air" is also a portrait of a revolution, like the revolution that led to Anarres in The Dispossessed. Both works' politics center on a woman revolutionary thinker: Stefana Fabbre in "Unlocking the Air", Odo in The Dispossessed.
The huge rally recalls the big protest in A-Io in The Dispossessed.
A statement by the author-of-the-acacia-seeds seems Taoist. It seems like a witty transcription of Taoist views into that author's language and world view.
Rocks. The end of the story discusses rocks. Geology as a science appears in "Hand, Cup, Shell", and a poetic treatment is found in "The Bones of the Earth" in Tales from Earthsea. Gahheya Rock seems to talk in "Stone Telling, Part One" in Always Coming Home. The Karst in "Brothers and Sisters" is memorable. Small stones become symbolically important to people in Very Far Away From Anywhere Else and "Solitude".
The Squid. A brief episode in "Solitude" reads as if it were another section of "The Author of the Acacia Seeds". This is the bit about the zoologist studying the squid. This episode has little to do with the rest of "Solitude": it is a change of pace.
Margaret Atwood made a notorious comment about science fiction dealing with "talking squids in outer space". Somewhat startlingly, this episode in "Solitude" actually is about "talking squids in outer space"! I have been unable to find the exact date of Atwood's quote, but it seems to be post-2000, long after Le Guin's tale.
At first the Veksi seem just nasty and brutal, likely even evil. This is certainly an aspect of their lives. But eventually the story begins to tell something odd about them: they have no dominance goals, or superior-inferior relations. So this aspect of their lives becomes a Utopian tale. Like the anarchists of The Dispossessed, it shows a society without hierarchy.
The weird anger-based grief of the Veksi, perhaps extends the mother's dubious lament at the start of "Brothers and Sisters".
The Veksi's hooves recall the aliens in Arthur C. Clarke's "Second Dawn" (1951). Le Guin has come up with new ideas that build on and further develop Clarke's original concepts. Science fiction writers are regularly in this sort of "dialogue".
The conflict with the Bayderac at the end is richly imagined, in its science fictional detail. It offers a new dimension to Le Guin's stories about non-standard humanoids. Politically it anticipates the conflict in Voices.
"Seasons of the Ansarac" shares subjects with The Dispossessed. Both:
The subject of dreaming links this tale to The Lathe of Heaven. However the treatment of dreaming is quite different in the two works.
The picture of life on farms and in small towns recalls a bit "Brothers and Sisters".
As best as I know, the tale's invented language and its treatment of meaning have no exact real world analogues. But the branching nature of meaning in the language is interesting. The complex branching of the language reminds one of some non-linguistic media of sharing ideas, which employ branching:
"The Nna Mmoy Language" is a favorite story of mine. One wishes it were better known.
It has links with The Dispossessed. Both:
World Building. Among the best episodes in Always Coming Home are those that tell the reader about the key features of the book's future world. In sf and fantasy as a whole, tales like these are said to engage in world building, the literary creation of an imagined world. World building is of interest in many authors. Le Guin is skillful at it, and these sections benefit from her imagination.
These sections include:
These sections also benefit from their strong storytelling.
"The Trouble with the Cotton People" reminds one of the Earthsea books, with its landscape one can follow on a map, and its sea and island voyages. Its finale, where the characters negotiate their way to a solution of a complex dispute, anticipates the end of Voices. These finales show non-violent approaches solving serious conflicts.
"The Trouble with the Cotton People" and especially "The Train" include the locomotive transport that Le Guin loves. The trains are in isolated regions, recalling the trains in "Brothers and Sisters" and The Dispossessed. See also the end of Very Far Away From Anywhere Else.
"White Tree" offers an interesting look at science and a scientist - subjects central to The Dispossessed. The footnote to the tale makes a thoughtful point about the nature of science. The financial poverty of the scientist's life, and his ability through work to make a contribution to science despite it, also recall The Dispossessed. A related look at a poor but gifted composer is in "An Die Musik". The hero "White Tree" moves from his home town to a place where he can conduct his research, then back to his home town: paralleling the movements of the scientist hero in The Dispossessed.
"The Keeper" offers a folk tale critique of the temptation towards private property. This too recalls The Dispossessed. The opening of "The Keeper" provides an understanding of the scope of the arts in the future world of Always Coming Home.
SF Mixed with the Supernatural. Always Coming Home is strange in its combinations of subject matter. It mixes science fiction with fantasy and the supernatural. The future world is explained in scientific terms: pure science fiction. Yet within this world, people often have visions, encounter supernatural beings, or meet the spirits of the dead. This mix of science fiction and the supernatural is uncommon in literature, to the best of my experience.
I intensely dislike and disapprove of the supernatural. I do not want to read books about it. The supernatural doesn't exist in the real world, is a bunch of hooey. And fiction books that promote it seem to me to be anti-reason. I have long felt this way in general, and see no reason to change my convictions, even for an author as talented as Le Guin. I mainly don't like the supernatural aspects of Always Coming Home.
Flicker. With this said, even I have to admit there are imaginative elements in "The Visionary: The Life Story of Flicker of the Serpentine of Telina-na". The visions of the electrical grid are fascinating. While presented as supernatural visions, their actual content seem science fictional: a way of thinking about technological networks.
In broad terms, one wonders if Le Guin had read and been influenced by Vernor Vinge's "True Names" (1981). "True Names" has a worldwide computer grid; so does Always Coming Home. And Flicker's visualizations of networks are a bit related to the visualization technique in "True Names". Such grids and their visualization in "True Names" led to the later concept of cyberspace.
Flicker sees the grids and other processes "as a whole". This recalls the cosmic view of the stars as a whole, by the huge plant in "Vaster Than Empires and More Slow".
Stone Telling's Name. Stone Telling gives an explanation of her name at the start of Part One. But it also echoes her supernatural encounter with the rock Gahheya that seems to talk, midway in Part One. Rocks play roles in "The Bones of the Earth" and the finale of "The Author of the Acacia Seeds".
Poetry. A plus in Always Coming Home is the poetry. Much of the verse is creative.
Le Guin points out the different genres and meters of the poems, showing us various literary traditions of this imagined future culture. The plays are also in verse, and they too fall into (fictitious) literary genres of this future society.
Some of the plays involve a chorus, recalling Greek drama. And "The Plumed Water" has a plot whose approach recalls Greek Mythology.
Some of the plays are little anecdotes, recalling traditional Japanese drama.
The syllabic meters of some of the poems, with four syllables or five syllables per line, also recalls Japanese verse.
Dangerous People: The First, Shorter 1985 Version. The "Dangerous People" section is one of the few mysteries anywhere in Le Guin. It is explicitly labeled a mystery in the introductory "A Note about the Novel".
"Dangerous People" is presented as an early chapter excerpted from a novel. We get no solution to the story's mystery in this excerpt. And I have been unable to see that any one solution is conclusively hinted at in the tale. So "Dangerous People" is in that small category, mysteries without solutions. Some famous films had earlier propounded mysteries they did not solve: L'Avventura (Michelangelo Antonioni, 1960), Picnic at Hanging Rock (Peter Weir, 1974). "Dangerous People" resembles both of these works. In all three:
"Dangerous People" itself makes a much better, more valid point about the unsolved mystery. It suggests people's laziness or vanity urges them to give glib explanations of situations that are in fact mysterious or unknown. This seems like a valid critique. It is also part of a long tradition in mystery fiction as a whole, urging people to think deeply and critically about mysteries, unsolved problems and the unknown.
There is no explicit detective figure in most of "Dangerous People". I kept hoping that someone would take active steps to solve the disappearance, but maddeningly, most characters don't. SPOILERS. Only at the tale's end, in a surprising and dramatic development, do two detective figures emerge. The emergence of the detectives forms a climax to the tale. It plays a role in the tale's formal structure as well as being interesting in its own right as an event.
"Dangerous People" depicts the heroine's family as suspicious: they perhaps have killed her or had her abducted. And the tale leaves open the possibility of the husband's guilt: he might have murdered her.
"A Note about the Novel" explicitly discusses the formal structure of "Dangerous People". It says the tale is constructed out of conversations between two people, followed by the departure of one, and the arrival of a new person to start a new conversation with the remaining one. This structure is linked to the hinge imagery that runs through the book. This analysis of the tale's form is consistent with the formal analyses of poetry in the book. Always Coming Home repeatedly tries to make its formal literary patterns explicit.
"Dangerous People" is full of moon imagery. From moonlight to a visionary staring at the moon, to such names as Moon Creek and Moondog, the story is filled with it. Why? It is unclear.
"Dangerous People" is one of the few sections of Always Coming Home to suggest explicitly there might be systematic prejudice among the Kesh. Husband Kamedan complains that his wife's family looks down on him because he is a Miller, and devalues him and his son because they are male. However, one wonders if the problems Stone Telling has with being the child of a foreign father, also constitute prejudice. And Flicker's grandmother does not approve of her Miller son-in-law, and does not want Flicker practicing her father's profession of Miller. So "Dangerous People" perhaps calls for a re-interpretation of earlier sections of Always Coming Home. Part Three of "Stone Telling" concisely discusses this, suggesting the end of the war with the Condor people has also led to a merciful decline in prejudice against foreigners among the Kesh.
Just before "Dangerous People", "The Cats Here Don't Care" in the section "Some Brief Valley Texts" offered a negative view of hunters. This seems extended in the hunter character in "Dangerous People". His hurting the dog seems especially offensive.
Le Guin gave a blurb for a Barbara Wilson mystery, and praised Tony Hillerman mysteries set among Native Americans. But otherwise she seems unsympathetic to the mystery genre, as a reader.
Dangerous People: The Expanded 2019 Version. Le Guin published an expanded version of "Dangerous People" (2019). Unfortunately, this version still does not offer a solution to the mystery.
Stone Telling: Politics. The political situation in Stone Telling's narrative anticipates Voices. Both pit a peaceful, settled, religiously pluralistic, literate, female-favorable culture against an evil army of a militaristic, nomadic, monotheistic, illiterate, patriarchal invader.
One notices that life among the militaristic, patriarchal Condor people is unfortunately not much mentioned in contemporary discussions of Dystopia. Margaret Atwood's The Handmaid's Tale (1985) came out later the same year as Always Coming Home, and has been treated as a cultural treasure. Meanwhile Always Coming Home seems mainly read by Le Guin specialists and a few determined science fiction fans. The idea that Always Coming Home might have anything to say to the broader culture is not widespread in the contemporary USA.
Part Three of "Stone Telling" is especially well done as science fiction. It offers a detailed look first at the Condor people and their neighbors, and then at life among the Kesh, seen from an adult's point of view.
I am not convinced by the way these books explicitly link monotheism to problems like misogyny and populations that can't read. History contradicts this:
Stone Telling: The Opening Journey. The journey at the start of Part One is more comprehensible when read with the map at the end of Part Three. The map shows the towns visited. The lack of the map obscures what is happening in the journey.
I'm not sure why Le Guin delayed the map till the end of the tale in Part Three. This delay adds to the effect of strangeness in Part One, plunging the reader into a strange not-too-explained future. It also suggests a child's point-of-view, a view of events without maps.
We learn more about the towns in the second half of "The Long Names of Houses". This too maybe should be read before "Stone Telling" Part One. The second half of "The Long Names of Houses" has info on two towns not much discussed in the Part One journey: Tachas Touches and Wakwaha. So the second half of "The Long Names of Houses" and the journey are complementary, together forming a picture of the book's towns.
"The Town of Chumo" offers much info about Chumo. We only learn a little about it in the Part One journey. The two works are consistent, however.
"White Tree" has a life story whose movements echo the Part One journey. The hero moves from Sinshan to Kastoha, then ultimately back to Sinshan. This is the overall pattern of the Part One journey.
Messages Concerning the Condor. "Messages Concerning the Condor" is appended to Part Three of "Stone Telling". It gives a science fiction background to the events of the story, telling what happened to society as a whole while the events of "Stone Telling" were transpiring.
At the end of Le Guin's The Eye of the Heron (1978), the population evades the dictatorial bad guys by dispersing: spreading out geographically so that the villains can't control them. Always Coming Home shows a similar strategy. The Kesh populations are already dispersed and decentralized. And populations who are directly attacked by the Condor people flee even further. The technologies used by the good guys are decentralized as well.
About a Meeting Concerning the Warriors. "About a Meeting Concerning the Warriors" is also appended to Part Three of "Stone Telling". It continues a subject found in a number of parts of "Stone Telling": how Kesh society has been infected with militarism due to contact with the Condor people. These passages recall the finale of The Lord of the Rings, where even good people who have carried the ring are corrupted and emotionally damaged by it. Always Coming Home shows a whole section of society similarly corrupted by Condor ideology. In both Always Coming Home and The Lord of the Rings, the corruption is a lingering, long term problem, and one that weighs heavily on people.
"About a Meeting Concerning the Warriors" features the sorts of public debates about an issue also found in The Dispossessed, especially the Anarres sections, and in "Unlocking the Air". These debates are full of oratory and rhetoric. They often focus on appeals to fundamental principles. Le Guin tries hard to make the debates dramatic and interesting as story telling.
Essays. The best of Le Guin's essays linked to Always Coming Home are "World-Making", "Text, Silence, Performance", "Legends for a New Land". "World-Making" and "Legends for a New Land" benefit from including examples of Native American literature. Some outstanding Le Guin poems open "Legends for a New Land".
Science fiction: the Campbell tradition. Science fiction elements are most emphasized in an early section, detailing the background of the book's society (Chapter 2). This section recalls in broad terms Robert Heinlein's famous novella "Universe" (1941). The tales differ in that Heinlein's takes place on a spaceship on a long voyage from Earth, whereas Lord of Light shows us the society that has developed long after the spaceship has crashed on an alien planet. So there is no "spaceship universe" as there is in "Universe" and most of its many imitators. But both "Universe" and Lord of Light show:
Reproduction. This section's depiction of radical reproduction technology (in the Karma houses) changing how humans create themselves in future generations, is part of a sf tradition that includes Arthur C. Clarke's The City and the Stars (1956) and Philip K. Dick's Dr. Futurity (1954, 1960). It also recalls the mass manufacture of humans and human body parts in Karel Capek's R.U.R. (Rossum's Universal Robots) (1920).
Mystery. Lord of Light has mystery elements. They are located in central sections of the novel (Chapters 4, 5, first half of 6). They culminate in a murder mystery. The mystery is soon solved (middle of Chapter 6). Lord of Light has a full, formal mystery puzzle. The identity of killer is a surprise, when revealed - although it is fairly easy to suspect. SPOILER. More baffling are aspects of how the killer managed to become an active presence. This two-stage process is firmly rooted in events previously depicted in earlier chapters. The use of these events by the killer is "logical but unexpected and surprising", in the best mystery puzzle tradition.
Reviving neglected ideas. The heroes in Lord of Light try to revive technological knowledge that has been suppressed by the planet's elites. The whole question of preserving and reviving knowledge that has slid or been pushed into obscurity is an important one. It appears in other sf works, such as Ursula K. Le Guin's The Telling (2000).
In real life, neglected ideas are sometimes linked to embattled minorities who speak their own languages. There are institutions attempting to preserve everything from Native American cultures to Scots Gaelic literature (see An Comunn Gaidhealach). Cultures can also be attacked politically, such as Cambodian culture under dictator Pol Pot, or Taoism in Communist China.
In addition, ideas can fall out of favor. Traditional ideas about mystery fiction and science fiction seem to be understood by far fewer people today than 50 or 100 years ago.
Meritocracy. The society in Lord of Light presents itself as a meritocracy. Its citizens are told that if they are virtuous, they will be promoted in future lives, and eventually reach the top rung and become gods. In reality, exactly the opposite is happening. People with real ability and independent ideas are being weeded out and killed. Only mediocrities with "go along and get along attitudes" prosper and get promoted.
This bears a satirical resemblance to the present day United States. The USA too is often depicted as a meritocracy, especially by members of the elites. It is unclear how good these elites actually are. How many owe their positions to coming from families of wealth and power? These questions might not have single answers, and some "elites" might be better than others. It might be, for example, that tenured college professors are genuinely highly skilled, while top Wall Street money-makers might simply be well-connected mediocrities and hacks.
Lord of Light has corrupt evil powerful people running society, battling each other and external challengers in sleazy, violent and vicious ways. This can recall Al Capone and 1920's mobsters battling for power; Nazi, Communist and Third World dictatorships with internal battles for power. It also recalls Jacobean tragedies, with their corrupt aristocrats fighting each other. Zelazny wrote his master's thesis on the Jacobean play The Revenger's Tragedy (1606).
Allusions. Lord of Light bears an overall resemblance to John Milton's epic poem Paradise Lost (1664). Both show a revolt of a high-powered being against Heaven. The hero of Lord of Light is far more moral than Milton's protagonist, however.
Lord of Light references two other poems, by descriptions rather than by explicitly naming the poets. These are "Correspondences" by Charles Baudelaire, and The Inferno by Dante. "Correspondences" does indeed anticipate the feel of Lord of Light.
The Rakasha pleading to be let out of their imprisonment, recall genies begging to be let out of bottles in The Arabian Nights.
The Irish stand-down contest recalls a similar duel in Baranca (1960), an episode of the TV series The Rifleman directed by Joseph H. Lewis.
Nikki: poetic diaries. "24 Views of Mt. Fuji, by Hokusai" explicitly invokes the Japanese poet Matsuo Basho. Basho took part in the Japanese tradition of nikki: poetic diaries. These diaries describe beautiful events in heightened poetic language. Some describe travel, journeys their authors took. This includes the Tosa Nikki (935) by Ki no Tsurayuki, one of the first great nikkis. And Basho's classic The Narrow Road to the Deep North (circa 1689). The nikki tradition influenced Beat writers, such as Jack Kerouac's On The Road (1957), which describes his journeys in the American West. "24 Views of Mt. Fuji, by Hokusai" is very much in the nikki travel diary tradition, with rich descriptions of what the heroine is viewing throughout Japan.
"The Fifth Head of Cerberus" perhaps shows the influence of Roger Zelazny's Lord of Light:
"Mouthpiece" opens with the dying, apparently meaningless ravings of a crook. Then the hero tracks down the crook's associates, to try to interpret the ravings. Such interpretation has antecedents both within and outside mystery fiction:
Meanwhile, the story's events trigger thriller elements. These seem modeled on The Mask of Dimitrios (1939) by Eric Ambler.
One can see such logically developed, highly detailed future societies in Vinge:
Campbell also liked sf stories based on science and technology. This has led some writers to claim, with some justification, that Hard Science Fiction is also a Campbell-based tradition. Still, in practice the term Hard Science Fiction has been most linked to post-1965 writers, who emerged after Campbell's heyday.
"Hard Science Fiction" and "Social Science Fiction" are two different concepts. A story can contain one without the other. Gregory Benford's "Exposures" (1981) is a good example of a story that is "Hard Science Fiction" but not "Social Science Fiction". It focus on an astronomer in the modern day USA, who makes discoveries at his observatory. There is plenty of serious science in the tale: making it "Hard Science Fiction". But there is no future society: just the typical life of contemporary America. This makes it NOT "Social Science Fiction".
Works can also be BOTH "Hard Science Fiction" and "Social Science Fiction". In other words, they can both contain much science, and develop future or alien societies. Examples include Hal Clement's Mission of Gravity, and Vinge's "True Names" and "Fast Times at Fairmont High".
The mystery of the Mailman is given three separate solutions during the course of "True Names", with only the third and last being the true solution. Such mysteries with multiple solutions go back to Trent's Last Case (1913) by E.C. Bentley, and are also common in the later mystery writers Anthony Berkeley and Ellery Queen.
The first and third solutions in "True Names" are deeply science fictional. By contrast, the second explanation is one that could occur in a non-sf mystery.
A reference early in "True Names" to government organizations as "instrumentalities", is perhaps a homage to Cordwainer Smith, and his concept of The Instrumentality of Mankind.
Both "True Names" and Earthlight (1955) by Arthur C. Clarke, end with a visit to a huge, futuristic apartment project. In each tale, this finale has a different atmosphere from the main earlier part of the story.
"The Cookie Monster" starts out like a typical mystery novel of the 2000's, with a heroine getting a new, ordinary job and plunged into mild mystery from it. This is the sort of situation that could occur in standard modern detective stories. But the science fictional events that soon erupt are far from standard.
The repeated looping of the characters, recalls a bit Charles L. Harness' "Time Trap" (1948).
"The Cookie Monster" offers a devastating look at the new world of work in the USA. People with middle class dreams and middle class self-identities, discover that they are really part of an exploited proletariat. Vinge includes both the computer industry and academia in the scope of this bitter satire.
SPOILERS. The powerful heroine's request for a social outsider to investigate (and by implication, change) her society, recalls members of the Instrumentality inducing social change in Cordwainer Smith.
SPOILERS. Elements of the mystery plot recall A Variety of Weapons (1942) by Rufus King. In both books, outsiders are brought into a compound of the rich; in both similar motives are eventually revealed.
The Culture: Predecessors. Elements of the Culture recall Cordwainer Smith:
The Culture has aspects that recall the Hainish tales of Ursula K. Le Guin:
Two of Ted Chiang's best short stories are "The Evolution of Human Science" (2000), and "Liking What You See: A Documentary" (2002). Both follow a classic science fiction paradigm: looking at a technological innovation, and how it might systemically change a future society. This is a good paradigm that often enables and leads to good results. It certainly works well in these two tales.
Both stories look at cognition. They show how thinking, reasoning and perception might be changed by these innovations in technology and society. Stories about cognition are an important subgenere in science fiction.
Science Fiction. The Intuitionist incorporates two key science fiction traditions:
Mystery Plot. The Intuitionist has a well-constructed mystery plot. It has two good plot surprises, one coming half-way through the book at the conclusion of the Down segment, the other the solution at the book's finale.
The Intuitionist includes much technology, making it part of the long, vast tradition of Scientific Detection.
Not Much Detection. Somewhat unusually, what The Intuitionist lacks is a detective figure. The heroine tries to get at the truth, but she does little actual detective work, and discovers little through her efforts. Instead the book's two main plot surprises are simply told her by other people: the first by Natchez at the end of the Down section, the revelation at the finale by Ben Urich.
Usually in mystery fiction finding things out through detective work is considered admirable; simply being told facts is considered an inferior approach. Unfortunately The Intuitionist mainly opts for this second approach.
Reporter Ben Urich does the book's only real detective work, when he photographs suspects and then investigates their identity using records. This is a sound, but brief, detection episode.
The heroine is brainy, and very good at any scientific or technical work involving elevators. But she is not a detective.
Cornell Woolrich. The Intuitionist sometimes recalls Cornell Woolrich, the best known writer of noir fiction.
Cornell Woolrich's "After-Dinner Story" (1938) is a suspense tale about a tragic elevator crash.
Woolrich's "The Dancing Detective" is the most famous story set in a taxi-dance hall. The dime-a-dance sequence in The Intuitionist seems like an homage to Cornell Woolrich.
Crime Films. The Intuitionist recalls some crime films, set in New York City in the 1950's.
On the Waterfront (Elia Kazan, 1954) deals with corrupt, violent labor unions, like The Intuitionist.
The Garment Jungle (Robert Aldrich, Vincent Sherman, 1957) has a corrupt businessman fighting an honest labor union. The businessman allies himself with mobsters. A mob killer disguises himself as an elevator worker, and causes a fatal crash.
Le Guin. Aspects of The Intuitionist recall Ursula K. Le Guin's The Dispossessed (1974):
Postmodernism. The Intuitionist has features characteristic of postmodern fiction:
Civic Corruption?. There is a long tradition in hard-boiled fiction of looking at civic corruption: crooked police and crooked government officials. Private eye writer Raymond Chandler is an archetypal example, with his crooked town of Bay City. At first The Intuitionist looks like it is going to be another instance. The elevator inspectors are employees of the city - and they look crooked.
SPOILERS. But near the book's end Ben Urich reveals the real culprits: the elevator companies. These big corporations are the book's true villains. It is Big Business, and perhaps Capitalism as a whole, that is behind the book's sinister events.
Truth. Aspects of The Intuitionist echo ideas that were fairly popular among humanities academics of their era. (See a long paragraph in the discussion between the heroine and Mrs. Rogers, pages 239-240 in the paperback edition.) Empiricism (reasoning from facts) is seen as a failed method of finding truth. The Intuitionist says it fails because people are corrupt and can be "bought" to constantly lie, thus obliterating truth.
This sounds fairly similar to various, very dubious, Postmodern Theory assertions that objective truth does not exist, and that everyone simply lies to promote their position in the class structure.
These ideas about the alleged impossibility of finding truth through empirical means have been widely and justifiably reviled. This whole approach is now seen as discredited.
Instead, convincing cases have been made that empirical methods, reasoning from facts and evidence, do indeed lead to the truth. And that despite failings and mistakes, that scientists, teachers, journalists and non-fiction writers are generally successful at finding truth and sharing it with the public.
The paragraph also says that Empiricism judges things purely on the basis of "what things appear to be". I don't agree: empirical methods can take a deep dive into facts and evidence, going far beyond surface appearances.
The Intuitionist instead embraces Intuitionism, a mystical discipline that reveals truth.
I am also uncomfortable with the book's apparent embrace of mysticism, in the form of Intuitionism. I just don't think mysticism can uncover facts about material objects like elevators.
Despite my disagreement with the apparent content of this section, I admire its form. The storytelling succeeds. The book weaves together many of its subjects, Intuitionism, race, passing, reasoning. The successive stages form into a successful storytelling pattern. They make a grand design. This works as a flowing, ongoing development of the book's ideas.
"I was climbing up a mountain path / with many things to do, / important business of my own, / and other people's too, / when I ran against a Prejudice / that quite cut off the view." - Charlotte Perkins Gilman, "An Obstacle" (1893).
"Peace, daughter of Righteousness, thou that makest cities great" - Pindar, "8th Pythian Ode".
Mystery Plot. The book follows the strict paradigm of the who-done-it murder mystery: there is an opening mysterious murder; the detective heroes investigate for the rest of the book, at the end the detectives figure out who committed the crimes.
Two pieces of detective reasoning by the Inspector are first rate:
The motive for the crime, and the identity of who-done-it, were unexpected surprises to me: a good thing.
The Thefts. The thefts are clever (Chapter 25). These fall into a category of mystery fiction with a long tradition: the "ingenious theft". They also come close to a linked tradition: the "impossible disappearance of an object". Objects are vanishing from the archaeological site, in a way that seems impossible, since the site is fenced and guarded.
Such impossible disappearances are traditions in Ellery Queen, Agatha Christie and Stuart Palmer.
Mystery Plot: Limitations. Twice the Inspector learns key ideas, not through any detective work, but through an informant on the phone (first half of Chapter 4, Chapter 16). This is not considered an admirable approach in mystery fiction. Sleuths are supposed to learn things through reason-based detection, not through informants simply telling them stuff. On the positive side, the plot revelations in these sections are well done.
There are mysteries about the history of the cities that the novel never explains: the origin of the cities during Cleavage; the strange mixed stratigraphy of the archaeological sites; why most artifacts are in Ul Quoma. In traditional mysteries, any mystery subplot not explained by the finale is considered a defect. But perhaps Miéville is saving up such explanations for a sequel.
Mise-en-crime. The opening crime scene investigation refers twice to "mise-en-crime" (Chapter 1). It is unclear exactly what this means. Is it is a police technique used by the cops in Beszel? Is it merely their term for "crime scene"?
An Internet search for "mise-en-crime" turns up few references, all after 2009 when The City & The City was published. This implies that Miéville invented the term "mise-en-crime" for the novel.
My guess: "mise-en-crime" is a variation on the much-used real-life term "mise-en-scène". Mise-en-scène is a term used in the theater and film. It refers to the atmosphere, staging and visual style added to a play or film by the director, used to create a visual, emotional experience for the audience, often to highlight the story and characters. It's an important concept: one often seen as central to the art of film.
Sightlines. The detective hero investigates "sightlines" at the crime scene: who could have seen what from where (Chapter 1). Such sightlines appear in some early detective stories. Please see my list of mysteries involving Line of Sight. It is possible that Miéville independently reinvented the concept of sightlines for The City & The City.
Sightlines have thematic links to the novel's key ideas of seeing and unseeing.
The Detectives. The approach to the detective characters recalls Golden Age mystery fiction (roughly 1910-1960), rather than contemporary mysteries:
Van Dine School. Mystery aspects of The City & The City recall the Van Dine School, a major tradition in American mystery fiction. Shared features:
Raymond Chandler. The opening "Acknowledgments" records a debt to Raymond Chandler. However, I am not seeing much concrete influence of Raymond Chandler on The City & The City:
Noir? Hard-Boiled?. The words "noir" (dark, gloomy, pessimistic) or "hard-boiled" (tough) have sometimes been used by critics to describe The City & The City. I disagree. After the opening chapter, little in The City & The City can be called noir or hard-boiled:
The opening (Chapter 1) is set in a drug-ridden slum area. It can accurately be called "hard-boiled". But drugs are barely mentioned again in the novel. And the main plot of the book plot relentlessly shifts towards the more educated characters just mentioned.
Political and social issues give The City & The City seriousness and gravitas. But these are different from what is meant by "noir" or "hard-boiled". One notes that quite a few Golden Age mystery novels also discuss politics: see Christie's One Two, Buckle My Shoe (1940) and Queen's The Glass Village (1954), for example.
Social Science Fiction. The City & The City reflects the Campbell tradition of Social Science Fiction. As in this Campbell tradition, it involves a single change to society, (two cities in the same location), with the social implications of that change set in forth in enormous, logical detail.
This Campbell tradition of Social Science Fiction was especially prevalent during the Golden Age of Science Fiction.
Ursula K. Le Guin. Aspects of The City & The City recall Ursula K. Le Guin:
Avram Davidson. Another possible predecessor to The City & The City is Avram Davidson. His The Adventures of Doctor Eszterhazy are mystery story / fantasy combinations, set in his imaginary 1900-ish Eastern European city of Bella.
Otto Lowy. Otto Lowy was the host of the long-running CBC Radio program The Transcontinental. This program nostalgically recreated the world of traditional pre-1950 Central Europe (and other parts of Europe too). It was a non-fiction show: it mixed reminiscences and factual accounts by host Lowy, with authentic musical recordings of the era. This non-fiction premise made it different from the fictional works of Le Guin, Davidson and Miéville. All four of them do share a rich atmosphere, however.
Archaeology. The Archaeology in The City & The City links up with two traditions:
Cultural References. The phrase "Holy Light" used by people in Ul Quoma recalls Milton's Paradise Lost (start of Book 3).
An exhibit of the real-life artist Jannis Kounellis is being held in Ul Quoma (last part of Chapter 10). Kounellis' grim minimalism perhaps represents the sterile, uncreative side of Modernism. It thus can symbolize the routine, uncreative Modernism of Ul Quoma.
Words and Names. Besz words and first names often seem to have analogues in English or other real-life languages. This makes their meaning easy to read:
Ballard had a great period in 1980-1984 with such classic works as the novel Hello America, the story sequence Memories of the Space Age, the historical novel Empire of the Sun, such short stories as "Report on an Unidentified Space Station" and "The Object of the Attack", and the interviews collected in Re/Search No 8/9 and the essay "What I Believe".
Running Wild. Three of his works of the 1985 - 1991 period stand out. "Running Wild" (1988) is a fascinating mystery novella. This story is thematically related to "The Object of the Attack" (1984). Both deal with revolt among a group of disaffected young people against authority in contemporary Britain. Both have a mystery like format, and a similar "tone". Both are full of political and cultural allusions that give the basic plot much richness of meaning.
On its own, "Running Wild" displays Ballard's mastery of narration. Ballard is able to create climaxes and give shape to events the way a classical composer gives structure to a piece of music. The reader soon comes to hang on every word of the story, not just to find out what happens next, but because of its meaningful part in an overall narrative structural flow. Ballard has created such effects before, in stories such as "The Waiting Grounds" and "Now: Zero". But this is one of his longest and most sustained pieces of narrative flow. At each step or stage of the story, Ballard creates a very elaborate "mise-en-scène" or atmosphere, just the way a film director creates a mise-en-scène in a movie. The Ballardian technique of narration shows each mise-en-scène emerging out of the next, through a logical (and emotional) development. Step by step, through eighty pages, Ballard develops each new mise-en-scène out of the last. The constant changes in the inner structure of the mise-en-scène, and the relationships between each mise-en-scène and the next, fascinate any reader with an interest in the formal unfolding of complex structures, whether in the form of music or story or film.
The reader almost "sees" the narrative progression of the story in terms of movement, or as dance images. It awakens mental images of movement, the way the unfolding forms of classical music also do. This is a good mental metaphor, one that springs spontaneously to the brain while under the influence of the artistic experience of the story, a metaphor that seeks to capture the almost magical sense of movement or flow this story seems to provide.
Dream Cargoes. "Dream Cargoes" (1991) is a science fiction short story. It breaks new thematic ground in Ballard's work in that it deals with the conception of a new child, an image of new fertility in Ballard's work. Although "The Waiting Grounds" can also be read as the "birth" of an advanced cosmic mind.
"Dream Cargoes" succeeds as a complex piece of science fiction imagination. One should never forget that Ballard, in his own words, is "a real science fiction writer", and that creating new science fictional situations is an important component of Ballard's art.
"Dream Cargoes", like the stories in Memories of the Space Age, is related in theme and technique to Ballard's earlier novel, The Crystal World (1964/1966). All of these works feature Ballard's most elaborate verbal style, featuring complex rhythmical prose and vivid visual imagery. (So do many Ballard works not thematically related to The Crystal World.) Such beautifully written stories are deeply satisfying to read.
Report on an Unidentified Space Station. Ballard says that he remembers virtually all his dreams. "Report on an Unidentified Space Station" (1982) is based on one of Ballard's dreams. It is one of his most Borges like works, recalling Borges' "The Library of Babel" (1941).
Its image of the station filling the universe recalls the global mind filling the universe at the climax of its evolution in "The Waiting Grounds".
The characters take confusing paths through a bewilderedly laid-out station. This recalls the way the hero wanders lost through the forest in "The Illuminated Man". In both works the protagonist finds himself doubling back over his trail. Both environments are futuristic and complex.
The Enormous Space. The story "The Enormous Space" (1989) features some of Ballard's most dream like imagery. This uneven but fascinating tale holds similarities to Ballard's early story "The Overloaded Man" (1961), where the protagonist deliberately tries to abstract his perceptions away from reality, and to "The Terminal Beach" (1964), where the hero deliberately maroons himself on an island with nothing but a candy bar to eat. Here the hero maroons himself in his home.
As hunger breaks down the protagonist's sense of reality, he begins to perceive his house in a new way, "discovering" new doors and rooms he never saw before. I have exactly such experiences in dreams, where I have found and explored such new areas in the house I grew up in. Ballard's story captures this sort of dream experience with extraordinary vividness and accuracy. Although it eventually falls apart into trumped up violence in its second half, the dream experiences of the beginning stab the heart with their beauty and insight to the world of dreams.
Passport to Eternity. The best of J.G. Ballard's very early stories is the exuberantly inventive outer space fantasy, "Passport to Eternity" (written c1955, published 1962). Ballard would never write anything this "science fictional" again, with the exception of "The Waiting Grounds". "Passport to Eternity" is part of a series of raucous comic satires that run through Ballard, culminating in "The Index" and "The Message from Mars" (1992).
"Passport to Eternity" anticipates Ballard's later novels, in which well-to-do characters indulge some taboo pathology as a kind of "entertainment". Those novels tend to be mainstream works set in contemporary times, rather than the science fiction of "Passport to Eternity". Both "Passport to Eternity" and the novels tend to have much about sexual indulgence.
Prima Belladonna. This period also saw "Prima Belladonna" (1956), the first of his Vermilion Sands short story series, set in a future resort town. All of these stories deal with some futuristic art form, and "Prima Belladonna starts this pattern by focusing on singing plants.
Both of the early tales, "Prima Belladonna" and "Passport to Eternity", are comic and intellectual in tone.
The characters in the Vermilion Sands stories show an intense interest in the arts, an interest that is both intellectual and burningly personal. This interest was widespread among intellectuals in the 1956-1970 period: the era in which the tales were first published. One can see this interest in the rapt attention of the people in the art galley in the film L'Avventura (Michelangelo Antonioni, 1960).
"Prima Belladonna" is set in the Recess, a ten-year period of reduced employment and thus enforced leisure. Many people instead devote their energies to the arts. This is a vision of a society where art is valued more than commerce, making money or economic development. Under its comic surface, this is a Utopian vision of a less materialistic society. The Vermilion Sands stories are how Ballard himself envisions the future, as he points out in the preface to the book. These stories don't preach or explicitly advocate such a less materialistic culture and society: but they show such attitudes in detail.
The Subliminal Man. The anti-materialist attitudes in "Prima Belladonna" can be contrasted with Ballard's nightmare tale of capitalist consumer society pushed to its ultimate in "The Subliminal Man", a tale that depicts work and consumption as evil forces that seize control of people's lives. "Prima Belladonna" and Vermilion Sands show the Utopia that can come about through anti-materialist society; "The Subliminal Man" depicts the Dystopia of materialism and the capitalist consumer good society.
Imagery at the end of "The Subliminal Man" recalls the climax of the film Il Grido (Michelangelo Antonioni, 1957). SPOILERS. Both have a man climbing up to a height on a structure, then falling to his death. Both have crowds of politically disturbed people below.
The Waiting Grounds. Ballard only published intermittently throughout the 1950's. His prolific period begins in force with "The Waiting Grounds" (1959), his first great work. Everything is immensely still in the early portions of this tale. Eventually, slight movement is introduced. It gradually accelerates, and eventually the landscape begins to revolve. The whole movement is one of the great triumphs of mise-en-scène in Ballard's work. Several later Ballard stories involve the vortex of a storm: the effect like the eye of a hurricane that sweeps through the forest in "The Illuminated Man", the tornado at the end of "The Cloud Sculptors of Coral D".
"The Waiting Grounds" seems to be in the tradition of Arthur C. Clarke:
"The Waiting Grounds" involves a highly geometric construction. Geometry in Ballard:
"The Waiting Grounds" is also the first Ballard tale to introduce one of his complex landscapes. These elaborate environments are one of the best features of his work. They are intended to evoke states of mind.
Studio Five, The Stars. The landscape of "The Waiting Grounds" would essentially reappear in the Vermilion Sands series, starting with the second tale, "Studio Five, The Stars" (1961). This tale, with its elaborate description of Vermilion Sands, is in some ways the real start of the series.
"Studio Five, The Stars" deals with the use of computers to write poetry. While now outdated in some slight ways - the use of paper punch tape is now passé, although it is put to magnificently poetic use in the story - this is an amazingly prescient look at the future of computing. It is still one of the best and most realistic looks at artificial intelligence in science fiction.
The Last World of Mr. Goddard. Ballard wrote several stories in this period, in which the sf events of the tale allegorically depict the mental states of the protagonist. The best of these pieces is "The Last World of Mr. Goddard" (1960). This is a fantasy tale, depicting a man about to be retired.
The Voices of Time. Published the same month (October 1960) as "Goddard" is "The Voices of Time". The climax of Ballard's early fiction, it is Ballard's greatest story. It is exceptionally beautifully written, with a rich collection of imagery.
The way first plants, then the hero can perceive time, is an example of the ideas about time that run through Ballard. The crystallization in "The Illuminated Man" and The Crystal World is based on overlapping time images. Ballard ingeniously describes the same process in reverse in "The Atrocity Exhibition", where real-life images are discussed as if they were examples of the overlapping time photos in a Marey chronogram. Mathematicians frequently invoke both a function and its inverse function; the overlapping-in-time images of The Crystal World, and the reversal of this process in "The Atrocity Exhibition", are rigorous mathematical inverse functions of each other.
"The Voices of Time" has spinal imagery, with sea anemones evolving into developing a notochord: the evolutionary ancestor of the spine in vertebrates. "The Atrocity Exhibition" including the image of a trilobite, a primitive segmented animal from the ancient past, one whose segmentation reflects the segmentation that underlies the body plans of spinal creatures. The trilobite is linked to a photo of balconies on a hotel: likely also involving repeated architectural segments in a row, like the repeated segments of a trilobite.
"The Voices of Time" ends with the hero experiencing a vision involving time in outer space. "The Waiting Grounds" also concludes with a penultimate vision; both stories have epilogues that wrap things up after the vision ends. These visions have something of the feel of a mystic vision: they reveal to the hero cosmic forces shaping the universe. But neither is in fact mystic: both visions use a mechanism based in science rather than mysticism, such as the time perception in "The Voices of Time". And both show a scientific cosmos, rather than a religious revelation.
The vision in "The Voices of Time" is linked to cosmic sources in far outer space. In this it anticipates the sources of the crystallization in similar outer space regions in "The Illuminated Man" and The Crystal World.
"The Voices of Time" is filled with strange plants and animals, evolved from and different from the familiar plants and animals of today's world. These are perhaps linked to the "biomorphic" abstraction in Surrealist painting. Surrealist abstract paintings like Max Ernst's The Eye of Silence (1944) show patterns built up out of forms and shapes that might be found in human or animal bodies. They are "biomorphic", coming from Greek words "bio" meaning "life" and "morph" meaning "form": paintings based on "life forms", the shapes of body parts. Ballard choose The Eye of Silence to be reproduced on the book jacket of Ballard's novel The Crystal World. Ballard is an outspoken admirer ofd Surrealism. "The Voices of Time" explicitly evokes Surrealism in its description of the evolved animals and plants.
The evolved, surreal animals living in their vivariums in "The Voices of Time", recall the evolved, surreal orchids in their vivariums in "Prima Belladonna". All of these organisms have startling new properties, ones that be called "cognitive": they relate to how these beings think, perceive and communicate. However, the tone of "Prima Belladonna" is comic and cheerful, while that of "The Voices of Time" is nightmarish.
The mandala is a well-known symbol in several religious traditions. The one in "The Voices of Time" contains a large cross inside, lines reaching to the circular edge. This anticipates the crucifix that is so prominent in "The Illuminated Man". Christian symbolism runs through Ballard. His point of view seems to be Mainline Protestant: the minister in "The Illuminated Man" is Presbyterian, for example.
The Cloud Sculptors of Coral D. Also very beautiful is "The Cloud Sculptors of Coral D" (1967). This piece has some of Ballard's best allegory, in the scene where the hero and heroine lay down in cracks of a giant mirror. This is allegory worthy of Hawthorne. Ballard is very sensitive to postures: see the Preface to Vermilion Sands, and the finale of "The Atrocity Exhibition" (1966), which concludes when the hero assumes a final posture - a sublimely imagined end. We are used to reading stories whose climax is some colossal event; this tale suggests we should look at the most intimate parts of our personal experience. In all these stories, the posture is "lying down". This is preparatory to sleep, in human life, and reminds one of the onset of sleep at the end of "The Voices of Time".
The Wind From Nowhere. Ballard has all but disowned his first novel, The Wind From Nowhere (1961), often no longer including it in lists of his published books. Written in two weeks of vacation from his job, it is very atypical of his work of the period. Unlike them, it is written in a plain prose style, and has little poetic imagery. I found it impossible to read years ago. However, after reading Empire of the Sun (1984), I went back to it, and found it surprisingly interesting. Like Empire, it has a war, or at least a military logistics background. It shows a side of Ballard that would not emerge into the rest of his work till twenty years later. The novel eventually turns into an absorbing adventure story.
The Drought. The Drought (1964) has the best architecture of Ballard's early novels. The first half shows a journey toward a goal (in this case, the sea); the second half takes place some years later, and shows the journey back. Along the way, the characters and places of the first half return, and their fates are revealed. Ballard used an identical architecture for Empire of the Sun. This later novel draws on the architecture of The Drought, and the subject matter of The Wind From Nowhere.
"The Trouble with Tycho" shares story elements with the earlier short tale "Mirage" (1950). "Mirage" investigates mysterious life on Mars, and shares some concepts with "The Trouble with Tycho". "The Trouble with Tycho" also reflects "Hermit of Mars" (1939), with the hunters of "Hermit of Mars" anticipating the prospectors on the Moon in "The Trouble with Tycho", similar mysterious creatures around, and a trip to a remote part of the alien landscape. A much poorer story, "Mr. Meek Plays Polo" (1944), also has an ancestral element, with its "radiation moss" gathered on rocks in the Inner Ring of Saturn anticipating the equally health-giving lichen on the Moon in "The Trouble with Tycho".
Way Station is also an impressive look at non-standard sexuality. It forms a plea for tolerance for those who are sexually "different". This centers on the treatment of the Vegan characters.
"The Thing in the Stone" (1970) resembles Way Station, in starring an isolated but educated man, living alone in rural Wisconsin, but who is in touch with aliens. It also has time travel elements, that recall "Project Mastodon".
"Honorable Opponent" (1956) also reflects Cold War tensions. It moves to a comic solution that is a bit of a wish fulfillment, but which is also clever as plotting.
"Project Mastodon" (1955) is unpleasant, when time travel is envisioned as a method for providing weapons for the Cold War. Such militarism is in contrast to the Cold War solutions offered in other Simak.
"Buckets of Diamonds" (1969) is another tale in the same mode as "The Big Front Yard". Transportation goes to the future in it. It also has some interesting ideas about both technology's role in life, and the possibilities of language. This light-hearted tale has some satire about the Cold War, recalling "Galactic Chest".
"How-2" (1954) is another look at the ideas of "Skirmish", but with non-violent solutions, this time in the courts. "How-2" was published a few months after the landmark US Supreme Court decision "Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka" (1954), which ordered the desegregation of US schools. Such legal approaches to integration were highly topical.
While comic, both "How-2" and "Skirmish" have a disturbing edge. One is uncomfortable about the machine imagery, which Simak develops with an uninhibited relish. One suspects that "How-2" might have influenced John Sladek's The Reproductive System (1968).
"Horrible Example" (1961) is a short but delightful tale, that builds on ideas in "All the Traps of Earth".
Both tales are constructed as science fiction mysteries: what is going on with the mysterious planet? Just as in a regular mystery, there are clues, investigation, and a solution to the mystery at the end of the story. Simak makes this explicit in "Limiting Factor". The characters are discussing the strange planetary system:
A similar mystery planet turns up in "Jackpot" (1956), but this tale is perfunctory.
"Worlds Without End" (1956) combines the spy thriller form, with science fiction. It has a bit of mystery, elements which are eventually explained. Simak has fun, coming up with science fictional versions of spy thriller paradigms, such as loyalty to dueling countries, or different teams of supporters (they include robots here). Such science fictional variants of modern day institutions, remind readers that human society is going to change: a key theme of science fiction. Way Station also opens with spy fiction elements, but they play less of a role as the tale progresses.
"Worlds Without End" continues Simak's interest in computer-aided writing. The two story-creators in the tale, George and Herb, echo the zany pair of Hollywood scriptwriters in the 1930's satirical play and film Boy Meets Girl, co-written by Samuel Spewack.
"Earth for Inspiration" (1941) is an early look by Simak, at "science fiction writing within an sf story". It does not deal with computer-aided writing. But it is a lively, inventive tale. It also deals with robots, and Earth's future history, elements that would soon be part of Simak's City. "Earth for Inspiration" was reprinted in Sam Moskowitz's anthology The Coming of the Robots (1963).
A non-science fiction look by Simak at the value of the press is found in his Western short story "Trail City's Hot-Lead Crusaders" (1944). The crusaders of the title, are newspapermen who stand up to corrupt town bosses in the old West. Simak was a newspaperman all his life, and this tale speaks to his convictions on the subject. "Trail City's Hot-Lead Crusaders" is in the anthology Westerns of the 40's: Classics from the Great Pulps (1977), edited by Damon Knight (also reprinted as 7 Westerns of the 40's: Classics from the Great Pulps). I was impressed by "Trail City's Hot-Lead Crusaders" decades ago. but a recent rereading suggests it is a fairly conventional Western tale, less creative than Simak's sf.
Way Station looks at an alien artform: works which blend abstract color images and a film-like experience. Such works recall the real-life "color music" or "abstract" films, long created by experimental animators. Simak's treatment is enthusiastic. It perhaps reflects the intense interest in avant-garde art, literature and film amnion educated people in the 1960's.
By contrast, I didn't like two Simak short stories about painters, "The Spaceman's Van Gogh" (1956), and the award-winning "Grotto of the Dancing Deer" (1980). Both seem static as story-telling, and uninteresting in their treatment of art. Both deal with solitary painters who have lived isolated lives. Both have a hero who tracks down the artist's work. Both have him finding an example of the painting, in a small, somewhat claustrophobic underground cave or burrow.
"The Civilization Game" (1958) returns to a subplot from Ring Around the Sun: humans deliberately leading archaic lifestyles. In "The Civilization Game" this is given more of a meaning and a serious purpose, in an attempt to preserve traditions that otherwise would be lost. It's a interesting idea, but one of which Simak seems to have generally negative feelings. The traditions include the arts, and also various political activities. "The Civilization Game" is one of several Simak works that suggest "bad" human traits, such as swindling and dirty dealing, might have hidden merit or survival value for humanity.
"Ogre" (1944) is a novella about an alien planet where music is composed, among other things. The tale embraces some dreadful moral and political ideas at the end: it seems to be written by Simak's Evil Twin. Probably the worst Simak story ever. Nellie the robot, does show that highly individualized robots were already part of Simak's fiction at this early date. The story appeared in January 1944, shortly before the debut of Simak's City series. Like a number of Simak's early works for John W. Campbell, it shows frighteningly powerful aliens in conflict with humans visiting their planets: see "Masquerade" (1941), "Tools" (1942), "Hunch" (1943), the last of which shares the moral failings of "Ogre". "Masquerade" has aliens on Mercury taking up human music and dancing through mimicry. These tales tend to be grim.
Both "Full Cycle" (1955) and "So Bright the Vision" are full scale sociological looks at future human societies. "Full Cycle" draws on sf premises Simak previously explored in City.
Simak would go on to look at multiple universes and their interaction in Cosmic Engineers (1939). This too is a pretty mild story, as a reading experience.
Way Station contains an approach that will recur in other Simak tales: the idea that in the future, scientific discoveries might give a factual, scientific basis to specific religious concepts. Such a development might increase spirituality and spiritual practice. But it also might change or transform the way people today view religion. It would thus be a two-edged sword. In science fiction, the future has the potential to transform everything. In Simak stories, the future can affect religion too.
Simak never became a big best-seller, or a household name celebrity. Almost all of Simak's readers were people who were interested in sf as a whole, from pulp fans in the 30's to academic specialists in sf in the 70's. He was rarely described as "transcending the genre". He was never taken up by mainstream literary critics who didn't read much sf. One guesses that he was completely unknown to most people who didn't read sf - and widely admired by those that did.
Simak's work has trenchant, far reaching sf concepts. It also has values that endear it to readers who believe sf should be literary, such as characterization, lyrical writing about nature, and a concern for human beings. Because of this, Simak was endorsed by many different schools of sf fandom, and kinds of literary taste.
Simak wrote a large number of short stories and novellas. The novellas are especially good. The novellas are concentrated in three key collections: So Bright the Vision, Skirmish, and Worlds Without End. These novellas offer much that can enhance Simak's reputation.
These are my personal picks and favorites, films I saw and like.
Please see also the science fiction and fantasy sections of my list of Best TV Shows. And my list of best Science Fiction TV Commercials.
Informative books on Science Fiction films:
Science Fiction, General:
Dystopia and Warnings about the Future:
Science Fiction Adventure:
Science Fiction Comedies:
Whimsy and Movement: Worlds of Animated Objects
The Future (works that show a future period, but without much science fiction):
Fantasy (often by artistically prestigious directors):
High-Brow Films that use Time Travel:
High-Brow Films that Visualize Dreams, Fantasies or Literary Works:
Film Noir Crime Films with Dream Sequences:
Fantasy Comedies, often about Magical Beings:
Strange Depiction of Life or Society (borderline fantasy):
Science or technology in contemporary or historical settings:
Medicine, Medical Research and Public Health:
Industry and Labor:
Environmental Dramas and Mysteries:
Global Warming (see also my list of recommended documentaries):
Anthropology, Collectors and Information Gatherers:
Under the City:
Mysteries about Strange Animals:
Trains (see also Railroad Crime Fiction):
Semi-documentary films are mainly crime films, that combine a fictional story about the Government hunting crooks, with documentary aspects. They typically depict 1) an elite Government team or agency 2) advanced technology used by the team or by the crooks 3) a big finale set in some spectacular industrial or technological area.
|Radio Patrol||Edward L. Cahn||1932||City Police||Radio Cars||Stockyard|
|They All Come Out||Jacques Tourneur||1939||US Federal Prisons||Medicine, Machinery||Machine Shop|
|Crime Does Not Pay:
Know Your Money
|Joseph M. Newman||1940||Treasury: Secret Service||Lab, Dictaphone|
|Crime Does Not Pay:
Respect the Law
|Joseph M. Newman||1941||Doctors, police, city officials||Plague suits||Isolation ward|
|The House on 92nd Street||Henry Hathaway||1945||FBI||Radio|
|Kiss of Death||Henry Hathaway||1947|
|T-Men||Anthony Mann||1947||Treasury: Secret Service||Counterfeiting, Lab analysis||Ship|
|He Walked By Night||Anthony Mann||1948||LAPD||Ballistics, Identikit,
Radio, Hollerith machines
|LA Storm Sewers|
|Call Northside 777||Henry Hathaway||1948||Reporter||Photo transmit by wire|
|The Street With No Name||William Keighley||1948||FBI||Heliograph, Communications,
|The Naked City||Jules Dassin||1948||NYPD||Williamsburg Bridge|
|Canon City||Craig Wilbur||1948||Colorado State Penitentiary||Funicular|
|Berlin Express||Jacques Tourneur||1948||Allied Occupation in Germany||Agriculture, Train||Brewery|
|White Heat||Raoul Walsh||1949||Treasury||Tracking Devices||Oil Tanks|
|Homicide||Felix Jacoves||1949||LAPD||Wires for Bookmaking, Lab Analysis|
|The Undercover Man||Joseph H. Lewis||1949||Treasury: IRS||Photo blowup|
|Follow Me Quietly||Richard Fleischer||1949||Police||Profiling, Dummy||Waterworks|
|Trapped||Richard Fleischer||1949||Treasury: Secret Service||L.A. Trolley Barn|
|Slattery's Hurricane||Andre de Toth||1949||US Weather Bureau||Planes||Hurricane, Control Tower|
|Panic in the Streets||Elia Kazan||1950||Centers for Disease Control||Epidemiology||New Orleans Docks|
|Mystery Street||John Sturges||1950||Barnstable Police||Pathology||Trinity Station|
|Armored Car Robbery||Richard Fleischer||1950||LAPD||Airport|
|Side Street||Anthony Mann||1950||NYPD||Radio, Pathology||Wall Street|
|A Lady Without Passport||Joseph H. Lewis||1950||Treasury: IRS||Planes||Everglades|
|711 Ocean Drive||Joseph M. Newman||1950||Wires for Bookmaking||Boulder Dam|
|The Tattooed Stranger||Edward Montagne||1950||NYPD||Botany, Ballistics||Monuments workshop|
|I Was a Communist
for the FBI
|Gordon Douglas||1951||FBI||Listening Devices||Pittsburgh Rail Bridge|
|On Dangerous Ground||Nicholas Ray||1951||LAPD|
|Red Skies of Montana||Joseph M. Newman||1952||US Forestry Service||Fire Fighting, Parachutes|
|Diplomatic Courier||Henry Hathaway||1952||US State Department||Coded teletype|
|Code Two||Fred M. Wilcox||1953||LAPD||Motorcycles||Chemical Pool|
|99 River Street||Phil Karlson||1953||Taxi drivers||Taxi Radio||Jersey City Docks|
|Crime Wave||Andre de Toth||1954||LAPD||Glendale Bank Robbery|
|Them!||Gordon Douglas||1954||LAPD, FBI,
|Entomology||LA Storm Sewers|
|The Scarlet Coat||John Sturges||1955||US Secret Service||Secret messages|
|Death in Small Doses||Joseph M. Newman||1957||Food and Drug Administration||Amphetamines, Trucks|
|The Lineup||Don Siegel||1958||San Francisco Police||Police Lab||Unfinished Freeway|
|The FBI Story||Mervyn LeRoy||1959||FBI||FBI Lab, Paint Samples|
The Hiding Place
|Joseph H. Lewis||1959||LAPD-like Police||Radio Phones, Police Sketches,
|Diagnosis: Unknown||Various: TV show||1960||Forensic Scientists||Pathology Lab|
|The Police Dog Story||Edward L. Cahn||1961||Canine Police||Animal Psychology||Warehouse|
Crime Films shot on location, with documentary features:
Please see my: